stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...







Value Judgements on two kinds of
networks...

Value Judgements on two kinds of
networks...
03/13/2003 10:16 AM

I don't have the expertise or the discipline to dive into this as fully as I would like, so I'm just going to sketch out a few thoughts which maybe someone else would like to pick up and run with.

There are two articles currently doing the rounds that both talk about the value and utility of being part of the networked world, and what it means to participate within it. The first is about the internet - it's called World of Ends and it's by the inspired Doc Searls and David Weinberger. The second is about international politics and it's called The Pentagon's New Map and it's by Thoma s PM Barnett.

The first article - Doc Searls and David Weinberger's - was immediately something I felt a desire to rally behind. It's states what we have come to perceive as the obvious facts about the internet: that it can't be controlled, that it should exist without governance, without regulation, that it routes around 'damage', that the internet consists of an agreement, that no one owns it, that everyone can use it, that everyone can add to it, that trying to deform the network lessens its power - lessens its democratising utility. I agree with all of this stuff.

The second article filled me with immediate distrust and discomfort. It's about countries which are disconnected from the 'network' of globalisation. Here's a quote:

"That is why the public debate about this war has been so important: It forces Americans to come to terms with I believe is the new security paradigm that shapes this age, namely, Disconnectedness defines danger. Saddam Hussein’s outlaw regime is dangerously disconnected from the globalizing world, from its rule sets, its norms, and all the ties that bind countries together in mutually assured dependence."

This is a paean to the power and value of globalisation as a force for good. He continues:

Show me where globalization is thick with network connectivity, financial transactions, liberal media flows, and collective security, and I will show you regions featuring stable governments, rising standards of living, and more deaths by suicide than murder. These parts of the world I call the Functioning Core, or Core. But show me where globalization is thinning or just plain absent, and I will show you regions plagued by politically repressive regimes, widespread poverty and disease, routine mass murder, and—most important—the chronic conflicts that incubate the next generation of global terrorists.

There seem to be some significant parallels that could be drawn between these two models of global scale-free networks that call into question the appropriateness of our (my) judgements about both globalisation as a democratic / capitalist process and the internet as a communications / publishing process. There's a collision here that I feel the need to investigate.

For me, the freedom and lack of regulation of the internet was an obvious goal - inevitably positive - while the spread of globalisation represented something tremendously powerful, but also threatening, difficult and dangerous. While the internet seemed to dismantle hegemony, globalisation also seemed to support it - promote it. But by seeing them in parallel, depicted simply as analogous networks that operate on protocols, some of my value judgements about each of them seem to be spreading to infect the other.

My anxiety about globalisation as a hegemonising power is now spreading into my feelings about the internet - could the power-law aspect of the internet that I've not previously had issue with actually not be analogous with multinational corporations doing terrible soulless inhuman things across the world. Rather than being analogous, could they in fact be the same thing? Could the infiltration of globalisation's spread through the world be the same 'liberating', equalising, opportunity-producing phenomenon that I've believed the internet to be?

There are other weird connections or analogies that can be drawn between the two articles / systems - some of which seem to collide with my argument or rephrase it or push it in a different direction. But each one of them seems to be to point towards something out of my reach at the moment. One analogy seems weirdly to be between disconnected states that constitute a threat to the network and to the very organisations that seem to be behind globalisation - large corporations who push for proprietorial behaviours in an interconnected space. Compare and contrast:

Think about it: Bin Laden and Al Qaeda are pure products of the Gap—in effect, its most violent feedback to the Core. They tell us how we are doing in exporting security to these lawless areas (not very well) and which states they would like to take “off line” from globalization and return to some seventh-century definition of the good life (any Gap state with a sizable Muslim population, especially Saudi Arabia). If you take this message from Osama and combine it with our military-intervention record of the last decade, a simple security rule set emerges: A country’s potential to warrant a U.S. military response is inversely related to its globalization connectivity.
"Remember, though, that if you come up with a new agreement, for it to generate value as quickly as the Internet itself did, it needs to be open, unowned, and for everyone. That’s exactly why Instant Messaging has failed to achieve its potential: The leading IM systems of today — AOL's AIM and ICQ and Microsoft's MSN Messenger — are private territories that may run on the Net, but they are not part of the Net. When AOL and Microsoft decide they should run their IM systems using a stupid protocol that nobody owns and everybody can use, they will have improved the Net enormously. Until then, they're just being stupid, and not in the good sense."

In this model, a fundamentalist state is kind of like a Microsoft or an AOL trying to spread propriety in the interconnected, protocol-based space. In trying to defy or censor or 'improve' the architecture to fulfil their needs they simply threaten the existence of the network in the first place. Except that the network is too huge and too integral to everything to be threatened. Terrifyingly / wonderfully / confusingly the network routes around it. Or does it? Am I losing my mind?

