stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS







David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS

David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS 04/09/2004 04:10 PM

David Stutz:  "Because of this, although I agree with many of Ray's observations, I disagree with his predicted outcome. Rather than becoming the basis for a powerful network driven by the commodity exchange of schematized XML data, WinFS is more likely to be just one more in a string of proprietary Microsoft extensibility mechanisms."

A very interesting essay.  Much depends upon whether you or not you believe developers will embrace this new platform "in the absence of commodity (replaceable) implementations". Indeed, one of the most significant (and voluminous) criticisms I received privately after writing my essay relates to the increasing version fragmentation of the Windows installed base itself - particularly between corporate and consumer PCs.  Regardless of a given platform innovation's merits, will or would ISVs take deep advantage of an OS innovation that will only reach a subset of the installed base for a very, very long time?  Or have we now transitioned to a world in which there is a sustainable advantage for redistributable commodity middleware versions of "good enough" solutions?  Although "Windows bundling" used to represent a surefire way to create a de facto systems-level standard e.g. MAPI, might new Windows innovations be ultimately less utilized/leveraged than commodity middleware, given the increasing fragmentation of the market?




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS

Grok Headline matches for David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS

The WinFS Files: Understanding WinFS by
Exploring the WinFS Type System


The WinFS Files: Understanding WinFS by
Exploring the WinFS Type System
07/17/2004 06:44 AM
This column explores the type system used when programming the WinFS platform. Sample code shows you how to work with the WinFS type system using the WinFS API.

WinFS Removal a Window of OpportunityThe
decision to axe WinFS from Longhorn
gives Microsoft the opportunity t


WinFS Removal a Window of OpportunityThe
decision to axe WinFS from Longhorn
gives Microsoft the opportunity t
09/19/2004 11:09 PM
eWeek Sep 20 2004 3:21AM GMT

The Linux Cookbook, 2nd Edition: Tips
and Techniques for Everyday Use by
Michael Stutz


The Linux Cookbook, 2nd Edition: Tips
and Techniques for Everyday Use by
Michael Stutz
03/14/2005 05:25 PM
A great reference for new Linux users who want quick tips for using various command-line features.

What? They cut WinFS??


What? They cut WinFS?? 04/14/2004 02:35 PM
Thanks, eldoen. There has been a great deal of hubub about what Jay Greene’s BusinessWeek article means for Longhorn, and WinFS in particular. I’ve been surprised by the general silence on MS blogs on this topic – which is perhaps an indication that I ought to be careful myself ;) But let me throw caution to the wind and get to the punch line: I, from my vantage as a Longhorn Evangelist, haven’t seen any changes that significantly impact anything we’ve said at PDC, or since, about the WinFX platform. You won't see me editing my slides, changing my talking points, or cutting back my demos, because the message about WinFX's capabilities hasn't changed.

rdf vs WinFS - Part I


rdf vs WinFS - Part I 06/09/2004 05:54 AM

I've been waiting for this battle to ensue.  I was struck with how rdf-like WinFS was.  Pure triples.

They've also elevated media, messages and people & groups -a s first order objects.  This shit is coolio.  No matter what you say - Longhorn is finely crafted, serious work.

Now Danny Ayers takes on Jon Udell on anumber of issues..... here we go.

rdf semweb winfs

Jon Udell is looking at Microsoft’s Longhorn and is skeptical about the benefits of WinFS. Apart from talking of lock-in, he essentially argues that the same kind of things can be achieved with the newer XML technologies, in particular XPath 2.0 and XQuery.

Jeremy Mazner < STRONG>responds to Jon’s comments. I was pleased to see that he suggests (as a response to the lock-in allegation) that the metadata of WinFS will be exposed, which should enable nice interop with RDF systems.

I remarked on the similarity between Microsoft’s WinFS and RDF the other day (I misinterpreted some bits, but was corrected in comments, if anything reinforcing the parallel). Reading Jeremy’s material is quite weird, because most of the time you could just replace ‘WinFS’ with ‘RDF’ and it fits perfectly. He talks of finding music files - an area where RDF technologies are already active, c.f. MusicBrainz. He also has a lovely event scenario that fits like a glove to RDFCalendar work.

