stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Google Toolbar AutoLink







Google Toolbar AutoLink

Google Toolbar AutoLink 03/14/2005 04:24 PM

I'm a bit wary about throwing myself in the middle of the whole Google Toolbar AutoLink business (Dan Gillmor has a good summary and lots of trackbacks to opinions, pro and con), but I'm sort of dumbfounded that so many people are so vehemently against it...at least for the reasons being given. The three main points I've heard articulated by those opposed to the feature are:

1. Browsers and toolbars should not modify the content or layout of Web pages...they should render them only as stored on the Web server.

2. Microsoft tried to do this with Smart Tags in Windows XP and everyone hated it so why are we willing to give Google a pass with a similar feature?

3. Google can unfairly use their growing clout to exploit AutoLink users.

I'll address the second point first because it's sort of beside the point and not an argument at all. One of the big reasons why people were so upset about Smart Tags is that Smart Tags were on by default in early preview releases of IE. The browser was automatically rewriting every single page you loaded, adding links here and there. I agree that this sucks (although users may become used to things like this in the future and not think it's such a big deal), but AutoLink is not on by default. It's optional...you have to specifically push a button to make something happen.

But the main reason people seem to be up in arms about AutoLink is that Google is modifying the content and display of other people's content and that browsers and toolbars should not be allowed to do that. Aside from the first part of that statement being factually incorrect (more on that below), browsers and toolbars already modify other people's content and no one really complains about it. In fact, people love it:

  • Firefox, Safari, Google Toolbar, IE, and several other browsers/toolbars all give end users the option to block JavaScript popups, which typically contain ads. This very much goes against the intention of the content provider and is a clear example of software that modifies a site from how it was intended to be displayed. But users love it so browser/toolbar makers include the feature.
  • Browsers allow users to use custom stylesheets when browsing sites, turn off JavaScript on pages, and browse without viewing images or other multimedia files.
  • There are tons of bookmarklets and browser extensions that let people modify the page they're viewing in interesting ways (this one inserts links to Feedster on NY Times and WaPo article pages).
  • Since the early days of the web right on up to the present, browsers have purposely misrendered badly written HTML so that people could view the pages instead of getting junk or a blank page.

All of these features break the supposedly cardinal sin of "thou shalt not modify the content providers content from the way it was intended by them to be viewed" and I don't hear anyone complaining about it. The fact is, once a user downloads a copy of a content provider's web page from their server, the page becomes just that, a copy. As a user, I should be able to use whatever software is available to me to manipulate, modify, or otherwise remix that copy which I've downloaded for my own personal use. If I can, for my own personal use, photocopy magazine articles, rip my CDs to mp3, make backup copies of my DVDs, and scribble in the margins of books, surely I can do the same with copies of web pages I've downloaded.

Now, if you're against AutoLink because you think Google is becoming too big, they're evil, they're abusing their power, or they bought another blog company instead of yours, then that's fine. Just be up front about why you're upset. It's a trust issue. Do you trust Google's software to do what it says its going to do and not take advantage of you? If the answer is no, don't use it. But if you're saying that Google should not provide this feature at all and that consenting adults in the privacy of their own homes can't choose to use the feature themselves, I don't think that's a good deal for the users. As content providers, let's not try and reach into our readers' computers and dictate what they can or can't do with the copies of our content that they've downloaded for their personal use...let's leave that sort of wishful thinking to the nutballs in Hollywood.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Google Toolbar AutoLink

Grok Headline matches for Google Toolbar AutoLink

Google AdSense ad points to Toolbar
with Autolink Feature!


Google AdSense ad points to Toolbar
with Autolink Feature!
03/14/2005 04:35 PM

insult.JPG Is Google trying to piss me off? You know I have been pretty outspoken on the Google Autolink feature so as you can see this was a Google AdSense that presented itself to me tonight. Talk about adding insult to injury!