I'm far too close to my own mental collision at the moment to know if I'm hallucinating connections that don't exist or if I'm merely stating the obvious. It seems to me that I'm not - it seems to me that there has been clear lines drawn between them and us through books like Naomi Klein's No Logo that I think are probably at least more problematic now. If only to me. Anyone got any thoughts? Can anyone shoot me down? Or push it further?




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...

Grok Headline matches for Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...

Snap judgements


Snap judgements 04/16/2005 08:03 AM
I've found a good use for my iPod - I listen to podcasts on the way to work. Yesterday, I found this gem: The keynote of SXSW conference by Malcolm Gladwell. (MP3 download and stream available.)

He talks about snap judgements, and how good we are convincing ourselves that we are making a rational decision, even when we're not. I've always believed that intuition is a skill that can be trained - but I didn't know humans were that dependent on it...

Highly, highly recommended.


Kinds of Funds


Kinds of Funds 06/23/2004 09:09 AM
Learn the difference between income funds and balanced funds.

It takes all kinds....


It takes all kinds.... 01/02/2005 01:07 AM
Educati ng Wesley: a photo essay.

Five kinds of "busy"


Five kinds of "busy" 10/29/2003 01:15 AM

We're so "way too fucking busy" that we are the Trotts.


All kinds of Ick in my Sick


All kinds of Ick in my Sick 12/29/2003 04:20 PM
Not to a whole lot of fun going on here I'm sick of being sick, the rain looks more like...

New kinds of marriages in Massachusetts


New kinds of marriages in Massachusetts 01/07/2004 04:19 PM

Our home state of Massachusetts has been in the news recently for a positive decision on gay marriages.  It would seem that the next natural step would be state recognition of other types of alternative unions.Apparently we don't think heterosexuality is worthy of special legal treatment anymore.  Why should duality be favored then over plurality?  Why can't a voluntarily polygamous family or polyandrous family apply for a marriage license?  The cultural and cross-cultural precedent for polygamy is certainly much stronger than for gay marriage.

My friend Richard and I were flying to Bradley Field in Connecticut today (excellent airplane museum) and it occurred to us that this could solve America's health insurance problem.  Consider 50 uninsured people.  They could all get married in one big union.  One of the 50 could take a job with really good health benefits, e.g., for the government.  The other 49 would then get spousal health benefits.


Inside the Injured Brain, Many Kinds of
Awareness


Inside the Injured Brain, Many Kinds of
Awareness
04/05/2005 04:31 AM
The debate over Terri Schiavo's fate comes at a time when researchers are deepening their understanding of the unconscious brain.

Weather radios will carry more kinds of
alerts (USATODAY.com)


Weather radios will carry more kinds of
alerts (USATODAY.com)
06/18/2004 06:39 AM
USATODAY.com - People across the nation now can learn quickly about emergencies ranging from tornadoes to terrorist attacks by owning a radio that broadcasts weather information, federal officials said Thursday.

Korean Integrated News Database System
(KINDS)


Korean Integrated News Database System
(KINDS)
01/05/2004 02:54 PM
Korean Integrated News Database System (KINDS)
http://www.kinds.or.kr/peng_html/what_kinds.html

"KINDS (Korean Integrated News Database System - Korea Press Foundation, Seoul, South Korea) provides full texts of ten major national dailies; the Kyunghyang Shinmun, the Kukmin Daily, the Korea Daily News, the Dong-A Ilbo, the Munhwa Ilbo, the Segye Ilbo, the Chosun Ilbo, the Joongang Ilbo, the Hankyoreh, and the Hankook Ilbo. Articles of January 1, 1990 and after are available. KINDS also provides articles of economic daily newspapers, such as the Maeil Business Newspaper, the Seoul Kyungje Shinmun, the Korea Economic Daily, the Naewoe Economic Daily, the Jeil Economic Daily, the Money Today, and the Financial News. It delivers essential financial and business information for the most selective consumer. KINDS has more than 5 million articles from national dailies, economic dailies, TV news programs, English language dailies, local dailies, professional newspapers, and news magazines."

Contempt Unites All Kinds in Haiti (Los
Angeles Times)


Contempt Unites All Kinds in Haiti (Los
Angeles Times)
02/15/2004 07:33 AM
Los Angeles Times - GONAIVES, Haiti — The chalkboard inside the tin-roof schoolhouse bears the remnants of a science lesson from six months ago. But the man at the head of the class is interested in a different kind of chemistry.