There are folks from the open source community who see a need for a completely open alternative to Longhorn, for example parts of Leo’s “Semantic Desktop” plan maps nicely onto WinFS.

I don’t personally think Microsoft can sustain a lock-in against Semantic Web technologies, with XAML, WinFS or anything else, any more than IE gave them control of the current web. In fact, if you can get at the data, then WinFS will probably be just as good for the future web as any open alternative. Having both is even better.

One angle that I think SemWeb folks need to address is how RDF technologies are still useful when you have XQuery. I’ve had a long-running exchange over what RDF/OWL can offer with Dare Obasanjo. I’m not as familiar with XQuery as I should be, so I’ve not got very far.

Dare also comments on the Udell piece, pointing to three things that he sees as potential issues with WinFS: performance, security and sucky programming model. Parallel universe. In the FOAF world, the first and last have been highlighted recently with PHP support for RDF, and security has been a discussion point for a while.

Dare’s final point about the Jon/Jeremy exchange is: “He is asking why couldn’t WinFS be based on XML instead of being an object oriented database.“.
I’m not sure how OO you’d call WinFS, but whatever, I’d like a good answer to : why RDF and not XQuery + XML DB?

Although Jon holds the record for has in the past talkinged most about a semantic web without mentioning Semantic Web technologies, he lets it slip a little today - his Google search box is on the keywords “rdf semweb winfs

This post should make a good googlepot for that, so can somebody point to a good RDF vs. XQuery FAQ?

PS. I completely missed a second post from Jon Udell specifically on WinFS and semantics. He quotes a beaut from Dare:

Being that one could consider RDF as just a logical model layered on top of an XML document (e.g. RDF/XML) I find it hard to understand how viewing some XML document through RDF colored glasses buys one so much more understanding of the data.

Exactly because it gives you a logical layer!
XML on its own provides absolutely zero machine understanding of the data beyond a bunch of character strings. [Raw]

:-)


No WinFS for Longhorn


No WinFS for Longhorn 08/28/2004 09:33 AM
Microsoft did, indeed, cut WinFS from Longhorn (both client and server). At least Avalon is still in there.

No More WinFS in Longhorn


No More WinFS in Longhorn 05/14/2004 08:55 PM

Longhorn goes to pieces: WinFS is out of Longhorn. That's gotta hurt. They've been talking about this as the centerpiece of the release.

Advanced search features that Gates has termed the "Holy Grail" of Longhorn, the next major version of Windows, won't be fully in place until 2009, Bob Muglia, the senior vice president in charge of Windows server development, told CNET News.com.

The technology, called WinFS, is an add-on the Windows file system that Microsoft says will make it easier for users to find data such as documents, e-mail messages and multimedia files — no matter what their format — on local PCs and across the network.

Click here to comment on this entry


Microsoft Uncertain About WinFS for XP


Microsoft Uncertain About WinFS for XP 03/14/2005 04:04 PM
OK, I am going to surprise many of you out there and give Microsoft the benefit of the doubt regarding the statement that they are re-thinking the release of WinFS for XP. Why? Think about it? Redoing an OS with a whole new file system midstream? That is just borrowing trouble! Still, I would encourage them to make the move for Longhorn at least as NTFS is really getting old….

Direct and Related Links for 'Microsoft Uncertain About WinFS for XP'


longhorn loses WinFS


longhorn loses WinFS 05/14/2004 07:24 PM
perhaps microsoft will never actually get to Cairo

WinFS coming to Windows XP


WinFS coming to Windows XP 03/14/2005 04:52 PM
Originally planned to be part of Longhorn, delays caused WinFS to fall by the wayside. When it does get here, it will be available for Windows XP.

Tagging and WinFS in the Enterprise


Tagging and WinFS in the Enterprise 03/30/2005 09:00 PM

Tagging is useful at personal level for categorizing data of any size and type without the constrain of hierarchy.  While WinFS is more than this, adding tagging to traditional file system will deliver most of the benefits WinFS offers at the user experience level.

