stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


RSS & Commenting







RSS & Commenting

RSS & Commenting 02/17/2003 12:16 PM

I have this idea for adding commenting information to RSS feeds. This would allow the writers of news aggregators to have forms built into their software where readers could send comments to the site their reading without having to visit the site. Below is an example of what I'm thinking.

<comments:method>XML-RPC</comments:method>
<comments:uri>http://yoursite.com/comments.php</comments:u
ri>
<comments:fields>
 <comments:field value="name" isRequired="true"/>
 <comments:field value="email" isRequired="true"/>
 <comments:field value="url"/>
 <comments:field value="body" isRequired="true"
maxlength="1024"/>
</comments:fields>

Messages could be sent any number of ways, including (in order of my preference): XML-RPC, HTTP-POST, POST, and HTTP-GET. There would have to be a standardized naming of fields. For instance, in the case of the above example, the user is asked to enter their email address. The standard would have to specify a singular name that would be understood to be email address, like email, so that code writers don't have to be sniffing for email addresses if the aggregator program decides to send it as contact instead.

The implementation could be as simple or as complex as the site owner wanted. Error checking in the aggregators could alleviate some headaches on the blog's end. If a site wanted to require registration, they could require a username and password field in the <fields> section above.

Of course, now that people could comment through their aggregators you would need to have a way getting your comments back to the aggregator. This could be done in three ways as I see it.

  1. The blog could run a seperate RSS feed containing their comments. Some blogs already do this (Phil Ringnalda, for instance).
  2. The RSS Commenting specification could include a method of showing comments inline in current RSS feeds (this would be best, I think).
  3. More tech-savvy sites could allow aggregators to set up connections to them (XML-RPC client/server perhaps) and request all the comments for a particular post. I think this method would be more work than neccessary.

Please leave me a comment below or drop me an email and let me know if you think this idea is good, or even if you think it's stupid. Also, if you know of the best way to propose such a thing to the RSS Working Group, let me know. I'm going to write up some more ideas and specifications, maybe even a DTD or Schema.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

RSS & Commenting

Grok Headline matches for RSS & Commenting

Revamps to Commenting and RSS


Revamps to Commenting and RSS 02/15/2003 08:39 PM

In my previous post, I asked that users who requested my old RSS file in news aggregators update to the new link. Phil left a comment which raised a good point. From what he said, I have changed my error handling to return an HTTP message of 301 Moved Permanently and redirect to the new RSS feed when the old feed is requested. I've tested the results with Syndirella and it worked. I could tell it worked because my access logs showed my request as one for the new URL, and not the old URL, even though I requested the old one. In the past I would have received an error code as well. However, let me know if you have any problems.

Also new, I completed the non-dynamic commenting system. Most of you will never see it because your browser supports the dynamic version, but this will affect a few people.


Turned commenting back on


Turned commenting back on 04/09/2004 04:01 PM
I spent several hours trying to install James Seng's CAPTCHA comment spam reduction MT hack, but didn't have any luck. Seng isn't answering questions any more about his hack, but apparently (undocumented), it requires a newer version of GD.pm than the antiquated 1.38 version that my webhost, phpwebhosting.com, has installed. I tried convincing my webhost to upgrade their version of GD, but they declined, and when I tried to do a private install, I found so many other packages that also needed upgrading that in the end I gave it up. The problem with comment spam is that I always feel like my site has been defaced, and I wonder why someone would go to all the trouble when I remove the comment spam on a daily basis. I have to remind myself that it isn't anything personal, the spammer hasn't even been to my site, it is just a script. So back to the old Spambad system until MT 3.0 ships. At least it has sharpened by SQL skills, devising a new SQL statement every day to erase the 90 spam comments while keeping the two valid comments. In any case, please feel free to comment again....

HaloScan.com - Webl0g Commenting


HaloScan.com - Webl0g Commenting 11/27/2002 03:31 AM
HaloScan.com - Weblog Commenting. Not all websites have comments built-in. For instance Blogger does not. Fortunately, there are third party systems like this that take care of that. Amazing that John found this. Main issue is that comments just hang in the air. I can see why traceback was developed. For ...