Paypal, internet banking systems use
wrong kinds of sockets, plugs


Paypal, internet banking systems use
wrong kinds of sockets, plugs
08/01/2004 06:47 AM
Theinquirer.net - Sun Aug 1, 09:00 am GMT

""Citizen Smash" deserves all kinds of
props for saying something important and
true, and probably not too popular with
his base"


""Citizen Smash" deserves all kinds of
props for saying something important and
true, and probably not too popular with
his base"
05/02/2004 03:40 PM

WiFi, Cellular, and Wired Networks
Merging To Form Pervasive Networks in
Homes and Offices, Says INSIGHT Research


WiFi, Cellular, and Wired Networks
Merging To Form Pervasive Networks in
Homes and Offices, Says INSIGHT Research
12/22/2004 01:46 AM
Pervasive networks—a ubiquitous “fabric” of computing, information, entertainment, and telemetry capability tied together by high-speed wired and wireless networks—are emerging from a flurry of new communication technologies now being used in home and office networks. Though communications carriers do not offer this type of continuous communication as a service today, the piece parts are already in place. [PRWEB Dec 20, 2004]

[The iPods] will be loaded with all
kinds of useful information, including
orientation schedules, calendars, campus
tours, even the Duke fight song


[The iPods] will be loaded with all
kinds of useful information, including
orientation schedules, calendars, campus
tours, even the Duke fight song
07/21/2004 09:42 AM
entregarles gratis un iPod a cada nuevo estudiante de la Universidad .. Here's your iPod

newsobserver.com/news/story/1446864p-7571661c.html
track this site | 5 links


Accessing Wireless Sensor Networks:
Gridlogix adds support for Dust
Networks’ SmartMesh™ Wireless Sensor
Network


Accessing Wireless Sensor Networks:
Gridlogix adds support for Dust
Networks’ SmartMesh™ Wireless Sensor
Network
06/17/2005 04:45 PM
Gridlogix, Inc., a leading creator of enabling interoperable XML Web Services technology today announced enhanced support for Dust Networks’ SmartMesh™ wireless sensor network. SmartMesh is a wireless mesh sensor network used in remote monitoring and control. The Gridlogix EnNET® XML Web Service application extends the functionality of the SmartMesh system to include robust protocol translation between the wireless mesh network and other automation protocols and systems. EnNET translates the SmartMesh wireless protocol into BACnet/IP, SNMP, and LonWorks® allowing Dust Networks’ wireless sensor network to be seamlessly integrated with existing automation networks. [PRWEB Jun 16, 2005]

My Networks


My Networks 07/14/2004 05:10 PM
Bill Gurley, the guy who really needs an RSS feed, hosted a great panel on wireless at AO2004. Key takeaway was the role of the consumer driving service offerings. There was a debate about technologies and business models between wireless...

RSS Ad Networks


RSS Ad Networks 08/09/2004 11:45 PM
If RSS represents a network of subscriptions with pass through potential, shouldn't its ad format? Scoble: So, over the next year, we're going to see these two philosophies bash heads once again. The "branders" versus "the users." He is exactly...

"Real Networks"


"Real Networks" 08/17/2004 09:24 PM

Proxy Pal For Networks


Proxy Pal For Networks 03/27/2005 11:30 PM
Renewing Release

Mac Tip: Access Wi-Fi Networks


Mac Tip: Access Wi-Fi Networks 09/18/2004 10:13 PM
G4 Tech TV Sep 19 2004 2:17AM GMT

Look Out Airport Networks...


Look Out Airport Networks... 11/18/2003 09:04 PM
JetBlue Airways is offering free Wi-Fi to folks hanging out in its departure gates in Terminal 6 in New York's JFK Airport: The airline also offers the free Wi-Fi in its hub, the LA/Long Beach airport. If more airlines start doing this, it will be interesting to watch what happens to the companies that are already offering fee-based services in airports. That seems to be a big business, with hotspot providers signing exclusive deals with airports. I wonder what sort of rights airlines have to build Wi-Fi networks in the gates they often use. Glenn has heard from some folks in the industry that airports are starting to assert rights to spectrum that they previously left alone, or encoding these rights in new contracts as airline leases expire....

IBM getting chummy with TV networks


IBM getting chummy with TV networks 04/18/2005 04:25 AM
CNET Asia Apr 18 2005 8:57AM GMT

Networks-n-Filters


Networks-n-Filters 08/20/2004 11:55 PM
New Release: Networks-n-Filters-1.1.0

Senator wants to ban P2P networks


Senator wants to ban P2P networks 07/22/2004 06:13 PM
A proposal to outlaw file-swapping networks receives warm welcome in Senate. Backers claim that iPods will stay off ban list.

A plague on all our networks


A plague on all our networks 12/03/2003 05:15 AM
Attacks on the up, as clean-up costs soar

Networks need to team up for 3G - IDC


Networks need to team up for 3G - IDC 05/10/2004 11:22 PM
ZDNet Australia May 11 2004 3:15AM GMT

P2P News Networks: will they fly?


P2P News Networks: will they fly? 04/10/2004 05:00 AM
Music and movies are distributed via P2P, why not daily news? It may just happen.