But IMHO the real power of tagging can be hatched only at the workgroup level.  This means introducing new ways (UI-wise) to expose and discover tags others use with the same level of ease as children learn new words.


PDC: WinFS and WinFX discussed


PDC: WinFS and WinFX discussed 10/29/2003 09:23 PM

Microsoft's New WinFS Gets the PDC Buzz


Microsoft's New WinFS Gets the PDC Buzz 10/29/2003 11:24 AM
Amid the 'firehose' of information coming at them about new tools and products at PDC, developers are talking about implications of search with the new WinFS system in Longhorn.

Good Article About WinFS


Good Article About WinFS 01/22/2004 02:26 AM

Code Name WinFS: Revolutionary File Storage System Lets Users Search and Manage Files Based on Content: Here's a really in-depth article that peeks behind the curtain at the upcoming WinFS in Longhorn (It's so in-depth, I don't even know what to quote.) This is going to be very cool, essentially separating files and folders — files don't reside in folders as much as they're assigned to them. They can be assigned to more than one, and can appear anywhere in the folder tree, even if you "slice" your taxonomy multiple ways.

Click here to comment on this entry


Longhorn, WinFS still just out of reach


Longhorn, WinFS still just out of reach 09/08/2004 05:34 AM
Last week, the press wires were all aglow over announcements about Longhorn, the next version of the Windows desktop operating system. There were two prongs to the news. First, Microsoft announced that really, definitely, it’s-a-done-deal, Longhorn will ship in 2006. Secondly, to make the ship date, Longhorn features would be cut - especially the much-heralded new file system, WinFS.

Video: WinFS Overview


Video: WinFS Overview 12/13/2003 10:29 AM

Microsoft won't ship WinFS with Longhorn


Microsoft won't ship WinFS with Longhorn 08/27/2004 05:20 PM
Microsoft today announced a significant change in plans for the next major release of Windows, code-named Longhorn. The new WinFS storage subsystem will not be part of it, as had been previously planned.

A Developer's Perspective on WinFS, part
2 of 2


A Developer's Perspective on WinFS, part
2 of 2
07/23/2004 07:42 PM
WinFS makes searching and manipulating WinFS objects very straightforward. Learn how to specify a very simple syntax for most cases, but also how the WinFS API supports a rich search syntax to perform complicated searches.

Highlights of the WinFS Data Access API


Highlights of the WinFS Data Access API 04/25/2004 08:34 PM
Mike Deem provides a quick look at the basic concepts of the WinFS data access API: objects based on schemas, powerful query support, and support for WinFS concepts such as relationships.

WinFS delayed even beyond Longhorn
Server


WinFS delayed even beyond Longhorn
Server
12/19/2004 03:46 PM
WinFS has been delayed again, possibly four or more years from now, as Server BP Bob Muglia says WinFS won't accompany Longhorn Server.

Questions about Longhorn, part 1: WinFS


Questions about Longhorn, part 1: WinFS 06/02/2004 01:38 PM
Over the next few days I want to explore a series of questions about the "pillars" of Longhorn -- WinFS, Avalon, and Indigo. Last fall, when this stuff was first announced, I reacted with an entry entitled Replace and Defend. I argued then that Longhorn reinvents quite a few wheels. Nobody can blame Microsoft for seeking new ways to keep customers locked into its Windows franchise. That's a business strategy that every rational player must pursue, in one way or another. In chapter 6 of Information Rules, entitled Managing Lock-In, Carl Shapiro and Hal Varian write:
The great fortunes of the information age lie in the hands of companies that have successfully established proprietary architectures that are used by a large installed base of locked-in customers. And many of the biggest headaches of the information age are visited upon companies that are locked into information systems that are inferior, orphaned, or monopolistically supplied.
There's no question that Longhorn aims for lock-in -- it has to. But what is the nature of the bargain that's being offered? What kinds of benefits will it yield? And what kinds of headaches will accompany those benefits? ...