Google Gets a Taste of It's Own Autolink
Medicine


Google Gets a Taste of It's Own Autolink
Medicine
03/17/2005 03:55 AM

Google autolink debate frenzy


Google autolink debate frenzy 03/14/2005 05:45 PM
I'm too mired in book work to offer much besides pointers, but here are pointers galore on the important controversy over the Google toolbar Autolink feature -- in which Google offers to overlay its own links to certain types of information that it finds on everyone else's Web pages. In 2001 Microsoft proposed putting something similar right into its Internet Explorer browser, and Walt Mossberg and many others blew the whistle on it. Links should be considered part of the vocabulary of Web content; inserting links is tantamount to tampering with the content.

This time it's been Dave Winer who's been blowing the whistle insistently. Here's Dave's case against Autolink. The opposite point of view -- it's a tool, I should be able to use any tools I want once content lands on my screen! -- is smartly summarized by Cory Doctorow here and here. Paul Boutin in Slate, and Tim Bray, also offer good, careful perspectives.

Me, I think the issue is fundamentally political more than technical; Google is now powerful enough that it needs to learn to tread more lightly in areas like this. My hunch is the Google-ites, encapsulated in their "let's bring all the world's information to light!" mission, simply had no idea what an ethical morass they have plopped themselves into. If the past is any indication, they're nimble enough to step out.

Google Toolbar Update, Google
Bookmarklets


Google Toolbar Update, Google
Bookmarklets
09/10/2002 11:49 PM
Thanks to Milly for sending word of a Google Toolbar update. New features include a Google Answers link and support for URLs that are broken apart (such as wrapped URLs in email). If you're running the toolbar you can use the experimental features setting to search Dictionary.com from the Combined Search button. Milly also has a series of Google bookmarklets, to search different parts of Google and things like the Microsoft Knowledge Base. They don't seem to work in IE5/Mac. If you're using that, you might be more interested in my own Googler or DTRT, which let you search all the Google's from the comfort of your address bar....

Google Toolbar


Google Toolbar 06/06/2004 11:38 PM
†‡ †‡§ŠŠ Toolbar ˆ„ .. the official Google toolbar .. custom browser toolbar .. Google’s Toolbar .. popup ad blocker .. Get you some .. defeated, .. Download .. toolbar .. that

toolbar.google.com
track this site | 3 links


Google Toolbar 2.0.114.5


Google Toolbar 2.0.114.5 09/26/2004 01:15 PM
HardwareGeeks.com Sep 26 2004 5:07PM GMT

Google Toolbar v2.0.107


Google Toolbar v2.0.107 02/18/2004 10:37 PM
Use Google Toolbar to search the web from any site and eliminate pop-up ads. [Freeware 465 KB]

Google Toolbar 3.0.120.7


Google Toolbar 3.0.120.7 04/02/2005 07:23 AM
Techzonez Apr 2 2005 11:56AM GMT

Google Toolbar Updated v1.70


Google Toolbar Updated v1.70 03/11/2003 01:22 AM
Appears to cure widely reported problem of random pr values.

Deconstructing the Google Toolbar


Deconstructing the Google Toolbar 07/25/2002 07:36 AM

New: Google PageRank Toolbar


New: Google PageRank Toolbar 07/14/2004 10:04 AM
Google PageRank Toolbar is a widget for Konfabulator and Safari that monitors what page is active in Safari and shows its Google PageRank.

Google Toolbar Update to v1.63


Google Toolbar Update to v1.63 10/22/2002 03:41 AM
Recent update to 1.1.63 deleon. Doesn't appear to be any new features.

Google beefs up Toolbar


Google beefs up Toolbar 07/15/2004 10:11 AM
Web-User Jul 15 2004 2:05PM GMT

Google Toolbar 3 Beta


Google Toolbar 3 Beta 03/14/2005 04:26 PM
Google Toolbar 3 beta has been released. New features:SpellCheck: Whenever users type into a web form (including web-based email, discussion forums, and intranet web applications), SpellCheck instantly reviews and suggests corrections. The AutoFix option enables users to automatically check and...

Google Toolbar for Mozilla


Google Toolbar for Mozilla 06/12/2002 03:20 PM
The Googlebar for Mozilla project has released version 0.4.5 of their Mozilla add-on. "While we are in no way affiliated with Google inc, our current release, 0.4.5 Release candidate, emulates all of the basic search functionality of the toolbar, allowing users to easily access a number of specialty searches from their browser [...]".

Google Toolbar Alternatives


Google Toolbar Alternatives 01/24/2003 05:22 AM
One of the downsides of the wonderful Google Toolbar is that there's no version for Netscape or Macintosh users. After praising ...

Google Toolbar Can Browse By Name


Google Toolbar Can Browse By Name 07/24/2004 08:10 AM
PC Magazine Jul 24 2004 12:44PM GMT

French Version of Google Toolbar 3


French Version of Google Toolbar 3 04/02/2005 12:49 AM
WebProNews Apr 2 2005 4:53AM GMT

Google Toolbar Security Warning


Google Toolbar Security Warning 09/21/2004 04:26 PM
Search Engine Journal Sep 21 2004 8:07PM GMT

Google Toolbar Security Flaws


Google Toolbar Security Flaws 09/21/2004 12:53 PM
Search Engine Lowdown Sep 21 2004 4:31PM GMT

Google Toolbar Security Hole


Google Toolbar Security Hole 08/09/2002 01:56 PM
GreyMagic has discovered a series of security exploits in the Google Toolbar. The Register has a summary of them. For their part, Google has released an updated version that will be automatically distributed to users of the toolbar. You're safe if you're running version 1.1.59 or higher. You can check what version you have by going to the Google menu and selecting "About Google Toolbar...". If you're running 1.1.58 or earlier, visit the toolbar website to upgrade....

Google Toolbar Upgrade and Fixes


Google Toolbar Upgrade and Fixes 08/08/2002 10:58 AM
"GreyMagic identified a total of nine vulnerabilities ranging from minor--a Web site operator being able to tell what keys a user is pressing in the Google search field--to serious--the scripting vulnerability."

New Google Toolbar 3 Beta Released


New Google Toolbar 3 Beta Released 03/14/2005 05:16 PM
A few new Google Toolbar features: Word translator, spell check webforms..

New Google Toolbar Brings Browse By Name


New Google Toolbar Brings Browse By Name 09/08/2004 10:04 PM

Google Toolbar suffering from the
'burps'?


Google Toolbar suffering from the
'burps'?
11/13/2003 03:59 PM
Search Engine Lowdown Nov 13 2003 3:23PM ET

MSN rivals Google with its own pop-up
blocking toolbar


MSN rivals Google with its own pop-up
blocking toolbar
01/27/2004 06:39 AM
Revolution Jan 27 2004 10:34AM GMT

Google Toolbar offers browse by name


Google Toolbar offers browse by name 07/15/2004 08:40 AM
In its constant quest to court Web surfers, Google Inc. added a new feature to its toolbar this week that allows users to navigate the Web by typing in a name instead of a URL (uniform resource locator).

Google Introduces Key Name Search into
Toolbar


Google Introduces Key Name Search into
Toolbar
07/15/2004 08:58 AM
Google puts Realnames like functionality into tool bar.

Google Using DivX to Install Toolbar?


Google Using DivX to Install Toolbar? 04/01/2005 01:57 AM
Addict3d.org Apr 1 2005 6:46AM GMT

Netcraft toolbar filters Google


Netcraft toolbar filters Google 12/30/2004 04:55 PM
p2pnet.net Dec 30 2004 7:11PM GMT

Google unveils search box for Windows
toolbar


Google unveils search box for Windows
toolbar
11/06/2003 11:54 PM
Sydney Morning Herald Nov 6 2003 11:10PM ET

Microsoft's MSN Toolbar Rivals Google
Tool


Microsoft's MSN Toolbar Rivals Google
Tool
12/19/2004 03:06 PM
Microsoft on Monday joined the battle for supremacy in desktop search, introducing software for quickly locating files on personal computers that challenges Google's rival product.