How Many Social Networks Is Too Many?


How Many Social Networks Is Too Many? 11/14/2003 02:29 AM
I keep reading about all these "social networking software" plays, and the amazing thing to me is that, unlike during the last bubble, everyone except people working for these companies or venture capitalists seem to know it's a bubble. Yet, they keep on coming. The latest is that Evite has launched their own version of Friendster tied to their event organizing system, and eMode (known for their fun tests and dating system) has changed their name to Tickle, which is what their Friendster wannabe is called. They also bought another social networking service, to take one of about 100 off the market. Who the hell signs up for all of these systems? Paten ts aside, there is nothing complicated in creating such a site (there's even one Friendster rip off called Yet Another Friendster Rip Off). The complication comes in actually making money from such a site. The odd thing, though, is the rampant skepticism about these sites. In the 90s bubble years, it was never like this. Sure, there was some skepticism, but not the near universal skepticism that is focused on social software space right now. What's funny is that you would think so much skepticism would make the VCs stay away, but the reverse is happening.

How to Pay for Municipal Networks


How to Pay for Municipal Networks 09/21/2004 02:46 PM
Some municipalities may have already learned some lessons about offering telecom services that they can consider when deciding to build Wi-Fi networks: Some of the most successful municipal offerings of wired telecom services started out with small trial networks and were offered by municipalities that already offer utility services to customers. But beyond whether a municipality has experience with billing and marketing a service, Wi-Fi presents a bunch of additional uncertainties. In the wired example, in many cases the market doesn't have any other option for broadband Internet access and customers definitely pay for the access. In the case of Wi-Fi, in many cases other service providers may already offer wireless access. Plus, cities have to decide whether they want to offer access for free or for a fee. If they want to deliver free networks, they have to decide how to fund it, considering both the initial outlay and ongoing support costs. Ultimately, citizens of communities may end up deciding. In St. Cloud, Fla., the city is trying to decide how to pay for the ongoing maintenance of the network and will likely ask residents to decide on a ballot referendum. If municipalities decide to ask residents to pay for access, they have to hope they can cover their costs. At this stage in the market, based on the experiences of commercial Wi-Fi providers, it's not clear that an operator can make money from for-fee networks....

You've Got Dust... Networks


You've Got Dust... Networks 09/20/2004 05:07 PM
For quite some time, we've been hearing various stories about "smart dust" with most of the talk coming from Dust Networks. After all this time, they've finally launched a product. It's clearly nowhere near the "smart dust" level yet, but looks to be a wireless mesh networking technology for letting a variety of sensors communicate easily, without killing batteries too quickly. Still, it's a big step forward for the space, meaning we should expect plenty of gushing news stories about the technology in the near future.

F5 Networks Appoints New CTO


F5 Networks Appoints New CTO 08/17/2004 02:58 PM
theWHIR Aug 17 2004 6:41PM GMT

Bot networks on the rise


Bot networks on the rise 09/21/2004 08:38 AM

Arbor Networks


Arbor Networks 07/05/2004 03:54 PM
I have been playing with an expensive tool recently which has made some incredible difference in detecting security issues on the network. Arbor Networks makes a bunch of security and operations based products, but the one I want to mention...

AI Neural Networks


AI Neural Networks 09/26/2004 02:57 PM
VC 8.x for free

3G networks roll out


3G networks roll out 09/07/2004 02:26 PM
The Economist Sep 7 2004 6:14PM GMT

Social networks and my big a-ha


Social networks and my big a-ha 06/14/2004 07:45 PM
Wisconsin Technology Network,WI-54 minutes agoReaders of DEMOletter know that I've written regularly about so- called social networks, services such as LinkedIn, Spoke, and Google's Orkut. ...

Web sites act like networks


Web sites act like networks 06/22/2005 02:17 AM
Usatoday.com - Fri Jun 17, 08:44 pm GMT

Are the TV networks dying?


Are the TV networks dying? 04/11/2005 08:14 AM

Social Networks Against Spam


Social Networks Against Spam 02/18/2004 02:56 PM
While the various social networking services continue to push forward, some researchers are using the same basic concept of linking people to their friends to see if social networks can help fight spam. The idea is that most people get their email from a limited social network of people, and that network can be worked out by looking at the "to:" "from:" and "cc:" portions of your email. The theory being that if I know two people, they're much more likely to know each other as well, and the system can link them, and assume that if they email each other it's unlikely to be spam. Spam messages, however, have no such linkage, and are more easily picked out from the crowd. Of course, it doesn't sound like this works all that well. You don't get any false positives, but it seems to only recognize a little over 50% of all spam. The folks behind this research say it's still useful, if used in combination with other spam filtering techniques.
Grok Description matches for Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...
GrokA matches for Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...

Value Judgements on two kinds of networks...

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out: