stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


On the benefits of competing audio formats...







On the benefits of competing audio
formats...

On the benefits of competing audio
formats...
01/27/2004 06:28 PM

There's a fascinating clump of posts going around the place at the moment about the various DRM-based digital audio solutions that you can buy at the moment. The one that kicked stuff off initially was a post on The Sobleizer (A challenge for webloggers: handling organizational difficulties) which included a chunk of stuff about why it's best for people who are going to buy music files with DRM to buy them in Windows Media format. Here's the main chunk of the argument:

When you hear DRM think "lockin." So, when you buy music off of Napster or Apple's iTunes, you're locked into the DRM systems that those applications decided on. Really you are choosing between two competing lockin schemes.

But, not all lockin schemes are alike, I learned on Friday. First, there are two major systems. The first is Apple's AAC/Fairtunes based DRM. The second is Microsoft's WMA

Let's say it's 2006. You have 500 songs you've bought on iTunes for your iPod. But, you are about to buy a car with a digital music player built into it. Oh, but wait, Apple doesn't make a system that plays its AAC format in a car stereo. So, now you can't buy a real digital music player in your car.

(I should mention at this point that Scoble works for Microsoft, but I'll say straightaway that I don't think that's particularly relevant to the argument at hand. Nonetheless, cards on the table.)

So the argument at this point is if you choose lock-in with Microsoft, then your music files will work on a wider variety of media than if you choose lock-in with Apple. Therefore you should choose lock-in with Microsoft. At which point BoingBoing's Cory Doctorow weighs in:

In this world where we have consumer choices to make, Scoble argues that our best buy is to pick the lock-in company that will have the largest number of licensees.

That's just about the worst choice you can make.

If I'm going to protect my investment in digital music, my best choice is clearly to invest in buying music in a format that anyone can make a player for. I should buy films, not kinetoscopes. I should buy VHS, not Betamax. I should buy analog tape, not DAT.

Because Scoble's right. If you buy Apple Music or if you buy Microsoft Music, you're screwed if you want to do something with that music that Apple or Microsoft doesn't like.

Cory's argument then is the fairly commercially radical proposition that we should buy only open music files, that companies should sell open music files (there is a precedent here - Bleep sells DRM-free songs from Warp Records), and even that companies like Microsoft should be using their substantial legal power to fight the record companies to be able to sell DRM-free songs online.

Now I'm not going to argue with that, although - to be fair - I think the current climate makes it pretty unlikely to happen. The various companies concerned are too neurotic about it, and frankly Microsoft has too much to lose from the proposition that intellectual property should be distributed without arcane DRM attached to it. Instead I'm going to argue that even if we're only given the choice between two DRM schemes, we should still not just automatically go for the one that plays on the most devices. Because what does this mean in the end? No more or less than yet another monopoly at the operating system level - the musical infrastructure ends up belonging to Microsoft.

The fact is we shouldn't think in those terms at this stage. We should be trying to create miscegenated musical libraries that we expect digital music manufacturers to support all of, not just some as it suits them or as it suits whichever company ends up dominating the market. We've been down this parth before - the company that owns the monopoly has the least to gain from a rapid pace of innovation, the least to gain from being standards compliant. We've seen it at the level of operating systems, internet browsers and now we're seeing attempts to own and define the one successful format in which music files could sit for the next few decades. These things are too important to be left in the hands of one company. We need to have consumer choice at the level of which DRM (or lack of DRM) we're comfortable with buying, we need variety so that different types of audio file can be released via a variety of business models, we need variety - fundamentally - because otherwise we all lose.

The examples that people cite about competing formats no longer hold true for music. It's not like VHS and Betamax - we're not talking about hardware with different sized slots that you can only fit one kind of music delivery system into. No - with music we mostly have applications on our desktop that can play dozens of different formats - whether we notice it or not. Just the other day, RealOne announced that it could now play Apple-encoded AAC files, and the rumour is that HP's deal with Apple required that the iPod should have its ability to play WMP files restored. These things can play more than one type of file and we should be doing our damnedest to make sure that continues to be the case. It should be obvious to car audio manufacturers that they should be able to play AAC tracks - that there are hundreds of thousands of people across America (and soon Europe) who are going to want to be able to do more things with their bought songs. And it should be obvious to all of us that we want a world in which new formats can be integrated into our listening without any particular effort, or at least without us having to rebuy all our old tracks to work on non-mutually functioning players.

