The latest Shirky
Grok Headline matches for The latest Shirky
why i like clay shirky
why i like clay shirky
04/11/2004 07:43 PMhis gothamist interview is my love of new york with logic substituting
for romance
It's a Shirky girl!
It's a Shirky girl!
02/11/2004 09:36 PMThe rumor going around etech is that Clay and his wife are the parents
of a girl! Woohoo! Mazel tov to the entire family. A world with more
Shirkies is a better world for all of us....
Shirky: Spectrum as resource
Shirky: Spectrum as resource
08/16/2004 04:25 PM
A nice
article on some of the engineering and economics aspects of WiFi,
and the history of frequency regulation in the USA.
Shirky on why light shouldn't be owned
Shirky on why light shouldn't be owned
08/14/2004 08:22 AMClay has posted the clearest, sober-est explanation of why it's time
to regulate spectrum as a public good and not as property. It's a
brilliant piece of writing in which every sentence tells....
Shirky on Spectrum Ownership
Shirky on Spectrum Ownership
08/14/2004 04:55 PMSkip this rant and read Shirky
Skip this rant and read Shirky
12/03/2003 07:33 AMShirky: Wikipedia's "anti-elitism" is a
feature, not a bug
Shirky: Wikipedia's "anti-elitism" is a
feature, not a bug
01/04/2005 02:40 AMCory Doctorow:
Kuro5hin published an
article
by a Wikipedia co-founder, in which he slams Wikipedia for its
"anti-elitism" and calls on the organization to mend its ways in order
to earn the confidence of academics, librarians and other learned
types. I read it when it was first published and it seemed wrong to
me, but I couldn't put my finger on it.
Now Clay Shirky -- himself an academic -- has written a wonderful and
comprehensive rebuttal of the piece, explaining why complaints of
"anti-elitism" are misplaced.
Of course librarians, teachers, and academics don't like the
Wikipedia. It works without privelege, which is inimical to the way
those professions operate.
This is not some easily fixed cosmetic flaw, it is the Wikipedia's
driving force. You can see the reactionary core of the academy playing
out in the horror around Google digitizing books held at Harvard and
the Library of Congress -- the NY Times published a number of letters
by people insisting that real scholarship would still only be possible
when done in real libraries. The physical book, the hushed tones, the
monastic dedication, and (unspoken) the barriers to use, these are all
essential characteristics of the academy today.
It's not that it doesn't matter what academics think of the Wikipedia
-- it would obviously be better to have as many smart people using it
as possible. The problem is that the only thing that would make the
academics happy would be to shoehorn it into the kind of filter, then
publish model that is broken, and would make the Wikipedia broken as
well.
Link"Clay Shirky?s terrific presentation on
Ontologies"
"Clay Shirky?s terrific presentation on
Ontologies"
04/04/2005 02:12 AM[etech] Day 2 Clay Shirky - Phone as
platform
[etech] Day 2 Clay Shirky - Phone as
platform
03/17/2005 03:00 AMClay begins a segment on tech and education. He says he thinks of his
group at NYU as "The Department of the Recently Possible." A few years
ago they noticed that students were increasingly integrating phones
into their apps. So they started looking into it. One experiment:
PacManhattan that mates the urban grid and the game grid. The runners
are controlled by people in a control room via mobile phones.
DodgeBall was an experiment in mobile social networking. "Mobile
phones are the first things since keys that everyone carries," Clay
says, citing Marko Ahtisaari. DodgeBall alerted him that there was...
Shirky: The Possibility of Spectrum As A
Public Good
Shirky: The Possibility of Spectrum As A
Public Good
08/14/2004 08:48 PMlong piece in defense of opening up more spectrum .. The Possibility
of Spectrum as a Public Good ..
Clay
shirky.com/writings/spectrum_public_good.html
track this
site | 3 links
Shirky: Cameraphones are today's
Gutenberg press
Shirky: Cameraphones are today's
Gutenberg press
05/11/2004 11:59 AMClay Shirky has written an excellent entry on the appearance of
unmediated photos from the Iraqi front on a Friendster-like service
called YAFRO. He likens this -- and other instances of undmediated
communication -- to the Protestant Reformation.