Symbio - Commenting System


Symbio - Commenting System 02/12/2004 06:14 PM
Symbio 1.7a released

more motion on the PGP commenting effort


more motion on the PGP commenting effort 03/06/2004 01:57 AM
i still fear the effort may be quixotic, but it's interesting to watch

BlogBack | Remote Commenting for Webl0gs


BlogBack | Remote Commenting for Webl0gs 08/22/2004 04:13 AM
postCount('109301549119851711');

tecknik.net/blogback/data/bb.php?bl og=3252948&post=109301549119851711
track this site | 3 links


Site News: New Commenting System


Site News: New Commenting System 09/03/2002 11:37 AM

Fw: comment on post #38 "HaloScan.com -
Webl0g Commenting"


Fw: comment on post #38 "HaloScan.com -
Webl0g Commenting"
12/03/2002 03:50 PM
-------------------------- Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld -----Original Message----- From: Rich Tong To: John Ludwig CC: John Zagula Sent: Tue Dec 03 10:06:49 2002 Subject: Re: comment on post #38 "HaloScan.com - Weblog Commenting" Wow we should talk about this. I spent sometime with mt over the weekend and you are right there needs to be ...

Re: comment on post #38 "HaloScan.com -
Webl0g Commenting"


Re: comment on post #38 "HaloScan.com -
Webl0g Commenting"
11/27/2002 07:45 PM
The integration isnt quite right. A blog ad its oents are v close to eail but don't interat correctly for those of us not at a screen. To e a blog entry should become email and comments too. I'm going to hack at b2 to show what I mean. I think ...

Info on Geek News Central's New
Commenting Feature


Info on Geek News Central's New
Commenting Feature
06/27/2004 04:18 PM

I have been getting some negative e-mail on us locking down our commentng system, we now require you to register with Typekey. I want to explain why we had to lock down the comments. I was spending 20 to 30 minutes a day removing spams that contained adult or inappropriate content. The spammers where using commenting programs that would put several 100 comments per spamming run places throughout our 2500 articles. We had a tool to help us clean those comments up but it took entirely to much time.

The new system is enable through a service called Typekey. Once you are registered with Typekey you will be able to post comments on any Movabletype 3.0 or greater webllog. They have a very clear policy that they will not disclose any more information than what you allow in your profile. If you look at my profile you will see that I have opted to allow you to see a variety of information about me. All of that information is OPTIONAL.

No they do require you to divulge a minimal amount of information when you signup but the main point is to verify posters identities. We do not require your e-mail address be posted on the website. This is to keep spam out of your inbox when spammers come harvesting e-mail address's.

I encourage our readers to forward me any concerns you have directly to geek at geeknewscentral.com


Auto Code Commenting Software, Free
Chairs


Auto Code Commenting Software, Free
Chairs
04/01/2005 05:25 PM

Jeff Jarvis asks for an external
commenting system


Jeff Jarvis asks for an external
commenting system
06/22/2005 02:41 AM
"Remind me of the names and addresses of external blog comment systems."

Hey Jeff - I hope you'll be at SuperNova to hear Sxip's announcement!


What Horse**** are all you people
commenting about..64bit software and
all. For the price it sells for, there


What Horse**** are all you people
commenting about..64bit software and
all. For the price it sells for, there
07/09/2004 12:20 AM
TechTree Jul 9 2004 4:45AM GMT

NASA muzzled from commenting on global
warming disaster film, fearing Bush will
be blamed


