stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal







Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is
Legal

Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is
Legal
04/09/2004 06:37 PM

This case may turn out to be a lot more important than people realize, but a judge has ruled that an aggregator of information on boat sales did not infringe the copyrights of a site they scraped for information. The judge pointed out that the aggregator only took factual info (which is not copyrightable) and the images it took weren't actually the property of the site, but those who uploaded them. This does leave open the possibility that those users could sue, but considering the fact that they're trying to sell their boats, they probably appreciate the wider exposure. Of course, all of this might not matter if Congress passes a law allowin g companies to copyright databases.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal

Grok Headline matches for Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal

Calif. Judge Cuts Microsoft Legal Fees


Calif. Judge Cuts Microsoft Legal Fees 09/17/2004 01:00 AM
Boston Globe Sep 17 2004 4:39AM GMT

Judge Cuts Legal Fees in Microsoft Suit


Judge Cuts Legal Fees in Microsoft Suit 09/18/2004 01:34 AM
NewsFactor Network Sep 18 2004 5:23AM GMT

The Difference Between Online Content
And Broadcast Content


The Difference Between Online Content
And Broadcast Content
02/10/2004 02:46 PM
Major League Baseball made news last year for claim ing to own all in-progress game data - saying they were going to go after websites that reported what was happening at a game in real-time. It didn't matter that the law is pretty clear that you can't copyright facts - MLB believes that just presenting the data is a "rebroadcast" of the game. That said, I guess it's no surprise to hear that they now believe that web audio and video broadcasts of games should work the same way as television broadcasts with a content provider paying a huge upfront fee for the rights to the games, and then telling them they can make it back in ad revenue and subscription fees. Of course, the various internet sites they've approached with this plan have been laughing them out the door, and pointing out that they're not television stations, and they just want to provide something useful to their users - but aren't going to lose money to do so. While MLB has been at the forefront of offering streaming video and audio, it appears they still look on this as a broadcast medium, and not the interactive medium it actually is. They're doing their best to squeeze more money out of existing fans, rather than attract new fans, which is dangerous for the future of the sport. Not only do you anger your biggest fans, you also make it less likely that you're going to pick up new fans.

Judge Cuts Legal Fees in Microsoft
Class-Action Suit


Judge Cuts Legal Fees in Microsoft
Class-Action Suit
09/18/2004 04:07 AM
Enterprise Windows I.T. Sep 18 2004 7:18AM GMT

BAD DAY IN COURT FOR BARBRA: STREISAND
PRIVACY CASE REJECTED BY JUDGE; PHOTO
IMAGES OF HOUSE NOT VIOLATION, MUST PAY
LEGAL FEES


BAD DAY IN COURT FOR BARBRA: STREISAND
PRIVACY CASE REJECTED BY JUDGE; PHOTO
IMAGES OF HOUSE NOT VIOLATION, MUST PAY
LEGAL FEES
12/04/2003 08:26 AM
Looky, see this picture .. the smoking gun .. justice

thesmokinggun.com/archive/babshouse1.html
track this site | 6 links


"BAD DAY IN COURT FOR BARBRA: STREISAND
PRIVACY CASE REJECTED BY JUDGE; PHOTO
IMAGES OF HOUSE NOT VIOLATION , MUST PAY
LEGAL FEES..."


"BAD DAY IN COURT FOR BARBRA: STREISAND
PRIVACY CASE REJECTED BY JUDGE; PHOTO
IMAGES OF HOUSE NOT VIOLATION , MUST PAY
LEGAL FEES..."
12/05/2003 03:19 AM

Aggregating Education


Aggregating Education 03/11/2003 10:45 AM

I know it seems like I'm only talking about RSS these days, but that's because 1) it's beginning to hit a critical mass, 2) I very much believe libraries need to be part of this (if not leading it), and 3) it's on my mind because of my upcoming presentation with Steven Cohen on this topic.

However, it's not just me. Ken Tompkins is thinking about aggregators, too, and he's doing me one better by actually creating some. For his campus, he's currently aggregating NY Times and BBC feeds in one aggregator, Manila sites in a second aggregator, and the feeds from both aggregators into one "meta-aggregator." Ken writes:

"I have just begun to consider rss in college literature teaching.... We have a Frontier server and, of course, I know about the aggregator in both Manila and Radio.