The spread of images from Iraq, both relatively plain ones like most
of what's on the YAFRO blogs to the horrifying images of torture and
abuse from the Abu Ghraib prison are all part of the removal of
bottlenecks that will change the political structure in ways we can't
predict.
And it isn't just military affairs, its politics and business and
everything else, from attempts to coordinate evidence of Apple's
manufacturing errors (previously handled case-by-case, but now
becoming a kind of grass-rooots class action protest, to Apple's
horror) to the distributed amicus brief on the SCO case conducted by
the Linux community to the recent right of Americans to get their
medical records on request and within 30 days to the publication of
spoilers for popular TV shows. (Read this last link now — its
from the Times and goes away in 5 days, and although on the surface
its about TV, its really a musing on life in a fully disclosed
culture.)
Link[etech] Clay Shirky: Ontologies and Tags
[etech] Clay Shirky: Ontologies and Tags
03/17/2005 03:00 AMClay talks about how taxonomies always have values built in. Even the
periodic table's "noble gases" division reflects an assumption about
the "essential" state of elements. He points to the Dewey Decimal
System's skewed religion category. [Yikes! I've been doing that, too!
I probably heard it from Clay first. I will attribute it from now on.
Ack!] Even the Library of Congress puts the Balkan Peninsula and
African on equal footing because it's measuring the number of books on
the shelves. The categorization reflects not the ideas but the
physical storage. He points out, that even though Yahoo has cross...
Clay Shirky tried to use some crippled
software to rip a DVD, and it didn't
work.
Clay Shirky tried to use some crippled
software to rip a DVD, and it didn't
work.
03/31/2005 10:58 PM
Clay Shirky tried to use some crippled software to rip a DVD, and it
didn't work. The software was apparently written by legally
paranoid people who are trying to diguise their paranoia by blaming
The Man. The law does not forbid software from copying unencrypted
DVDs (all burned DVDs are unencrypted) -- hence the existence of Nero,
Popcorn, etc. It is a shame that so much voluntarily crippled software
and hardware is out there, but let's not lay all the blame on the law.
Shirky: Wikipedia is better than
Brittanica on net-centric axes
Shirky: Wikipedia is better than
Brittanica on net-centric axes
01/05/2005 07:09 PMCory Doctorow:
Clay Shirky's posted more about Wikipedia on Many2Many, responding to
danah boyd's post about
how Wikipedia won't be an encylopedia. The thing Clay
really nails this time in the idea that
"new media don't succeed because they're like the old media, only
better: they succeed because they're worse than the old media at the
stuff the old media is good at, and better at the stuff the old media
are bad at."
And of course, sometimes Wikipedia is better, since, as with the
Indian Ocean tsunami example, Britannica simply has no offering. So,
at the margin, a casual user who wants free access to a Web site that
offers a communally-compiled and non-authoritative overview of a
recent event will prefer the Wikipedia to nothing, which is what
Britannica offers. In this case, Wikipedia comes out on top, and
walking along several of those axes like cost, availability,
topicality, and breadth of coverage, Wikipedia has the advantage, and
in many cases, that advantage is increasing with time
Now Britannica doesn't want this to be true (god, do they not want
this to be true) and so they try to create litmus tests around
authoritativeness -- "WARNING: Do not read anything that does not come
from an institutional source!" But this is as silly as audiophiles
dismissing the MP3 format because it wasn't an improvement in audio
quality, missing entirely that the package of "moderate
quality+improved cost and distribution" was what made the format
great. Considering MP3 as nothing more than a lossy compression scheme
missed the bundle of services that it enabled.
Link"Gothamist Interviews: Clay Shirky,
Internet Technologist"
"Gothamist Interviews: Clay Shirky,
Internet Technologist"
04/12/2004 10:00 PMGothamist Interviews: Clay Shirky,
Internet Technologist
Gothamist Interviews: Clay Shirky,
Internet Technologist
04/10/2004 08:47 AMGothamist has an excellent interview with Clay Shirky today ..
intervju
gothamist.com/interview/archives/2004/04/09/clay_shirky_int
ernet_technologist.php
track this
site | 9 links
Clay Shirky: RIAA Succeeds Where
Cypherpunks Fail
Clay Shirky: RIAA Succeeds Where
Cypherpunks Fail
12/18/2003 11:52 AMscubacuda writes "Clay Shirky has an interesting take on encryption:
'The RIAA is succeeding where the Cypherpunks failed, convincing users
to trade a broad ...
Shirky: stupid (c) laws block me from
publishing own work online
Shirky: stupid (c) laws block me from
publishing own work online
04/02/2005 09:18 AM
Xeni @ Boing Boing Blog
Shirky: stupid (c) laws block me from publishing own work online
Clay Shirky tells Boing
Boing:
Welcome to the Copyfight. So, at Etech this year, I
gave a talk entitled
Ontology is Overrated. I want to put a transcript up online, and
Mary Hodder, who recorded the talk, graciously agreed to give me a
copy of the video.
When she came by NYC last week, she dropped off a DVD, which I then
wanted to convert to AVI (the format used by my transcription
service.) I installed ffmpeg and tried to convert the material, at
which point I got an error message which read "To comply with
copyright laws, DVD device input is not allowed." Except, of course,
there are no copyright laws at issue here, since I'M THE COPYRIGHT
HOLDER.
Got that? I am in possession of a video, of me, shot by a friend,
copied to a piece of physical media given to me as a gift. In the
video, I am speaking words written by me, and for which I am the clear
holder of the copyright. I am working with said video on a machine I
own. Every modern legal judgment concerning copyright, from the Berne
Convention to the Betamax case, is on my side. AND I CAN'T MAKE A COPY
DIRECTLY FROM THE DEVICE. This is because copyright laws do not exist
to defend the moral rights of copyright holders -- they exist to help
enforce artificial scarcity.
Copyright holders in my position, who want to use Creative Commons
licensing to share material, are treated as pathological cases,
because we're not behaving in the extortionate manner that current
regulations are designed to protect.
I've gotten the copy another way, and the transcript will go up,
but this is the state of the world, circa 2005: I can be prevented
from copying my own words from my own devices, precisely because I
want to share them freely, a use the law is perfectly prepared to
regard as irrelevant.
Yes. Welcome to the
copyfight. The scary thing is that more and more people are beginning
to think it is NORMAL not to be able to do what Clay is upset about
not being able to do.
Comment -
TrackBack
Clay Shirky talks about the RIAA forcing
people to adopt Encryption
Clay Shirky talks about the RIAA forcing
people to adopt Encryption
12/18/2003 02:28 PMI have always been intrigued with encryption and use PGP on select
e-mail from time to time and understand the...
Boing Boing: Shirky: stupid (c) laws
block me from publishing own work online
Boing Boing: Shirky: stupid (c) laws
block me from publishing own work online
04/01/2005 05:23 PMClay Shirky rants about the absurd US copyright laws that are
preventing him from copying his own media .. Clay Shirky tried to use
some crippled software to rip a DVD, and it didn't work .. Boing
Boing
boingboing.net/2005/03/31/shirky_stupid_c_laws.html
track this
site | 3 links
only-latest-0.01
only-latest-0.01
11/04/2003 05:16 AMThe Latest In Lie Detecting
The Latest In Lie Detecting
11/05/2003 02:55 AMEverybody knows that the old polygraph test is a joke that isn't
particularly accurate. So, the next question is whether or not it's
possible to build a system that can actually catch people telling a
lie? It looks like there are a
lot of different projects underway to invent the
next generation of lie detector. Researchers are trying out all
different methods, many of them sponsored by the Department of
Defense. There are certainly a number of ethical issues with "looking
into someone's mind", but the researchers appear to have come to terms
with those issues (or, perhaps we should test them on their own
machines to see how they feel on that issue...).
the latest Blu-ray roadmap
the latest Blu-ray roadmap
08/03/2004 09:26 PMSony showed
the
latest Blu-ray roadmap in Japan (scroll down, the images are in
English). I'm glad to see that they're considering advanced codecs and
their focus on "absolute best quality video" (does that mean 1080p?).
The bad news is that the Blu-ray movie format is not finished, so the
$4,000 Blu-ray players that people already bought probably won't be
able to play Blu-ray movies (suckers!).
What’s New in Latest Adobe CS
What’s New in Latest Adobe CS
04/11/2005 11:25 AMlatest news...
latest news...
