stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags







Ontology is Overrated: Categories,
Links, and Tags

Ontology is Overrated: Categories,
Links, and Tags
06/05/2005 10:57 PM

Today I want to talk about categorization, and I want to convince you that a lot of what we think we know about categorization is wrong. In particular, I want to convince you that many of the ways we're attempting to apply categorization to the electronic world are actually a bad fit, because we've adopted habits of mind that are left over from earlier strategies. I also want to convince you that what we're seeing when we see the Web is actually a radical break with previous categorization strategies, rather than an extension of them. The second part of the talk is more speculative, because it is often the case that old systems get broken before people know what's going to take their place. (Anyone watching the music industry can see this at work today.) That's what I think is happening with categorization. What I think is coming instead are much more organic ways of organizing information than our current categorization schemes allow, based on two units -- the link, which can point to anything, and the tag, which is a way of attaching labels to links. The strategy of tagging -- free-form labeling, without regard to categorical constraints -- seems like a recipe for disaster, but as the Web has shown us, you can extract a surprising amount of value from big messy data sets. - More at http://shirky.com/writings/ontology_overrated.html




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags

Grok Headline matches for Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags

Tags Turning Web Chaos into Categories


Tags Turning Web Chaos into Categories 03/22/2005 03:21 PM
Individual users are getting the power to help classify the Web as emerging online services embrace a new twist on metadata.

AvalonRF Debuts its UAV links with TAGs
New Aerial UAV Close Surveillance
Capabilities at the 77th Oscars


AvalonRF Debuts its UAV links with TAGs
New Aerial UAV Close Surveillance
Capabilities at the 77th Oscars
03/14/2005 05:06 PM
AvalonRF Debuts its 'No Moving Parts" Tracking Antenna Receiver and UAV links with TAGs New Aerial UAV Close Surveillance Capabilities at the 77th Oscars [PRWEB Mar 2, 2005]

Wists new features - exploiting tags to
improve a search engine - global search
over users, tags and items


Wists new features - exploiting tags to
improve a search engine - global search
over users, tags and items
03/14/2005 04:33 PM
We've added a global search feature to Wists. The search will look up users, tags and individual item titles and...

Ipod Overrated?


Ipod Overrated? 04/11/2005 05:54 AM

Is Ulysses Overrated?


Is Ulysses Overrated? 02/16/2004 04:02 PM
With the centenary of the first Bloomsday coming later this year, the scene for a showdown between Joyceans, literary critics and generic whiners of all sorts has been set. The perennial debate regarding the worth of James Joyce's Ulysses has been sparked off yet again by a dude called Roddy Doyle.

The case of the overrated mystery novel


The case of the overrated mystery novel 01/07/2004 05:37 PM
Robert Parker, Dennis Lehane, Lawrence Block, Michael Connelly -- I've read them all. Amid the logrolling and endless hype, one thing gets obscured: Raymond Chandler and Ross Macdonald did it first, and did it a lot better.

Overblown, overrated, overhyped


Overblown, overrated, overhyped 04/26/2004 01:01 PM
Too many open source advocates complain about Microsoft writing terrible buggy software and think that open source developers do it better. The truth is Microsoft is innovative, has vision, and executes well. If open source developers can do as well as Microsoft, it's a big compliment. Smart people like Miguel de Icaza and Brendan Eich have known this for a long time. Miguel has a reality check for these innocent virgins, giving his assessment of the potential of XAML and Avalon.

Brendan (one of the Mozilla leads) has a frank assessment of Mozilla too. Not too positive. I talked about this last year.

However i think that Miguel and Brendan are just hyping things up. XAML and Avalon may be great technology but no one is waiting for Longhorn to implement web based apps - everyone is implementing them NOW!

tri: An introduction to Avalon by Charles Petzold.