So, I've worked out a way to aggregate our student Manila sites or, at least, the best ones as well as provide a way to aggregate news of interest to Arts & Humanities students....

These are very modest and display nothing important. I just got them working today. They need formatting and a swipe at css. For me, what is important, is that I now have a technique for aggregating sites of any flavor -- faculty, student, major, etc -- and can easily set faculty to creating similar sites for their departments."

Very impressive, Ken! This is another good experiment to watch. Is it my imagination or is education becoming an epicenter of RSS activity? Certainly more than at the BigPubs these days.

Ken describes a setup similar to what I want for Illinois libraries. For our "News Exchange Web Service" (NEWS) grant project, we're going to get four of the twelve Illinois Library Systems blogging with accompanying RSS feeds. We'll also provide individual and group aggregation inter- and intra-System, thereby creating a knowledge exchange system of unparalleled potential for communication. And that's just for starters.

Side note of personal opinion: the new Illinois Library Systems home page should be a blog with an RSS feed!


SyberWorks Chosen by CustomerCentric
Systems LLC to Develop Online Content
and Host Their CustomerCentric Selling®
Sales Training Program Online


SyberWorks Chosen by CustomerCentric
Systems LLC to Develop Online Content
and Host Their CustomerCentric Selling®
Sales Training Program Online
03/22/2005 03:16 PM
SyberWorks, a leader in custom e-Learning Solutions and the Learning Management System industry, announced today they have been selected by CustomerCentric Systems LLC, a nationally recognized leader in sales process training and consulting, to develop online content and host their CustomerCentric Selling® Sales Training Program online with the SyberWorks Hosted e-Learning Solution. [PRWEB Mar 22, 2005]

Google Tests Aggregating Hotspot
Directories


Google Tests Aggregating Hotspot
Directories
02/18/2004 01:17 PM
Google Lab's new Search by Location service lets you aggregate results for hotspots: This is nifty idea which aggregates the address information that Google is parsing from its results (any time it sees anything that looks like an address) and tying it to keywords. It's particularly useful for Wi-Fi aggregation, because you're finding locations that not only my business partner JiWire lists or libraries that Bill Drew has assembled, but you're seeing even individual locations like coffeeshops that mention they have Wi-Fi, community wireless pages, and other randomly related content. I've pumped in my office Zip code in the link above, but try other combinations. Note that JiWire's listings are prominent because of how they structured their site. As a group of former Cnet.com'ers, they know that if you expose URLs that are permanent and look like "good" URLs (not full of argument junk after a question mark) then search engines will well index their hierarchy. This is hardly a secret, but many sites still haven't discovered it. [link via Jim Thompson, Doc Searls]...

New News Aggregating Site On the Horizon
-- Topix


New News Aggregating Site On the Horizon
-- Topix
01/16/2004 11:01 AM
I rarely get site announcements describing the site as a "News Site of Doom," but what the hey. After viewing it, I'll give it props as a news site of...

Aggregating Mail Lists, Sorting by Topic


Aggregating Mail Lists, Sorting by Topic 05/12/2004 06:54 PM

The disintegration of e-mail under the corrosive effects of spam has led many people, including me, to assume that mail lists are next to useless as ways to get information out to people. After all, spam filters trap lots of legitimate mail, and who has time to subscribe to and then read all the junk that comes in on various lists, however useful they might be. Zack Rosen just showed me a new project he and Neil Drumm have been working on, and I'm impressed. It's called Progressive Pipes, and it aggregates a bunch of progressive and left-leaning lists into an easy-to-peruse collection of "headlines," namely the subject lines. (Rosen and Drumm both developed technology for the Howard Dean presidential campaign and are now working to bring collaborative tools to a wider activist community.) Progressive Pipes breaks the messages down in several ways, including list names and topics. Among the latter, for example, are "Beat Bush" and "Civil Liberties" among others. Even better, you can subscribe to the site and its sub-categories as RSS feeds. While this is a targeted site -- aimed at one side of the political spectrum -- there's no reason that such an application couldn't be done for any kind of mailing list on any kind of topic. This is clever, and useful.