So in the meantime, buy, steal or rip whichever tracks suit you best in whatever format you want and make it your mission to put pressure on all the players (both business players and audio players) concerned to support as many of them as possible as soon as possible. And don't listen to anyone who says that having one organisation controlling the musical infrastructure will result in greater choice. That's never been the case in the past, and I very much doubt it will be so in the future either.

Read the comments




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

On the benefits of competing audio formats...

Grok Headline matches for On the benefits of competing audio formats...

New Digital Audio Formats


New Digital Audio Formats 06/13/2004 12:16 PM

All the World's a Soundstage as Audio
Formats Evolve


All the World's a Soundstage as Audio
Formats Evolve
04/09/2004 04:03 PM
A new music format called MP3 Surround adds the extra audio channels needed for five-speaker sound without appreciably increasing file size.

HNS Audio Learning Session: The Benefits
of SSL VPNs


HNS Audio Learning Session: The Benefits
of SSL VPNs
06/23/2004 02:59 AM

Unitime Systems' New Benefits Manager
Automatically Tracks Employee
Paid-Time-Off Benefits


Unitime Systems' New Benefits Manager
Automatically Tracks Employee
Paid-Time-Off Benefits
02/05/2005 10:00 PM
Benefits calculated as part of the company’s daily time and attendance tracking [PRWEB Feb 3, 2005]

"URGENT: WASH POST: Bush admin weighing
changes in Social Security benefits
formula... // 'cutting promised benefits
by nearly a third in the coming
decades'... Developing... "


"URGENT: WASH POST: Bush admin weighing
changes in Social Security benefits
formula... // 'cutting promised benefits
by nearly a third in the coming
decades'... Developing... "
01/04/2005 05:59 PM

URGENT: WASH POST: Bush admin weighing
changes in Social Security benefits
formula... // 'cutting promised benefits
by nearly a third in the coming
decades'... Developing


URGENT: WASH POST: Bush admin weighing
changes in Social Security benefits
formula... // 'cutting promised benefits
by nearly a third in the coming
decades'... Developing
01/04/2005 04:24 AM

washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A45726-2005Jan3.html?nav=rss_pol itics
track this site | 3 links


Friends, Friends With Benefits and the
Benefits of the Local Mall


Friends, Friends With Benefits and the
Benefits of the Local Mall
05/29/2004 10:54 PM
Whatever happened to teen romance? Life inside the under-age sexual revolution.

Next-gen DVD riven by two competing
standards.


Next-gen DVD riven by two competing
standards.
11/13/2003 09:52 PM
EE Times: Next-gen DVD riven by two competing standards. Red lasers are out, so it's blue vs. blu now.

Competing With Microsoft By Ignoring
Them


Competing With Microsoft By Ignoring
Them
04/15/2004 09:02 PM
One thing that you always hear among new startup companies looking for venture capital is figuring out how they're going to avoid competing with Microsoft. Obviously, it's not true of all startups - some of whom are in completely different areas. However, any software (and many services) company always gets the question "well, how will you deal with it when Microsoft enters your space?" Companies that don't have a good answer don't get funded. Robert Cringely's latest column is all about the best way to compete with Microsoft - and it's a bit counterintuitive, but it makes a lot of sense. The companies that have successfully competed with Microsoft have done so by not worrying about Microsoft. In other words, they've been focused on building innovative products that their customers can use. Microsoft, for all it's strong points, doesn't have the greatest track record at actually innovating (I can already hear some of you scoffing). What they are good at (and, you have to admit, they are good at it) is taking innovative ideas that others have come up with, and then putting a nice, user friendly interface on them and getting it out in the market. So, as Cringely points out, when you decide to turn and face Microsoft and compete directly with them, you're going to be in a lot of trouble - because you've set the rules of the game on their terms, and they've got a lot more money and experience to beat anyone else on those terms. Instead, by pretty much ignoring Microsoft, and coming up with new and innovative products companies can out-innovate them, and not face real competition from them.