CNN.com - 'Friends': The most overrated
comedy ever - Feb. 12, 2004


CNN.com - 'Friends': The most overrated
comedy ever - Feb. 12, 2004
02/17/2004 04:00 AM
“Friends”: The most overrated comedy ever .. it still sucks .. is

cnn.com/2004/SHOWBIZ/TV/02/12/apontv.friends.ap/index.html
track this site | 5 links


iBetX Data Shows Google to be Overrated


iBetX Data Shows Google to be Overrated 08/12/2004 03:02 PM
Casino City Times Aug 12 2004 6:45PM GMT

TM-Ontology-KIF-0.02


TM-Ontology-KIF-0.02 07/26/2004 05:35 AM

TM-Ontology-KIF-0.01


TM-Ontology-KIF-0.01 07/26/2004 12:44 AM

Gene Ontology


Gene Ontology 10/30/2003 04:56 PM
Seeking community input on requiring Java 1.4 for DAG-Edit

Ontology Generator


Ontology Generator 12/30/2003 08:30 AM
Ontology Generator
http://progos.hu/ontol ogy_generator.html

Ontology Generator can be used to generate RDF Schema (RDFS), owl or daml+oil, from an uploaded RDF file, RDF file URL or from RDF pasted directly into the page.

Epistemology and Ontology of Programmers


Epistemology and Ontology of Programmers 06/17/2004 11:54 AM
A new paper by David King and Chris Kimble of York Univerisity explores the philisophical assumptions about reality behind common software design methods. The paper, titled "Uncovering epistemological and ontological assumptions of software designers" (PDF format), explains that object-oriented design is not based on a rationalist epistemology but, instead, argues that knowledge is the result of observation. OO design further relies on the assumption that once a description is derived by observing reality, the two somehow remain synchronised, allowing a programmer to learn new things about reality by studying his description of it! A "holistic" design method also described seems to be the only method denying the equivalence of both the programmer's mental model to reality and the programmer's code to his mental model. This seems most likely to me but the paper points out embedded software applications in which an almost exact match between model and reality exists. A simplified slide-presentation (PDF format) of the paper is also available. Okay, it's not specifically robotics related, but I found it very entertaining.

Web Service Modeling Ontology


Web Service Modeling Ontology 04/27/2004 05:56 AM
Web Service Modeling Ontology
http://www.wsmo.org/

The SDK WSMO working group, part of the SDK Cluster aligns the research and development efforts in the areas of Semantic Web Services between the SEKT, DIP and Knowledge Web research projects. Members of this working group include key participants with expertise in Semantic Web-related research areas. It is the mission of the SDK WSMO working group to, through alignment between key European research projects in the Semantic Web Service area, further the development of Semantic Web Services and works toward further standardization in the area of Semantic Web Service languages and to work toward a common architecture and platform for Semantic Web Services. WSMO working group includes the WSML working group, which aims at developing a language called Web Service Modeling Language (WSML) that formalizes the Web Service Modeling Ontology (WSMO). This has been added to the Semantic Web Research section of Deep Web Research Information Blog.

OWL: Web Ontology Language - Overview


OWL: Web Ontology Language - Overview 12/17/2003 03:49 AM

"All categories"


"All categories" 04/14/2004 10:32 PM

If Ontology, Then Knowledge: Catching Up
With WebOnt


If Ontology, Then Knowledge: Catching Up
With WebOnt
05/23/2002 10:39 PM

Web Ontology Language (OWL) - Guide
Version 1.0


Web Ontology Language (OWL) - Guide
Version 1.0
11/11/2002 06:02 AM

Requirements for a Web Ontology Language
Updated


Requirements for a Web Ontology Language
Updated
07/09/2002 06:29 PM
9 July 2002: The Web Ontology Working Group has released an updated Working Draft of requirements for the Ontology Web Language (OWL) 1.0. Automated tools can use common sets of terms called ontologies to power services such as more accurate Web search, intelligent software agents, and knowledge management. Read about the W3C Semantic Web Activity. (News archive)