Legal Documents Will Go Online


Legal Documents Will Go Online 03/14/2005 04:49 PM
Times.hankooki.com - Mon Mar 14, 10:42 am GMT

Judge Won't Reinstate Online Pharmacy


Judge Won't Reinstate Online Pharmacy 11/11/2003 01:20 AM
AP via Los Angeles Times Nov 11 2003 0:22AM ET

Gaming companies want legal online bets


Gaming companies want legal online bets 06/28/2004 09:45 PM
Article.wn.com - Mon Jun 28, 06:38 am GMT

Free Online Legal Service Launched (AP)


Free Online Legal Service Launched (AP) 08/27/2004 01:26 PM
AP - A nonprofit that helps the poor with legal services launched a free Web site Friday to help people navigate the state and federal courts in California.

Free Online Legal Service Launched


Free Online Legal Service Launched 08/29/2004 07:25 AM
Telegram.com - Sun Aug 29, 03:14 am GMT

Judge tosses online privacy case


Judge tosses online privacy case 06/16/2004 08:20 AM
ZDNet Jun 16 2004 12:42PM GMT

Will Online Gaming's Addictive Marketing
Get Them In Legal Trouble?


Will Online Gaming's Addictive Marketing
Get Them In Legal Trouble?
06/28/2004 05:22 AM
For years, people have described how online multi-player games like EverQuest were addicti ve, and the industry loved it. In fact, many started using the phrase in their own marketing materials. Now, however, some are wondering if the self-proclaimed addictive labels are going to come back to haunt online video game makers when lawyers come along to blame them for just about any crime associated with the game. Already there's been talk about blaming such games for suicides and for child neglect -- and calling the game "addictive" in the marketing probably won't help the game makers' side of the story in front of a jury.

Ordering liquor online sets off legal
challenges


Ordering liquor online sets off legal
challenges
06/10/2004 04:50 AM
Usatoday.com - Thu Jun 10, 08:30 am GMT

Napster reborn as legal music online
service


Napster reborn as legal music online
service
09/18/2004 07:25 AM
Hamiltonspectator.com - Sat Sep 18, 06:41 am GMT

Stewart's Letter to the Judge Shows Up
Online, in Two Versions


Stewart's Letter to the Judge Shows Up
Online, in Two Versions
07/19/2004 01:17 AM
New York Times Jul 19 2004 5:47AM GMT

Federal judge tosses Pennsylvania online
porn law


Federal judge tosses Pennsylvania online
porn law
09/10/2004 12:44 PM
SiliconValley.com Sep 10 2004 4:27PM GMT

Accuser asks judge to stop online
postings


Accuser asks judge to stop online
postings
07/20/2004 06:00 AM
Kentucky.com - Tue Jul 20, 07:48 am GMT

Profiting from free, online content


Profiting from free, online content 07/15/2004 06:50 PM
There isn't a compelling business argument today that would suggest that giving away our content is a good idea. (more) What tangible benefit does the New York Times get in return for being a world news library to us? It's neat to be revered by all as a repository of information, but without a visible associated profit, I can certainly understand why it could be rejected by higher-ups. In the interests of simplifying things, I'm going to make a gross generalization of this and call it: "How do I make money while giving everything away for free?": Advertising The scourge of optic nerves everywhere can still be useful when done tactfully. Loud, garish ads can send people into seizures, drive people to distraction, inspire thousands to write code to block them — all for the sake of making a...

TiVo steps into online content


TiVo steps into online content 06/09/2004 12:00 PM

Tom Online adds mobile content


Tom Online adds mobile content 08/12/2004 05:44 AM
Technology.scmp.com - Thu Aug 12, 08:29 am GMT

Ordering liquor online sets off legal
challenges (USATODAY.com)


Ordering liquor online sets off legal
challenges (USATODAY.com)
06/10/2004 06:23 AM
USATODAY.com - Zack Vines came home from high school one day last October, logged on to his computer and, with a few clicks of a mouse, ordered liquor from several different online sites. He isn't sure which site ultimately came through, but a week later, a gallon of tequila - wrapped in a plain, brown package with no return address - was delivered to the Vines home in Franklin, Mich.