03/24/2005 04:41 AMWelcome to my desktop
mikebutler.editthispage.com
track this
site | 8 links
"latest reports"
"latest reports"
12/29/2004 03:31 AMThe latest works
The latest works
07/13/2004 07:06 PMTons of crazy optical illusions .. motion-related
illusions
ritsumei.ac.jp/~akitaoka/saishin2e.html
track this
site | 4 links
Apple's Latest
Apple's Latest
06/28/2004 10:06 AMHeading this morning to Apple's Worldwide Developers
Conference in San Francisco, where Steve Jobs will deliver the
keynote. There's never any WiFi connectivity inside the hall at such
things, so I'll be letting you know later what's what.
Deflectors on full: Entering Reality Distortion Field...
MCI to consider latest $8.9m Qwest bid
MCI to consider latest $8.9m Qwest bid
04/04/2005 08:26 AMComputer Business Review Apr 4 2005 12:25PM GMT
Next big thing--or the latest fad?
Next big thing--or the latest fad?
03/31/2005 11:29 PMZDNet Apr 1 2005 12:20AM GMT
The Latest On The Father Of The DVD
The Latest On The Father Of The DVD
06/28/2004 05:22 AMA year and a half ago, we wrote about
Warren
Lieberfarb getting fired from Warner Brothers. Lieberfarb is
often credited as the "father of the DVD," who fought long and hard to
get everyone on the same page to offer the DVD. Newsweek is now
running an article looking at the story a year and a half later, where
Lieberfarb is still
not particularly
liked in the industry he helped save. The article also has the
overall background story of how he got warring parties together in
order to build the DVD. While he's still fighting with Time Warner
over his compensation, he's now working for Microsoft on the next
generation of DVD technologies. It would have been a lot more
impressive if he would have taken his deal making skills and energy to
get the entertainment industry to realize the power of peer-to-peer
networking, rather than just trying to rehash his last success story.
The story is positioned as if Lieberfarb realized the importance of
getting everyone together on this particular "disruptive" technology.
It's too bad he doesn't appear to be paying attention to the much
bigger disruptive technology that's out there.
Latest OS Updates
Latest OS Updates
03/20/2003 04:19 PMWolfe’s Latest
Wolfe’s Latest
06/06/2004 01:51 AMI just finished reading
The Knight, by Gene Wolfe, one of
only two or three living authors whose works I’ll pick up without
regard to reviews or word-of-mouth...
Latest W3C publications
Latest W3C publications
02/25/2003 10:16 AMThe following documents have been published recently by the W3C: SVG
Printing Requirements, OWL Language Reference, DOM Level 3 Events,
Voice XML 2.0 (Candidate Recommendation), and XML Protocol Abstract
Model
Latest SP2 News
Latest SP2 News
08/18/2004 03:25 AMMadonna's Latest Self, a Mix of Her Old
Ones
Madonna's Latest Self, a Mix of Her Old
Ones
05/26/2004 11:57 AMOn the first date of her Re-Invention World Tour, Madonna often found
herself shadowboxing with her own past lives.
The Latest in Bluetooth
The Latest in Bluetooth
04/14/2005 01:43 PMEntrepreneur.com Apr 14 2005 3:54PM GMT
Latest Scam: Pay Us For Using @
Latest Scam: Pay Us For Using @
08/17/2004 03:23 PMTheRegister has picked up one of the more amusing scam emails
apparently making the rounds. It's not entirely clear how much
they're actually asking for (the quoted email shows a few different
amounts), but those behind the scam are suggesting that they've
copyright
ed the "@" symbol and users need to pay (somewhere around $10 to
$20) for an unlimited one-year license. The thing is... some people
might actually fall for something like this.
RSS: The Latest Feed
RSS: The Latest Feed
12/27/2004 06:52 AMRSS: The Latest Feed by Judith Wusteman
h
ttp://www.ucd.i
e/wusteman/lht/wusteman-rss.html
Abstract
The number of library-related
RSS and Atom applications is increasing daily. But, as yet, the
formats and technology involved are far from stable. This article
looks at the current state of the field, discusses future developments
and considers implications for the library. This has been added to my
Bots, Blogs and News
Aggregators presentation.
Grok Description matches for The latest Shirky
GrokA matches for The latest Shirky
The latest Shirky