Standard Animal Behaviour Ontology


Standard Animal Behaviour Ontology 11/18/2003 06:59 AM
SABO

OWL Web Ontology Language Is a W3C
Proposed Recommendation


OWL Web Ontology Language Is a W3C
Proposed Recommendation
12/15/2003 04:32 PM
2003-12-15: W3C is pleased to announce the advancement of the OWL Web Ontology Language (OWL) to Proposed Recommendation. Comments are invited through 19 January. OWL is used to publish and share sets of terms called ontologies, supporting advanced Web search, software agents and knowledge management. Read about the Semantic Web Activity. The OWL language is presented in six parts. (News archive)

POWL - web based ontology editor


POWL - web based ontology editor 04/21/2004 11:34 AM
Second Release

Amazon and Ebay would be useless without
an ontology


Amazon and Ebay would be useless without
an ontology
12/02/2003 01:05 AM
Clay Shirky is continuing to set himself up as the anti-semantic web guy. Its an easy target and good for...

Guardian Unlimited Books | News |
Overlong, overrated and unmoving: Roddy
Doyle's verdict on James Joyce's Ulysses


Guardian Unlimited Books | News |
Overlong, overrated and unmoving: Roddy
Doyle's verdict on James Joyce's Ulysses
02/12/2004 06:26 AM
Overlong overrated and unmoving: Roddy Doyle's verdict on Ulysses .. has courted controversy for his confession .. Literary mud-slinging! .. riporta .. disses

books.guardian.co.uk/news/articles/0,6109,1144626,00.html
track this site | 5 links


Categories are back, and better!


Categories are back, and better! 06/05/2005 11:55 PM

If you've got sharp eyes, you might have noticed that categories have made their way back onto megnut.com entries. As part of my "slow but steady" redesign process, I've recategorized all my entries into topics more manageable than I had before. I haven't set up any category archive pages yet, but will at some point soon. I don't know whether this will be useful or not, but it seemed like a good idea to me.


winning categories


winning categories 01/26/2004 05:20 PM
a list of winners .. Golden Globes .. winners

hfpa.org/realtime.html
track this site | 4 links


MagPortal Categories


MagPortal Categories 05/21/2004 05:41 AM
MagPortal Categories - Current and Archived Magazine Articles by Category
http://magportal.c om/sitemap.html#categories

A very comprehensive listing of current and archived magazine articles broken down into selected categories. This has been added to Research Resources Subject Tracer™ Information Blog. This will be added to Academic Resources 2004 Internet MiniGuide.

Different templates for different
categories


Different templates for different
categories
09/09/2004 03:40 AM

Here’s some more cleaning out my idea database. This is yet another half-conceived idea that if you want to take it, flesh it out, and run with it, it’s yours.

I get asked on occasion how to get Movable Type to use a different templates for each category on the blog. Now that you can segment your site with subcategories, I suspect that more people will want to do this. So here’s a rough outline of how. Please don’t link to this as a tutorial. I don’t want confused MT users to have to sift through my barely coherent ramblings. But if you want to write up a tutorial on how to do this, put a link to it in the comments.

Read more » (252 words)

Dynamic categories


Dynamic categories 01/16/2004 11:27 AM
A while back I stopped assigning the items I post here to categories. It wasn't because I couldn't be bothered to do the categorization. Quite the contrary, I'm really interested in achieving that result, and more than willing to put some effort into it. But, although I'm generally a huge proponent of the publishing technique I call static serving of dynamically-generated pages, it increasingly seemed like the wrong way to deal with categories. ...

Features: Ontology Tools Survey,
Revisited


Features: Ontology Tools Survey,
Revisited
07/14/2004 06:56 PM
Michael Denny updates his original survey of tools for creating ontologies, including the W3C's OWL Web Ontology Language.