NASA muzzled from commenting on global
warming disaster film, fearing Bush will
be blamed
04/26/2004 09:48 PM
NASA Curbs Comments on Ice Age Disaster Movie .. More

nytimes.com/2004/04/25/national/25MOVI.html
track this site | 4 links


Comcast Outages Prevent Comcast From
Commenting On Comcast Outages


Comcast Outages Prevent Comcast From
Commenting On Comcast Outages
04/14/2005 01:21 PM
Last week, we noted that Comcast was having widespread outage problems, which they chalk ed up to "scheduled maintenance", even though no one was actually informed of said schedule ahead of time. It turns out that schedule is pretty crowded, because all week long, there have been continued reports of recurring outages all across the Comcast network. Comcast, of course, continues to be pretty much silent on the issue, leaving its increasingly fed up call center staff to deal with incredibly angry customers who feel they're getting no information at all. How hard is it to admit that they screwed up and they're working on fixing the problem? Instead of chalking it up to bogus scheduled maintenance or pretending there's nothing wrong, admit what the problem is and give people real updates. People would still be unhappy, but at least they'd feel like the company wasn't ignoring them. Of course, maybe they can't do that because Comcast staffers don't have any internet access either...
Grok Description matches for RSS & Commenting
GrokA matches for RSS & Commenting

More Linux with Motorola A780


More Linux with Motorola A780 07/27/2004 02:34 PM
infoSync Jul 27 2004 6:52PM GMT

Motorola's A780 See-Through Smartphone


Motorola's A780 See-Through Smartphone 07/28/2004 01:20 PM

motorola_a780_01.jpg imageInfosync has some hinkfo about another one of the phones announced by Motorola this week, the A780, a Linux-based handset that will run on EDGE (new wireless broadband fastness) networks. And while it's full-featured as anything -- 1.3-megapixel camera, gostosa! -- the most interesting thing about the A780 is its screen. Through a hole in the flip-top basic information like Caller ID can be seen, while the full display is accessible when opened. It's a smart design; hopefully developers will take advantage of it.

Read - More Linux with Motorola A780 [InfosyncWorld via CoolHunting]

Related
Motorola Webcast Highlights [Gizmodo]
More Motorola RAZR V3 Pics [Gizmodo]
Motorola MPx220 and RAZR V3 Officially Unveiled [Gizmodo]


Motorola Announces A780 Linux SmartPhone
and MPx220 Pocket PC SmartPhone


Motorola Announces A780 Linux SmartPhone
and MPx220 Pocket PC SmartPhone
07/27/2004 02:34 PM
bargainPDA.com Jul 27 2004 6:18PM GMT

Telnet Server for Windows NT/2000/XP
v4.0


Telnet Server for Windows NT/2000/XP
v4.0
11/19/2003 02:15 PM
The product turns a Windows NT/2000/XP system into a multi-user Telnet server. Gives Telnet users full access to Windows NT command line. Telnet users can run a variety of character-based applications. Accepts any telnet connection from any client (Unix, NT, 2000, 95, 98, Me, etc.) right out of the box. [Shareware $100.00 30 Days 415 KB]

MITKRB5-SA-2005-001: buffer overflows in
telnet client


MITKRB5-SA-2005-001: buffer overflows in
telnet client
03/29/2005 06:00 PM
Tom Yu (Mar 28 2005)

Enabling The Windows Server 2003 Telnet
Service


Enabling The Windows Server 2003 Telnet
Service
05/09/2004 12:56 PM

MDKSA-2005:061 - Updated krb5 packages
fix telnet client vulnerability


MDKSA-2005:061 - Updated krb5 packages
fix telnet client vulnerability
03/30/2005 02:01 PM
Mandrakelinux Security Team (Mar 29 2005)

[USN-101-1] telnet vulnerabilities


[USN-101-1] telnet vulnerabilities 03/28/2005 07:59 PM
Martin Pitt (Mar 28 2005)

DoS in GoodTech Telnet Server 4.0.103


DoS in GoodTech Telnet Server 4.0.103 01/02/2004 05:02 PM
Donato Ferrante (Jan 02 2004)

sshdos - SSH, SCP, SFTP, Telnet client


sshdos - SSH, SCP, SFTP, Telnet client 11/14/2003 09:14 AM
0.94 released

Features: Telnet and REST Web Services?