WhenU.com Enjoined From Competing
Pop-Ups


WhenU.com Enjoined From Competing
Pop-Ups
01/06/2004 03:14 AM
Frisky070802 writes "The NY Times reports that a preliminary injunction has been issued against WhenU.com, a company that distributes software that performs ...

Competing spam 'solutions'


Competing spam 'solutions' 01/25/2004 09:25 AM
Legislation and technology are being turned against spam--but to what effect? Knowledge@Wharton offers a status report.

Other News: Competing Codecs


Other News: Competing Codecs 07/06/2004 09:54 AM
A Reuters article looks at the Balkanization of digital music download systems via competing compression formats.

WhenU.com Enjoined From Competing
Pop-Ups


WhenU.com Enjoined From Competing
Pop-Ups
01/06/2004 06:53 AM
Slashdot Jan 6 2004 5:25AM ET

AT&T Changes Competing Policy in 7
States


AT&T Changes Competing Policy in 7
States
06/23/2004 11:10 AM
AT&T said today it would stop competing for customers in seven states after a court threw out regulations giving it cheap access to the dominant local telephone networks.

Competing standards may shake up e-mail


Competing standards may shake up e-mail 03/06/2004 02:04 AM
Microsoft, Sendmail, and Yahoo are pushing anti-spam protocols

Next-generation DVD Driven By Two
Competing Standards


Next-generation DVD Driven By Two
Competing Standards
11/14/2003 11:28 AM

Competing Claims and Interaction Types


Competing Claims and Interaction Types 02/10/2004 02:49 AM
Continuing his review of the W3C's Architecture of the World Wide Web document, Kendall Clark looks further at the principles set out governing interactions on the web.

Sound Audio Systems Announces Huge Sale
on Selected Professional Audio Products


Sound Audio Systems Announces Huge Sale
on Selected Professional Audio Products
03/14/2005 05:26 PM
Sound Audio Systems announced today that the company will have a huge sale on selected items. [PRWEB Mar 1, 2005]

AT&T Changes Competing Policy in 7
States in Wake of Ruling


AT&T Changes Competing Policy in 7
States in Wake of Ruling
06/23/2004 01:56 PM
AT&T's decision followed the elimination of regulations giving it cheap access to the dominant local telephone networks.

Objectively Comparing Competing Search
Engines?


Objectively Comparing Competing Search
Engines?
03/29/2005 05:27 PM

Competing voice standards via for
developers' attention


Competing voice standards via for
developers' attention
04/21/2004 03:42 AM
Speech technology is now pushing deeper than ever into the enterprise and carrier space. VoiceXML proponents tout their W3C standard and the warm reception the open standards approach has met from the industry. Meanwhile, a group of companies led by Microsoft is pushing a separate specification called Speech Application Language Tag (SALT) that some say may end up stifling voice advances.

Goldman, Morgan Stanley competing for
Google IPO


Goldman, Morgan Stanley competing for
Google IPO
10/29/2003 12:11 AM
Goldman Sachs Group Inc., Morgan Stanley and eight other investment banks are in the running to underwrite a $2 billion initial public offering by Google Inc ...

Microsoft to Create Competing BitTorrent
Technology


Microsoft to Create Competing BitTorrent
Technology
06/17/2005 03:58 PM

There Goes the Neighborhood. Nice code name: avalanche. Says it all don’t you think? here’s what Infoworld had to say: Researchers at Microsoft’s Cambridge, England, labs are developing a file-sharing technology that they say could make it easier to distribute big files such as films, television programs and software applications to end-users over the Internet. Code-named Avalanche, the technology is similar to existing peer-to-peer (P-to-P) file swapping systems such as BitTorrent’s, in the sense that…

Direct and Related Links for 'Microsoft to Create Competing BitTorrent Technology'


Elemental Audio offers Neodynium audio
compressor


Elemental Audio offers Neodynium audio
compressor
09/14/2004 07:23 AM
Elemental Audio Systems on Tuesday introduced Neo dynium, a plug-in for RTAS, Audio Unit and VST-compatible audio software designed for compression and dynamics processing. It uses an "I/O Map" visual interface that helps audio pros optimize and direct their efforts, rather than relying on more common transfer curves and displays. Neodynium costs US$159 (and is available for $139 for a limited time). It works with Digidesign Pro Tools, Emagic Logic and other software. System requirements call for a G3 or faster with Mac OS X v10.2 or newer and a compatible host application.

Avoid competing Terminal window title
commands


Avoid competing Terminal window title
commands
11/16/2003 01:48 PM
Note to self: if you're trying to set a terminal's name via File -> Set Title..., then by all means, please be sure that your /etc/bashrc file does NOT contain code similar to the following: PROMPT_COMMAND='echo -ne "\0...

Microsoft to Avoid Competing with Oracle
--Testimony (Reuters)


Microsoft to Avoid Competing with Oracle
--Testimony (Reuters)
06/24/2004 09:39 PM
Reuters - Competing in the enterprise software market would be bad strategy for Microsoft Corp. (MSFT.O), a Microsoft executive testified on Thursday in the antitrust trial over Oracle Corp.'s (ORCL.O) $7.7 billion hostile takeover bid for rival PeopleSoft Inc. (PSFT.O)

Congress offers competing ideas on
fighting ID theft


Congress offers competing ideas on
fighting ID theft
06/17/2005 04:55 PM
Senators at a hearing this week offered a number of competing ideas to fight identity theft, including a proposal to license data brokers and a national law to notify potential victims of a data breach.

Competing Measures Add to Complexity of
State Ballot (Los Angeles Times)


Competing Measures Add to Complexity of
State Ballot (Los Angeles Times)
09/13/2004 04:59 AM
Los Angeles Times - SACRAMENTO — Californians face one of the longest and most complicated ballots in the nine decades since the state invoked direct democracy — putting Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger on the defensive to protect his political fortune and leaving voters to sort out a patchwork of ideas.

Westec InterActive Selects the Voice
Tracker™ Array Microphone for Enhanced
Audio in Retail and Restaurant
Audio/Video Surveillance and Operations
Audit


Westec InterActive Selects the Voice
Tracker™ Array Microphone for Enhanced
Audio in Retail and Restaurant
Audio/Video Surveillance and Operations
Audit
03/17/2005 03:36 AM
Westec InterActive, the leader in interactive remote security monitoring for convenience store, retail, restaurant and other business applications, selected Acoustic Magic’s Voice Tracker™ array microphone to be used for enhanced audio for audio/video monitoring. Enhanced audio is especially important for Operational Audits, enabling clear reception of conversations between employees and customers. [PRWEB Mar 17, 2005]

Enhancing all audio output via Audio
Hijack


Enhancing all audio output via Audio
Hijack
09/03/2004 08:46 AM
This is kind of a followup to this previous hint regarding an iTunes equalizer setting. Something I do as a matter of course is configure Audio Hijack Pro to enhance the sound that iTunes (and DVD Player, Real Player, you na...

Audio controller promises next gen audio
systems


Audio controller promises next gen audio
systems
06/25/2004 11:57 AM
The latest version of Oxford Semiconductor's OXFW970 FireWire audio controller IC allows next generation audio systems to be easily added to desktop and notebook systems on the Mac and PC platforms, reports electropages in an article noted at MacSurfer...

M-Audio introduces Revolution 5.1 audio
card


M-Audio introduces Revolution 5.1 audio
card
08/04/2004 10:03 AM
M-Audio on Wednesday introduced the Revolution 5.1, a surround sound audio card compatible with both Macs and PCs. The PCI card comes bundled with Aspyr Media's Wakeboarding Unleashed featuring Shaun Murray, billed as the first Mac game optimized for surround sound. The Revolution 5.1 is available for US$99.95.

Linux a national security risk,
competing RTOS vendor claims


Linux a national security risk,
competing RTOS vendor claims
04/09/2004 04:07 PM

War! Google to Take on PayPal: plans to
Offer Competing Online Payment System


War! Google to Take on PayPal: plans to
Offer Competing Online Payment System
06/22/2005 02:06 AM
All I can say is wow…makes sense. Caught this from Reuters: “Google Inc. this year plans to offer an electronic-payment service that could help the Internet-search company diversify its revenue and may heighten competition with eBay Inc.’s PayPal unit, the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday. “Exact details of the search company’s planned service are not known, the report said, but quoted people familiar with the matter as saying it could have similarities with PayPal,… Direct and Related Links for 'War! Google to Take on PayPal: plans to Offer Competing Online Payment System'