Pfizer Brings Legal Barrage Against
Online 'Viagra' Sales


Pfizer Brings Legal Barrage Against
Online 'Viagra' Sales
08/04/2004 06:41 AM
Ecommercetimes.com - Wed Aug 4, 03:48 am GMT

Guardian Unlimited | Online | Spam gangs
exploit UK legal loophole


Guardian Unlimited | Online | Spam gangs
exploit UK legal loophole
06/14/2004 06:51 AM
I do not what the UK to become the next spammers .. guardian .. Quote:

guardian.co.uk/online/news/0,12597,1237103,00.html
track this site | 3 links


Providing paid online content is
RealNetworks' new gig


Providing paid online content is
RealNetworks' new gig
08/27/2004 01:31 PM
SiliconValley.com Aug 26 2004 6:29PM GMT

EBU makes Olympic video content
available online


EBU makes Olympic video content
available online
08/20/2004 06:35 AM
Indiantelevision.com - Fri Aug 20, 10:38 am GMT

AP Says Its Time To Charge Partners For
Online Content


AP Says Its Time To Charge Partners For
Online Content
04/18/2005 11:29 PM
This probably doesn't come as a shock to many, but at its annual meeting today, the Associated Press announced that it would begin charging newspapers and broadcasters to post its content online starting in 2006. Currently, licensees of AP content are allowed take content they've licensed for print and repurpose it for online at no additional charge. Clearly, the AP is trying to evolve itself to meet the shifting media consumption of the average user, from trying to charg e Google News for AP content to offering charg ing several different versions of an AP story. With its new "eAP" platform, licensees will be able to access news via a searchable database, complete with tags. However, the question remains, will the current licensees see the benefit to paying for the same exact commodity content? The Associated Press is making the bet that online is now part of its affiliates' long term strategy. Feeling the pinch in their classified and advertising revenues, newspapers are scrambling to invest in the web. The AP realizes that it has been giving away too much for too little. Couple with the fact that the AP is starting to build its own online presence, and the AP can hope for two endgame scenarios. Scenario one is that the affiliates find an adequate return in licensing AP content; in this case, the AP is able to extend its current model to the online medium. Scenario two is that most licensees cannot justify paying for the commodity content, and only a few larger trafficked sites decide to take on the expense. In that case, the AP has its own ad-supported news site, which could end up being the one main source for AP content -- but it could also lose out on content from members who are upset at the higher fees. Either way, we're witnessing the latest experiment in how the traditional press makes its way into the internet world.

Checks on Online Games Content to Be
Intensified


Checks on Online Games Content to Be
Intensified
06/05/2005 11:16 PM
Article.wn.com - Thu Jun 2, 01:36 pm GMT

Spending on online content reached $1.8
bln in 2004, up 14%


Spending on online content reached $1.8
bln in 2004, up 14%
03/27/2005 02:33 AM
ZDNet Mar 27 2005 5:55AM GMT

Another Lawsuit hits eBay as the Giant
Online Auctioneer’s Legal woes mount


Another Lawsuit hits eBay as the Giant
Online Auctioneer’s Legal woes mount
06/18/2004 03:10 AM
eBay Inc. the online behemoth based in San Jose, CA is being sued by RAM Systems, Inc for fraudulent suspension of its account and eBay store. [PRWEB Jun 18, 2004]

Why Charging For Newspaper Content
Online Doesn't Make Sense


Why Charging For Newspaper Content
Online Doesn't Make Sense
11/07/2003 04:16 AM
One of the arguments that shows up here repeatedly is on the backwardness of local newspapers charging for online content. There are a number of reasons why it's a bad idea - from the level of taking yourself out of the online discussion and believing that walled garden content can survive to misunderstanding the very basic economics of the internet. Still, many newspapers are trying to do so, and some even believe that it's going well. Along comes Vin Crosbie, who knows both the newspaper business and the online content world, to smack a little sense into them. The Albuquerque Journal explained why they thought they were brilliant for creating a "successful" operation charging for their online content, and Crosbie picks apart the argument, bit by bit, and explains how they're actually losing money on this plan - and how all their other examples of newspapers charging for online content are bad (or irrelevant) examples. If you're interested in the economics of online content, it's worth a read.

Young Men Like Online Games and Video
Content More Than Sports


Young Men Like Online Games and Video
Content More Than Sports
06/18/2004 08:37 PM
Mediapost.com - Fri Jun 18, 04:00 pm GMT

ROO Group, Inc. Completes Purchase Of
Online Music Content ...