MSDN TV: Highlights of the WinFS Data
Access API


MSDN TV: Highlights of the WinFS Data
Access API
04/22/2004 05:33 PM
Mike Deem provides a quick look at the basic concepts of the WinFS data access API: objects based on schemas, powerful query support and support for WinFS concepts such as relationships.

Microsoft says Longhorn to ship in 2006
without WinFS


Microsoft says Longhorn to ship in 2006
without WinFS
08/29/2004 12:08 PM
Microsoft is now targeting a second half of 2006 ship date for Longhorn. In order to make the date, WinFS will not be a part of the successor to Windows XP

WinOE Likely To Join Indigo, WinFS In
Longhorn


WinOE Likely To Join Indigo, WinFS In
Longhorn
05/14/2004 04:52 AM

Spotlight on the Longhorn SDK: WinFS
Schema Overview


Spotlight on the Longhorn SDK: WinFS
Schema Overview
05/24/2004 09:17 AM
In the WinHEC build of Longhorn the schema types that ship in the WinFS System.Storage namespace have changed since the PDC release. You can get an overview of these "everyday" types in the Longhorn SDK.

Longhorn to be Released in 2006, Sans
WinFS


Longhorn to be Released in 2006, Sans
WinFS
08/28/2004 11:15 AM
Slashdot Aug 28 2004 3:38PM GMT

Avalon, WinFS decoupled for Windows
Shorthorn


Avalon, WinFS decoupled for Windows
Shorthorn
08/31/2004 12:02 PM
Cue 'out-of-band add-on packs'

WinFS Axed From Longhorn Client and
Server


WinFS Axed From Longhorn Client and
Server
08/27/2004 05:18 PM
Microsoft confirms developer buzz that its next-gen storage subsystem won't make it into its 2006 client and 2007 server Windows releases.

Questions about Longhorn, part 2: WinFS
and semantics


Questions about Longhorn, part 2: WinFS
and semantics
06/07/2004 03:51 PM
In the first installment of this series of questions about Longhorn, I concluded that the compelling benefit of WinFS must lie in the realm of "organizing stuff" rather than just "finding stuff" -- else why not just leverage existing and well-understood relational, free-text, and XML search methods? And I posited that the signature feature of WinFS -- "relationships" -- must be powerful enough to justify the creation of a proprietary new storage model that will enable (but also require) new applications and developer skills. Admittedly my "finding versus organizing" distinction was a bit of a cheat, since finding depends sensitively on prior organization. Except when it doesn't: brute-force free-text search routinely trumps navigation and structured search. But OK, we've all got to hope that better organization, someday, will level the playing field. ...

WinFS StoreSpy v0.8 for the WinHEC 2004
Longhorn Build


WinFS StoreSpy v0.8 for the WinHEC 2004
Longhorn Build
05/19/2004 11:41 PM
WinFS Store Spy is an Explorer-like tool to browse WinFS. It offers flexible ways for you to quickly find your stuff and navigate the store. You can inspect Item, Relationship (all 3 types), Extension, Nested Element, and MultiSet properties.

MSDN TV: WinFS Overview - Significant
New Storage Innovation for Longhorn


MSDN TV: WinFS Overview - Significant
New Storage Innovation for Longhorn
12/12/2003 05:31 PM
Quentin Clark provides an overview of WinFS, including what benefits it produces, what it is, and how it's put together. This episode introduces WinFS as a basis for more detailed presentations.

Mobile Platforms


Mobile Platforms 02/01/2005 08:36 PM

The last time I've done any intense development work for mobile devices was 4~5 years ago.  At that time, I've looked at Palm, Pocket PC, J2ME, and WAP and concluded that mobile platforms were not yet ready.  Last week, I've looked at the mobile devices and OSes again.  My opinion is that it's still not ready despite the amazing change in capabilities and capacities.

The main problem that prevents emergence of killer apps on mobile platforms is that applications are treated as second-class citizens, placed in a straight-jacket and pigeon-holed.

To receive or make a call, one just flip-opens the phone or press a button.  To use an application. one has to navigate around a typically hierarchical tree of functionalities.  Some devices have separate buttons for built-in applications but they either cannot be remapped to another application or controls for remapping is buried and lost in that confusing tree of functionalities.

In addition, functionalities are not tightly integrated and offers wide array of modal experiences depending on where you are on the tree.  On top of the default phone mode, browser mode, SMS mode, e-mail mode, address book mode, and various preference modes, each application has its own mode.

Before killer apps can emerge, mobile platforms must be changed drastically, removing modes and allowing applications to add their functionalities without being boxed in.


"animated gif: platforms"


"animated gif: platforms" 07/21/2004 02:40 PM

animated gif: platforms


animated gif: platforms 07/21/2004 09:42 AM
is superb .. Holy shit

j-walkblog.com/blog/docs/platform.htm
track this site | 6 links


BI bigwigs ramp up platforms


BI bigwigs ramp up platforms 05/10/2004 01:32 PM
BI vendors Firstlogic, IBM, Informatica, and SAS Institute are all working to broaden the reach of their respective BI platforms via extensions to their product lines focused on data integration.

Tips For Crossing Platforms


Tips For Crossing Platforms 03/20/2003 10:00 PM
Clip, save and pass along to your platform-crossing friends, no matter which way they're switching. (New York Times via MyAppleMenu)

New: Gboard wheeled platforms


New: Gboard wheeled platforms 02/12/2004 11:28 AM
AstroAge's Gboard wheeled platforms for G5 and G4 towers are made of half-inch thick architectural-grade Plexiglas with die-cast twin wheel casters.

2004 reviews: Platforms


2004 reviews: Platforms 01/03/2005 05:19 PM
InfoWorld reviews the year in operating systems, including the arrival of the v2.6 Linux kernel.

Substation computing platforms


Substation computing platforms 01/02/2005 06:33 AM
Reed Business Information Jan 2 2005 9:11AM GMT
Grok Description matches for David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS
GrokA matches for David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS

David Stutz on Platforms and WinFS

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

BumbleBee, the
XQuery Test Harness

XML Namespaces
Support in Python
Tools, Part 1

The Library of
Congress Comes Home

The Beauty of REST
Microcontent
Management with
Syncato

Growing Interest in
XML Seen at AIIM
Conference on
Content and Records
Management

Tunneling Variables
PyCon 2004: Making
Python Faster and
Better

Getting in Touch
with XML Contacts

Using libferris with
XML

The XML.com
Interview: Jeff Barr

Utility Stylesheets
From P2P to Web
Services: Addressing
and Coordination

SVG and Typography
Fair use, or not
fair?

Google Gets Makeover
Google Gets Its
Groove On

Google Not Fooling
Around: Launches
Gmail

Google to Unveil
Free E-Mail

Free E-Mail With a
Steep Price?

Gmail Takes Heat
from Privacy Groups

The Secret Source of
Google's Power

Turning Search Into
a Science

Google Gets More
Gmail Guff

I wish I didn't
understand

Panda Joke V
Global Feature
Request

Outlook as a
platform

Innovations in
Self-Help

Are web companies
tech or media?

Fools, etc.
talking to the
outsiders

Content Targetting
for Personal Ads

Great Moments in
Advertising

Rumor Today:
Portales Revised

Impulse Buy
NetWare Client For
Mac OS X IP Released

Apple Dealers Deny
iPod's "Dirty
Secret"

Apple Granted Patent
For Adjustable
Screen Snake Arm

Analysts Look For
Improvement In G5
Sales

Making A Killing On
eBay

No April Fools Joke
For Apple Reps

Donn Denman: Apple
Is Getting 'More
Connected'

Apple Aims At
Architects

Apple Makes Noise
Perfect Storm
Brewing For
Microsoft?

Reduce CPU Usage
Pink iBook
Speculation: The
Real iPod Killer

12" iBook 800MHz G4
what is grok?