Ontology Building: A Survey of Editing
Tools


Ontology Building: A Survey of Editing
Tools
11/06/2002 08:34 PM
Ontologies, structured depictions or models of known facts, are being built today to make a number of applications more capable of handling complex and disparate information. Michael Denny surveys the tools available for creating and editing ontologies.

Digital Harbor Docks Ontology for SOAs


Digital Harbor Docks Ontology for SOAs 08/02/2004 08:18 AM
The software maker uses ontology rules to tie disparate applications together.

How dynamic categories work


How dynamic categories work 01/22/2004 02:05 PM
In the spirit of the lightweight browser-based solution, I decided to create an equally lightweight server-based version based on Python and libxml2/libxslt. (I'm also working on a slightly heftier, but more powerful variation based on Berkeley DB XML; we'll explore that one next time.) [O'Reilly Network]
...

Ad-hoc categories and information
architecture


Ad-hoc categories and information
architecture
04/19/2004 01:43 PM

Ad Hoc Categorizations and the Emergence of Context Effects: "We discuss how marketers may actively affect categorization processes to increase product appeal, for example, in brand extensions and other category-based product evaluations."

I am looking at Ad-hoc categories (and came across the link above) and what they mean for information architecture.

Ad-hoc categories are categories like "things to take on a camping trip" - they can be created immediately and form a category, even if they didn't exist before. I believe that's the definition.

They have specific properties (for example, their members can have nothing in common other than the fact of their membership, while still showing gradation-of-membership effects.), and are already being used on the web (for example Amazon's "People who bought this book also bought" looks like an ad-hoc category.)

Of course, your copy of Women, Fire and Dangerous Things has some things to say about ad hoc categories, and Lawrence W. Barsalou did research talking about how these are goal-derived categories (I look at ad-hoc categories as a bit broader than goal-derived categories. The Amazon example isn't goal-derived, for example, but it's ad-hoc.).

I'm just starting my investigations into this particular intersection of information architecture and cognitive psychology, any ideas are very welcome.


Web Ontology Language (OWL) Guide
Working Draft Published


Web Ontology Language (OWL) Guide
Working Draft Published
11/08/2002 08:17 PM
8 November 2002: The Web Ontology Working Group has published its First Working Draft of the Web Ontology Language (OWL) Guide. The OWL Guide demonstrates the use of OWL to formalize a domain by defining classes and properties of those classes; define individuals and assert properties about them, and reason about these classes and individuals to the degree permitted by the formal semantics of the OWL language. Read about the Web Ontology Working Group. (News archive)

Categories Of Unsolicited Commerical
E-Mail


Categories Of Unsolicited Commerical
E-Mail
02/16/2004 06:49 PM
Macleans Online Feb 16 2004 10:10PM GMT

FREE RSS News Feeds from Moreover. More
than 330 Categories.


FREE RSS News Feeds from Moreover. More
than 330 Categories.
12/17/2004 06:28 PM
Moreover Technologies Dec 17 2004 9:11PM GMT

Nore that Overall, Libraries Don't Fall
into Any One of the Three Categories *


Nore that Overall, Libraries Don't Fall
into Any One of the Three Categories *
06/03/2004 11:42 PM

RSS Feeds Can Build Web Traffic, but Fence Sitters Note Problems

"Richard Miller's creative use of script is not unique, especially given that RSS relies on open standards using XML. The Web is as littered with scraped feeds as it is with the orange XML and RSS boxes widely used to identify that a site offers its own feeds.  Miller and his fellow readers aren't stressed about business models or strategic planning. They know content feeds can be done. They think it makes their lives easier. They either find a way to do it or they move on, abandoning sites that don't make the effort to provide feeds.

Today's online news universe might be divided into outlets that have joined the RSS ranks, ones that have declined and those that continue to take a close look.... [*]

He added: 'It's so convenient. I just can't go to the Web site every day and make it a priority to look for stories that interest me. I just won't use it if it's not an RSS feed.'