Google Adds Browse By Name Feature to
Toolbar


Google Adds Browse By Name Feature to
Toolbar
07/16/2004 10:02 PM
The Google Toolbar ( http://toolbar.google.com ) has a new feature: Browse by Name. Browse by Name allows you to type words into the Internet Explorer address bar and get relevant...

Google Toolbar Page Rank Goes Missing


Google Toolbar Page Rank Goes Missing 06/05/2005 11:27 PM
Currently not being seen on toolbar.

Google Toolbar Introduces Browse By Name
Feature


Google Toolbar Introduces Browse By Name
Feature
07/16/2004 01:16 PM
Source: Search Engine Guide - Though I must admit that thus far, the feature seems to work pretty well, the question of whether or not people will use Browse By Name once the novelty wears off remains. After all, does...

Security Hole in Google Desktop Search
Toolbar


Security Hole in Google Desktop Search
Toolbar
12/22/2004 01:44 AM

Three academic computer scientists have uncovered a serious security hole in the Google Desktop Search Toolbar that was released on October 14th. Dan Wallach, assistant professor of computer science at Rice University and two graduate students, Seth Fogarty and Seth Nielson, have known of the security problem for a month; however, this is the first confirmed report of a serious problem with Google's popular search tool.


New Google Toolbar Feature Rekindles the
Old SmartTag Debate


New Google Toolbar Feature Rekindles the
Old SmartTag Debate
03/14/2005 05:16 PM
The AutoLink feature of the new beta Google toolbar, threatens to refire the incendiary debate over SmartTags.

AOL Joins Google, MSN & Yahoo in the
Search Engine Toolbar Club


AOL Joins Google, MSN & Yahoo in the
Search Engine Toolbar Club
04/24/2004 01:10 PM
Search Engine Journal Apr 24 2004 5:09PM GMT

Google Bundles Toolbar and Desktop
Search Application with WinZip


Google Bundles Toolbar and Desktop
Search Application with WinZip
06/17/2005 07:22 PM

Grok Description matches for Google Toolbar AutoLink
GrokA matches for Google Toolbar AutoLink

Two New Bugzilla Releases, Bugzilla
Website Redesigned


Two New Bugzilla Releases, Bugzilla
Website Redesigned
07/10/2004 09:25 PM

[BUGZILLA] Multiple vulnerabilities in
Bugzilla 2.16.5 and 2.17.7


[BUGZILLA] Multiple vulnerabilities in
Bugzilla 2.16.5 and 2.17.7
07/12/2004 02:16 PM
David Miller (Jul 10 2004)

bugzilla.mozilla.org Upgraded to
Bugzilla 2.19.1+


bugzilla.mozilla.org Upgraded to
Bugzilla 2.19.1+
12/17/2004 06:35 PM

VhaYu Technologies


VhaYu Technologies 03/14/2005 04:20 PM
VhaYu Technologies
http://www.vhayu.com/index.asp

Vhayu delivers the fastest and easiest to use real-time software solutions to the world’s leading financial institutions for the capture and high speed analysis of massive amounts of streaming and historical data. The company's proven software solutions meet the needs of mission critical financial applications which rely on the fastest technology available to perform algorithmic trading, quantitative research, pre & post trade analytics, strategy development, real-time compliance, back testing and market sweeping for best execution. Vhayu’s products are linearly scalable, fault tolerant and cost effective. This has been added to
Financial Sources Subject Tracer™ Information Blog.

Bugzilla-BR


Bugzilla-BR 12/21/2003 10:50 AM
Brazilian Portuguese localization package released

Bugzilla.NET VS.NET Add-In


Bugzilla.NET VS.NET Add-In 12/26/2003 01:40 PM
Project page setup

bugzilla be


bugzilla be 08/02/2004 03:38 PM
bugzilla-be 2.16.6 released

bugzilla-kr


bugzilla-kr 10/31/2003 07:27 PM
All files re-uploaded (archive extraction problem)..

Bugzilla-fr


Bugzilla-fr 12/22/2003 10:09 AM
Version 2.16.4 en test

Bugzilla in Chinese


Bugzilla in Chinese 02/12/2004 02:50 AM
a new bugzilla-cn version had uploaded

Bundle-Bugzilla-0.11


Bundle-Bugzilla-0.11 07/08/2004 05:10 PM

Bugzilla 2.18 Released


Bugzilla 2.18 Released 02/01/2005 09:28 PM

Bugzilla 2.17.5 (Development)


Bugzilla 2.17.5 (Development) 11/04/2003 09:29 PM
A bugtracking system project hosted and used by mozilla.org.

Bugzilla 2.16.4 (Stable)


Bugzilla 2.16.4 (Stable) 11/04/2003 09:29 PM
A bugtracking system project hosted and used by mozilla.org.

Bugzilla Bug Squashed


Bugzilla Bug Squashed 12/30/2002 12:47 PM
The popular open-source bug-tracking system has a potentially harmful bug of its own.

Bugzilla 2.16.6 (Old Stable)


Bugzilla 2.16.6 (Old Stable) 07/11/2004 02:20 AM
A bugtracking system project hosted and used by mozilla.org.

Bugzilla Test Runner


Bugzilla Test Runner 02/01/2005 09:12 PM
New version released

Bugzilla 2.18rc2 (Stable)


Bugzilla 2.18rc2 (Stable) 08/01/2004 09:35 PM
A bugtracking system project hosted and used by mozilla.org.

Bugzilla meets the press


Bugzilla meets the press 02/01/2005 09:42 PM
This morning's Romenesko brought this link to a Sacramento Bee column about how some newspapers have begun to use databases to track errors and corrections. Reasonable enough, but maybe not far enough, and it got me thinking.

Software development teams have used bug tracking software for ages now -- why not journalists? But keeping it in-house, as the papers the Bee cites seem to do, limits the value of the approach.

I'm spending a lot of time these days around open-source software developers, and they take the logic of this approach one step further: Major open source projects maintain public bug databases. Anyone can come along and post a bug report. It's like opening a trouble ticket: developers will have a look, see if your complaint is new or duplicates an existing problem; over time the database provide a permanent record of the resolution (or non-resolution) of the issue.

The model doesn't map perfectly onto journalism, but it's not too far off: Let people file "bug reports" if they believe your publication has published something in need of correcting. The publication can respond however it seems appropriate: If the complaint is frivolous, you point that out; if it's a minor error of spelling or detail, you fix it; if it's a major error, you deal with it however you traditionally deal with major errors -- but you've left a trail that shows what happened. However you respond, you've opened a channel of communication, so that people who feel you've goofed don't just go off to their corners (or their blogs!) feeling that you're unresponsive and irresponsible.

I know this idea will horrify a lot of editors and reporters, but I think an adventurous newsroom could benefit from the transparency and the accountability. Maybe someone's already doing this out there -- if so, it would be great to see what we can learn.

Bugzilla 2.18rc1 (Stable)


Bugzilla 2.18rc1 (Stable) 07/11/2004 02:20 AM
A bugtracking system project hosted and used by mozilla.org.

Bugzilla Security Problems


Bugzilla Security Problems 08/26/2002 06:33 PM
Noel Davis looks at buffer overflows in PostgreSQL, and UnixWare and Open UNIX's ndcfg; and problems in PHP, scponly, the kernel supplied with Red Hat Linux 7.3, Bugzilla, EPIC Script Light, UnixWare DNS Resolver, Mantis, an exploit for the Cisco IOS TFTP Server bug, and Red Hat's tcl/tk and expect.

Seguimiento de fallos con Bugzilla en
Linux


Seguimiento de fallos con Bugzilla en
Linux
03/22/2005 04:59 PM

Open-Source Bug Tracking with Bugzilla


Open-Source Bug Tracking with Bugzilla 04/27/2004 06:01 AM
How Bugzilla can help any project tracks job tasks as well as bugs.

[CLA-2003:774] Conectiva Security
Announcement - bugzilla


[CLA-2003:774] Conectiva Security
Announcement - bugzilla
11/05/2003 04:53 PM
Conectiva Updates (Nov 05 2003)

[BUGZILLA] Security Advisory -
information leak


[BUGZILLA] Security Advisory -
information leak
11/10/2003 11:39 PM
David Miller (Nov 09 2003)

Linux Netwosix Bugzilla - Bugtracking
System


Linux Netwosix Bugzilla - Bugtracking
System
07/26/2004 12:28 PM
Vincenzo Ciaglia (Jul 25 2004)

Automatic Resolution of Unconfirmed
Bugzilla Bugs


Automatic Resolution of Unconfirmed
Bugzilla Bugs
03/31/2005 02:53 PM

bugzilla.mozilla.org Upgrade Scheduled
for Sunday 12:00pm PST


bugzilla.mozilla.org Upgrade Scheduled
for Sunday 12:00pm PST
01/24/2004 01:14 AM

[BUGZILLA] Security Advisory - SQL
injection, information leak


[BUGZILLA] Security Advisory - SQL
injection, information leak
11/03/2003 01:26 PM
David Miller (Nov 02 2003)

Bugzilla 2.17.7 and 2.16.5 Released, New
Date-Driven Development Plan Detailed


Bugzilla 2.17.7 and 2.16.5 Released, New
Date-Driven Development Plan Detailed
03/06/2004 01:59 AM

Google Toolbar AutoLink

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry: vhayu bugzilla

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

Yahoo! is ten years
old

Micropatron gifts
(L@@K L@@K)

Help a newbie
blogger out

Technorati and the
evolving corporate
conversation

My business
influences

Earworm
New Star Wars
trailer

The Long Tail of
PayPal

Fetch 5.0 enters
beta testing

ThumbsUp 4.1
Apple wins round in
lawsuit against
rumour sites

Microsoft
discontinuing Mac
internet software
client

Site News: Spymac
joins TRUSTe Privacy
Program

Rumors: Get 'em
while they're hot

A few random
thoughts about the
shuffle

BlackBerrys get AIM
and YM services

Apple weighs legal
options with
Luxpro's shuffle
clone

Motorola's V551
seal_fk
Member Page
Spotlight:
kilogram13

IOGEAR introduces
removable Pocket
Card Reader

Aspyr ships Doom 3
for the Mac

Staying creative in
the Mac design world

OCKHAM Alerting
Service

Hyperwords
A Practical Guide to
Managing E-Mail
Overload

Liquid Information
Research Project

Curiae Project
Technology and
Religion

World Wind
VhaYu Technologies
Science and
Technology Resources
on the Web

Asian Tsunami Web
Archive

Pew Internet Report
on Politics and the
Internet

Potential Advantages
Of Semantic Web For
Internet Commerce

V3N11 March 14, 2005
Current Awareness
Happenings On the
Internet: Virtual
Private Library

Virtual Private
Library

CeBIT Attendees
Dodge Picket Signs

CeBIT: 3GB Music
SmartPhone Samsung
SGH-i300

CeBIT: 7MP Camera
Phone Samsung
SCH-V770

CeBIT: Logitech Sony
PSP PlayGear

CeBIT 2005: SLI
Shuttle Surfaces

'Millipede'
Prototype Shown at
CeBIT

CEBIT LIVE:
Moblogging meets
Siemens

CeBIT focus on
security

Cool Gadgets on
Display at CeBIT

Korean firms taking
center stage at
CeBIT

NVIDIA Previews
nForce4 SLI for
Intel at CeBIT 2005

Mobile interactive
television
demonstrated at
CeBIT

Cebit show does more
with media

what is grok?