Features: Telnet and REST Web Services? 12/19/2004 03:48 PM
Telnet isn't the most efficient way to send GET, PUT, POST, and DELETE commands to an HTTP server, but once you've done it by hand, you'll have a better understanding of the core HTTP method.

Buffer-overflow in Jordan's telnet
server


Buffer-overflow in Jordan's telnet
server
12/29/2003 05:37 PM
Luigi Auriemma (Dec 29 2003)

SSH2, Part 1: Securing Your Telnet
Session


SSH2, Part 1: Securing Your Telnet
Session
07/14/2004 09:53 AM

Cisco warns of lock-up flaw for IOS and
telnet


Cisco warns of lock-up flaw for IOS and
telnet
09/06/2004 09:42 PM
Computer Weekly Sep 7 2004 1:18AM GMT

Configure a networked HP LaserJet 2100
via telnet


Configure a networked HP LaserJet 2100
via telnet
02/17/2004 11:49 AM
The HP utilities for configuring JetDirect 600N (as used in LaserJet 2100 and others) only run under Windows. The web based configuration utility is not supported on Macs. However, once the DHCP assigned IP address is known...

Bay Technical Associates telnet server
logon bypass


Bay Technical Associates telnet server
logon bypass
03/31/2005 07:14 PM
nolimit bugtraq (Mar 31 2005)

Combating Reverse Telnet using OpenBSD
Packet Filter


Combating Reverse Telnet using OpenBSD
Packet Filter
12/30/2003 01:30 AM

Using the ‘telnet:’ URI
Protocol to Delete Files


Using the ‘telnet:’ URI
Protocol to Delete Files
05/21/2004 01:01 PM

Mac OS X’s default handling of the ‘telnet:’ URI protocol allows any file to which you have write privileges to be overwritten.


[ GLSA 200504-01 ] telnet-bsd: Multiple
buffer overflows


[ GLSA 200504-01 ] telnet-bsd: Multiple
buffer overflows
04/01/2005 05:06 PM
Thierry Carrez (Apr 01 2005)

Opera Telnet URI Handler Vulnerability
also applies to other browsers


Opera Telnet URI Handler Vulnerability
also applies to other browsers
05/13/2004 03:20 PM
Jannes (May 13 2004)

Re: Bay Technical Associates telnet
server logon bypass


Re: Bay Technical Associates telnet
server logon bypass
03/31/2005 07:14 PM
Michael Brennen (Mar 31 2005)

UNIX Authors Rush to Patch Telnet Flaw


UNIX Authors Rush to Patch Telnet Flaw 03/31/2005 05:03 PM
Several high-profile distributors of the BSD version of the Telnet protocol have rolled out patches for a critical bug that could cause system-hijack attacks. The bug, which was reported by iDefense Inc., is a remotely exploitable buffer overflow that could allow the execution of arbitrary code with user privileges.

A successful attacker would have to convince the user to launch a Telnet session with a malicious server. A malicious Web page could be designed that could launch the Telnet client on the user's system by clicking a link, or, using the IFRAME tag, by loading the page. Telnet is a protocol that supports virtual terminal sessions across IP networks including the Internet. The Telnet client program provides the interface for the terminal session to the user.

News source: eWeek

Read full story...

[SECURITY] [DSA 697-1] New netkit-telnet
packages fix arbitrary code execution


[SECURITY] [DSA 697-1] New netkit-telnet
packages fix arbitrary code execution
03/29/2005 06:00 PM
Martin Schulze (Mar 29 2005)

Re: GoodTech Telnet Server Buffer
Overflow Vulnerability [EXPLOIT]


Re: GoodTech Telnet Server Buffer
Overflow Vulnerability [EXPLOIT]
03/17/2005 03:53 AM
cybertronic_at_gmx.net (Mar 16 2005)

[SECURITY] [DSA 699-1] New
netkit-telnet-ssl packages fix arbitrary
code execution


[SECURITY] [DSA 699-1] New
netkit-telnet-ssl packages fix arbitrary
code execution
03/29/2005 06:00 PM
Martin Schulze (Mar 29 2005)

[SECURITY] [DSA 529-1] New
netkit-telnet-ssl package fixes format
string vulnerability


[SECURITY] [DSA 529-1] New
netkit-telnet-ssl package fixes format
string vulnerability
07/19/2004 09:50 AM
Matt Zimmerman (Jul 18 2004)

APC 9606 SmartSlot Web/SNMP management
card "backdoor" - Telnet can't be
disabled.