Even an imperfect feed was better than none to him and to the users he's heard from who are disappointed about losing his WSJ.com feed. Fortunately for them, Dow Jones has caught on to the interest in RSS and plans to launch an RSS feed "in coming weeks" for the main sections of the Online Journal, Jessica Perry, VP-business development, said via e-mail.  Like Miller's set-up, full stories will be available only to subscribers." [OJR, via Scripting News]

I believe the term the article's author was looking for is "RSS bigot."  ;-)  More from the article:

"The Christian Science Monitor's csmonitor.com started in October 2002 with 1,000 RSS files served; last March it served nearly three million. Sites adding it recently see mounting interest, particularly as more articles about RSS make it into the consumer press.

But news sites that don't offer even a front-page headline feed in this online universe risk becoming irrelevant not only to bloggers who can drive traffic with a mention of a story but to increasingly savvy news consumers like Miller who want control....

'You need to know what it is you're trying to get out of having an RSS feed,' cautions Eric Bauer, information architect for Boston.com. 'Early adopters looked at RSS as something cool that adds a little wow to its site. That phase is over. A lot of people have RSS. It's still not universal by any means but not unique.'  Boston.com is getting 10,000-15,000 page views a week from RSS feeds. Without marketing beyond the RSS link on the front page, traffic has increased 10-fold since the feeds were introduced earlier this year -- partly in response to reader requests."

While libraries can't expect these kinds of numbers any time soon, we're still going to have to provide our information to patrons in their aggregators. Is your library prepared for this?

I'll reiterate that the fastest way to get an RSS feed for your news and announcements is to use blog software. SLS libraries - don't forget that we will host a blog for you for free!


Grok Description matches for Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags
GrokA matches for Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags

Ontology is Overrated: Categories, Links, and Tags

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

The Free IT Network
Vorms
GameNuke
Mortíforo
Speak Clipboard
XAMJ - Alternative
to HTML, XAML, XUL

And Now For Some
Good News

Special Report: Whos
Next?

CIO Dave Barnes and
his company, UPS

Coaching: One-to-one
right the wrong
Watch Carefully
STORE WARS: REVENGE
OF THE [s]IT[h]

Read the Full
Interview

Some new tricks for
finding data

Tech test drive: Web
page design service
is buggy, but holds
promise

Were All Worker Bees
Here

Full Article
The Postive Power of
Chargeback

The Post-PeopleSoft
Landscape

GEICO - Get a Car
Insurance Quote
Today - Sponsored
Link

Seattle Traffic
Dashboard Widget

Random Tiger Notes
Tiger Performance
Boosts

TidBITS: Meet
Automator

Cage Fighter
Write Your Own
Automator Actions

NetNewsWire html
uploader - Automator

Beginning Mac
Development

FlickIt supports
MarsEdit

A Guide to Using
RSS, Which Helps You
Scan Vast Array of
Web Sites

Dictionary Look-Ups
From BBEdit,
Mailsmith, and
TextWrangler

MacSB gathering at
WWDC

Dashboard: Widget
(In)Security

NewsGrowl
XML-RPC for
Textpattern v1.0

Let RSS Go Fetch
How Podcasting Works
ATPM reviews
NetNewsWire 2.0

Who's Hot Today?
Moscow, West
Sacramento

Canada's Sluggish
Market Unites (a
Little)

Coffeeshop Turns off
Wi-Fi on Weekends

Who's NOT So Hot
Today? Tempe,
Arizona

Windows, WPA2, and
Wi-Fi Security

Key Missing Piece
from Microsoft's
WPA2 Support:
Updated Supplicant

Who's Hot Today?
Albany, NY (Buses)

Texas Telecom Bill
Dead

McAfee Buys
Outsource 802.1X
Firm

JiWire Launches
Wi-Fi Discussion
Boards

Ubiquiti Networks
Offers High-Power
mini-PCI

what is grok?