McKeesport Teens Seek Support In Order
to Fulfill Dream of Competing in FIRST
National Robotics Competition


McKeesport Teens Seek Support In Order
to Fulfill Dream of Competing in FIRST
National Robotics Competition
03/25/2005 06:34 AM
Local Students Win Regional Robotics Competition But Lack Funds to Move On to the Championship [PRWEB Mar 25, 2005]

AAC Audio Format Selected for DVD Audio


AAC Audio Format Selected for DVD Audio 04/09/2004 04:10 PM
Tony Smith writes for the Register, “The AAC (Advanced Audio Codec), the audio format supported by Apple’s iTunes Music Store, has been chosen as a key future DVD Audio disc technology by the standard’s governing body, the DVD Forum.” [Mar 25]

Take Along the Music in All Its Many
Formats


Take Along the Music in All Its Many
Formats
09/15/2004 10:58 PM
New York Times Sep 16 2004 2:44AM GMT

Mac Office 12 to Get XML Formats, Too


Mac Office 12 to Get XML Formats, Too 06/05/2005 11:59 PM
Rick Shaut, a member of the Macintosh Office team, wrote in his Web log that the Macintosh version of Office 12 will also support the Office Open XML format announced Thursday for its Windows counterpart. He also admitted Microsoft Mac Business Unit had fallen behind on XML support within the Office Suite.

Understanding HD Formats


Understanding HD Formats 01/19/2004 08:29 AM
High-definition television (HDTV) first arrived on the national stage in the late 1980s, but even today only a minority of consumers in the United States and a much smaller minority in other industrialized nations have HDTV systems. However, high-definition (HD) production for video and film is increasing rapidly, as is the installed base of high-definition-capable displays. Consumers are demanding higher-quality content that takes advantage of these better displays. In addition to the content delivered over the airwaves, a significant amount of content will be delivered to the displays through computers. This demand will help to further drive the increasing availability of HD content.
Grok Description matches for On the benefits of competing audio formats...
GrokA matches for On the benefits of competing audio formats...

On the benefits of competing audio formats...

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

Hutchison starts up
3G service in Hong
Kong

NTT Docomo Signals
AT&T Wireless
Interest

What You Should Know
About the Mydoom
Worm

Gates: Windows 'By
Far The Most Secure'
System; Tries To Use
'Mac OS X Secure
Through Obscurity'
Myth

Apple Program Can
Turn Anyone Into A
Musician

Which Format Will
Win?

A Very Personal
Computer

Muine 0.3.0
PwManager 0.5.1
nVidia XFree86 4.x
Drivers 1.0-5336

tasks 1.8.4
Gnomoradio 0.9
(Development)

Moron 0.5.1
(Experimental)

Fast OnlineUpdate
for SuSE 0.11.1

FeedCreator 1.5.1
JMTF Initial Alpha 1
Tomorrow Flux 0.1
Star wars footage
leak

passion chokes the
flower

Hansard Society -
Hansard Society
organises public
meeting on MPs and
Blogging

'Manhunt' Redefines
Video Game Violence
(AP)

pointless
Zang CMS Framework
froi -- FSFAST ROI
Man Rescues Cat; Cat
Saves Man From Fire
(AP)

GoogObits:
Obituaries with
Google News links

Procket Networks COO
resigns

SCO issues bounty
for MyDoom creator

Nigeria to tackle
e-mail scams

Amazon finally flows
into profit

NASA Says Shuttles
Could Fly Again by
September (Reuters)

System Tray
Whack-a-Mole

qmail Lazydog 2.0
2004/01/21 10.19
(Development)

NewsCache 1.1.92
(Development)

Distributed Checksum
Clearinghouse 1.2.29

SQua Flux 0.3
wxGuide 0.3.4
libnova
TclAddressBook
SolOffice, the Open
Source Office Suite

PostWoman
Compad
CycleAtlas
Visual Basic
utilities

OWC, Shure, Drive
Savers on Inside Mac
Radio

DiskWarrior update
adds Panther support

Cell Phone Guns
Speechless
Virus 'Mydoom'
Continues to Hit
Computers Worldwide

COB Alumnus Donates
Computers

what is grok?