APC 9606 SmartSlot Web/SNMP management
card "backdoor" - Telnet can't be
disabled.
02/19/2004 03:30 PM
David Monosov (Feb 19 2004)

XBOX EvolutionX ftp 'cd' command and
telnet 'dir' buffer overflow


XBOX EvolutionX ftp 'cd' command and
telnet 'dir' buffer overflow
02/10/2004 01:32 PM
icbm (Feb 09 2004)

[ GLSA 200504-04 ] mit-krb5: Multiple
buffer overflows in telnet client


[ GLSA 200504-04 ] mit-krb5: Multiple
buffer overflows in telnet client
04/06/2005 05:45 PM
Posted by Thierry Carrez, Apr 06 2005

Re: APC 9606 SmartSlot Web/SNMP
management card "backdoor" - Telnet
can't be disabled.


Re: APC 9606 SmartSlot Web/SNMP
management card "backdoor" - Telnet
can't be disabled.
02/19/2004 06:14 PM
Keith Clifton (Feb 19 2004)

RSS & Commenting

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry: telnet into a780 password hack a780 gpl "download a780" "removing sent from my blackberry wireless handheld" message "a780 telnet" a780 telnet access jay carol e mail addresses 2005 pgp protection windows xp v8.0 motorola a780 hack sdk "removing sent from my blackberry wireless"

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

phpMyAdmin 2.4.0-rc2
released

Larry Page: Google
Was an Accident

Chatters love
cyberspace

Google Acquires Blog
Software Firm

Google buys into
blogging

Linux Journal:
Making a PHP Site on
Linux Work with a
Microsoft SQL Server
Database

WHAT BOTOX AND
VIAGRA TEACH US
ABOUT ADVERTISING

Email your Google
searches

Web search finds
local angle

Web-ad spending
rebounds

Error Handling,
Apache and PHP

Integrating
DreamWeaver and PHP

Cold Fusion versus
PHP

Dynamically
Filtering Dropdown
Lists in Javascript

Google Deal Ties
Company to Weblogs

'I lit the match'
World clicks on to
gem of a business

Two Critical Tips
for Unit Testing in
Java

Using QuickTime in a
Production
Environment

Googlebot Deepbot
and Freshbot FAQ

Simple Reasoning on
Google/Blogger

Preserving the Sound
of America

Very Busy Day
Google buys Pyra
Labs

0wn3d by G00g13
Pretentious? or Just
an Ass?

Blogger: The New 500
Pound Gorilla of the
Blog World

iDVD Nightmare
If you want your
government to adhere
to the Constitution

Green-Fredricksen
Dan Gillmor: Google
buys Pyra in big
boost for blogging

EVMS 1.9.0 released
Wicked's Developer
Suite WK Beta

Economic downturn
brought high fliers
down to earth

History's unsung
heroes

Beaucoup
tribulations:
French, Americans
give each other the
eye

Google Buys Pyra
Makers of Blogger

Google Buys Blogger
Getting the best
resumes from HR
requires a little
elbow grease

Writing DHTML that
meets the
cross-platform
challenge

Google buys Blogger
maker Pyra

OS X Screen Capture:
SnapzProX

Revamps to
Commenting and RSS

PHP Class 'Date and
Time Manipulation'
released

Eggers v the
establishment

Not Scripting News
"Bold, Yet Ethereal"
AltaVista - Small
Screen Search Option

Look Ma, No Downtime
Hall buys billboards
on the information
superhighway

what is grok?