ROO Group, Inc. Completes Purchase Of
Online Music Content ...
06/01/2004 06:37 PM
Business Wire (press release),CA-3 hours ago ... Its clients include Telstra Corporation, AAP and Coca Cola, and its distribution partners include Google, VH1, Nova, Artist Direct and News Now. ...

Taking A Tiered Approach To Fee-Based
Content Online


Taking A Tiered Approach To Fee-Based
Content Online
10/30/2003 11:46 PM
Mark Glaser's latest piece at OJR looks at the plans to charge for the online content at canada.com, with a focus on how the pay system will work on tiers. The basic level of news access will be free, but columnists and opinion pieces get shifted up to tier 2 - which requires a subscription to a CanWest newspaper. Tier 3 offers a PDF version of the newspaper, mainly targeted at out of towners who want to get the paper. Tier 4 is their "holy grail" - where they'll add in extra multimedia content. It'll be an interesting experiment, but so far, most (but certainly not all) attempts at charging for online newspaper content has failed miserably. The problem is that you're competing against tons of free content that is often considered as good, if not better. You have to really offer something different, that can't be found elsewhere, and which people place a value on. The Wall Street Journal has been able to do that. Most news organizations, though, can't get that sort of buy-in. There are also pretty big risks in taking this route. Page views drop precipitously - so if you don't get back the lost ad revenue in subscription fees, you're actually worse off. You also have to realize that there are additional costs associated with billing, customer support, and maintaining subscriptions (partly offset by lower bandwidth fees). There's also the larger question of blocking your content off from the world. What makes content increasingly valuable these days is the links between it and other content. That is, after all, what makes the web what it is. Blocking up your content behind a paid wall like that cuts you out of that process, for the most part. Depending on what they're trying to do, some sites may be able to get away with that, but the risks are pretty big. It makes it much more difficult for new people (customers) to discover you and realize you might be relevant to their lives. It also makes your overall content less valuable because there isn't any of the additional valuable discussions that often go on around good content.
Grok Description matches for Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal
GrokA matches for Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal

Judge Says Aggregating Content Online Is Legal

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

Bounce Out Blitz 1.0
Solitaire Till Dawn
1.3

Plone Installer 2.0
Photo to Movie 3.0.3
Lunar Colony 1.0.7
Norton AntiVirus 9.0
Nintendo Tops Japan
Videogame Sales

Al Gore Testifies to
9/11 Panel

Rose Stays Out in
Front, Woods
Recovers

Pope Presides at
Good Friday Amid
High Security

Powell Sees Signs of
Sunni-Shi'ite
Tactical Contact

Court lets cable off
the hook--for now

Yahoo's Semel gets
raise, stock

This Price War Has
EA Cheering

Impressions:
Soldner: Scret
WarsEli Shayotovich
goes hands up with
an upcoming PC
release frrom
Encore. Things

SBC Offered
Wi-Fi/DSL Router
before Qwest

Copyright Doesn't
Cover Whole Net:
U.S. Judge

Torre Agrees to a
3-Year Contract
Extension

PHP Class 'Drop Down
Menu' released

New Post to Global
Guerrillas

Tell Tale Weekly's
audiobooks

How hard is it to
put a book online,
legally?

Suddenly Camping
XML Hackers
Sex in Games and
Blogs

Anti-Phishing
Working Group
Meeting

More on Hunters and
Butchers

Security Alert:
Voluntary XSS

Safety Attributes
Safety of a
different kind

Afraid to Breath Out
Gone Fishing
Music Sales Up In
The US

AOL Installing More
Spyware/Adware

Why Our Choice Of
Language Prevents Us
From Debating The
Real Issues

Companies Understand
Themselves By
Powerpoint

Apple DMCA sends
iTunes DRM decryptor
offshore

failed to act
Emulex LPFC Linux
Driver

Pattern Brewery
NICIC
IRC Services
Klusters
USBAuth
Information Resource
Manager

Together at last...
A Corporate Site
with Cheek

A Chemical Love
Story

Vintage Year For New
WINE?

Longhorn's
Diminished
Expectations

what is grok?