stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Really Simple Subscription, PII







Really Simple Subscription, PII

Really Simple Subscription, PII 02/01/2005 08:43 PM

There has been a lot of debate following my initial post about Reall y Simple Subscription. Shortly after I suggested using the f eed URI scheme, NetNewsWire developer Brent Simmons came out in favor it, and in the comments to my post we heard that Safari RSS (part of Apple's upcoming Safari 2.0) will use feed:// quite heavily.

But other solutions have been proposed, such as the Universal Subscription Mechanism (USM) authored by Randy Morin. I've spoken with Randy about USM, and he knows that I have a number of issues with the "reflexive auto-discovery" mechanism. However, part of his proposal includes convincing feed producers to provide the correct Content-Type header for their feeds, and I'm 100% in favor of this. Although having the correct Content-Type doesn't entirely solve the problem, it would take us a big step in the right direction.

If you're interested in this topic, be sure to read all the comments beneath Brent Simmons' post, including Danny Ayres' comment that he "can't actually see [much] conflict between these approaches, implementing one doesn't rule out implementing the other." I agree. We'd all be better served if we realized this isn't either/or situation and stopped endlessly debating which solution is better. I'm in favor of feed:// because it's simple for everyone to implement, but I'm also in favor of evangelizing feed producers to use the correct Content-Type. And once it's fleshed out some more and answers my concerns about privacy, I may like Dave Winer's solution as well.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Really Simple Subscription, PII

Grok Headline matches for Really Simple Subscription, PII

Is Subscription the Next Thing?


Is Subscription the Next Thing? 07/15/2004 07:10 PM
Source: John Battelle's Searchblog - Can I imagine giving Google $40 a month to get the WSJ, Times archives, BBC archives, all my favorite blog archives, and whatever other universe of paid content I might want to add elegantly served...

One-Click Subscription


One-Click Subscription 02/01/2005 09:44 PM
Recently, Dave Winer pointed out that there’s a problem in how people go about subscribing to to RSS feeds, and made a proposal to address it. Dave’s idea—essentially One Great Big subscription dispatcher—should work, near as I can tell, so any problems would be around business and politics, not technology. John Robb does some more thinking, as does P hil Windley. If we can’t find the business creativity, Atom has another solution that RSS could maybe borrow...

A $1,700 subscription for free


A $1,700 subscription for free 07/24/2004 03:02 AM
The National Journal opens up its doors to the public for two weeks every four years. Best known for its ann ual vote ratings (which declared John Kerry most liberal senator of 2003), there's also ads galore, snarky coverage of the media, and more polls than you can shake your fist at.

Validate on subscription?


Validate on subscription? 01/18/2004 09:15 AM
I've thought about Brent's proposed compromise, and to borrow a phrase that is a favorite of Tim Bray, I think that there is a way that 80% of the value can be obtained with 20% of the effort.  Is there really a market requirement to be selectively pedantic on a feed by feed basis? ...

Subscription Services


Subscription Services 01/11/2004 07:55 AM
Have you signed up for a subscription service from a web site such as MacUpdate or VersionTracker? Are you planning to? Or does the idea simply disgust you? Let us know. Follow the "Read More" link to the poll.

Please Note: The free subscription to VersionTracker Plus, provided by .Mac, does not count as currently holding a paid subscription.

Like Pixels? Check out MacDesign

Will Subscription Software Take Over?


Will Subscription Software Take Over? 03/19/2003 10:25 PM

Simple and Secure isn't so Simple


Simple and Secure isn't so Simple 09/02/2004 09:24 PM

Software by subscription: What about
support?


Software by subscription: What about
support?
01/05/2005 01:38 PM
ZDNet Jan 5 2005 5:07PM GMT

AOL offers $300 PC with one-year
subscription


AOL offers $300 PC with one-year
subscription
12/04/2003 03:36 PM

Subscription Small Print


Subscription Small Print 03/14/2005 05:06 PM

What happens when you cancel your Napster To Go subscription?


Sun to offer more subscription pricing


Sun to offer more subscription pricing 02/13/2004 04:04 PM
Sun Microsystems Inc. plans to offer subscription pricing for more of its products as part of an effort to ensure a steadier flow of revenue into the company, Sun executives said this week.

MSN Looks to Subscription Gaming for New
Revenues


MSN Looks to Subscription Gaming for New
Revenues
04/22/2004 06:44 PM
MSN rolls out a minor upgrade to MSN Messenger and introduces four new online games as part of the launch.

Impact Online (subscription)


Impact Online (subscription) 04/03/2005 10:39 AM
Theimpactonline.com - Sun Apr 3, 06:51 am GMT

Blogosphere subscription trends


Blogosphere subscription trends 02/01/2005 08:52 PM
We've all seen the hockey-stick curve that shows the blogosphere growing like gangbusters. But I haven't seen much on subscription trends, so I took a look at the public information available in Bloglines. For a given feed you can ask Bloglines to show not just the count of subscribers, but also -- for the "public" subscribers who allow this information to be shown -- their usernames and the dates when they began subscribing. ...

eMusic to relaunch MP3 subscription
service


eMusic to relaunch MP3 subscription
service
09/19/2004 11:26 PM
Indie-focused download site offers music with no copy locks attached

Macromedia pushes subscription plan


Macromedia pushes subscription plan 02/10/2003 12:58 AM
CNET Feb 10 2003 0:15AM ET

An Analysis of MMOG Subscription Growth


An Analysis of MMOG Subscription Growth 07/19/2004 02:44 PM
An Analysis of MMOG Subscription Growth .. MMORPG subscriber growth stats

pw1.netcom.com/~sirbruce2/Subscriptions.html
track this site | 5 links


Voice & Data Online (subscription)


Voice & Data Online (subscription) 12/24/2004 01:06 PM
Voicendata.com - Fri Dec 24, 02:42 am GMT

IBM Boosts Software Toolbox Subscription


IBM Boosts Software Toolbox Subscription 02/26/2003 02:37 PM
Big Blue continues to try to fuel standards-driven Web services adoption by padding its subscription offering for software developers.

Napster gives away music players with
subscription


Napster gives away music players with
subscription
06/17/2004 02:58 PM

IDC: Software subscription gaining
popularity


IDC: Software subscription gaining
popularity
05/25/2004 11:50 AM

Could Google Make it Under a
Subscription Model?


Could Google Make it Under a
Subscription Model?
01/06/2003 09:37 PM
Could Google require subscription fees for searching?

Validate on Subscription (or, my turn to
compromise...)


Validate on Subscription (or, my turn to
compromise...)
01/22/2004 02:40 AM

Sam Ruby proposes that aggregators validate on subscription, and I have to confess that this makes more sense than my stated position of req uiring Atom feeds to be well-formed.

What Sam suggests is that aggregators such as FeedDemon inform of validation errors only when first subscribing to a feed. After informing the user of the fact that these errors might affect how the feed displays, the aggregator should continue to subscribe and not show any further indication that the feed is invalid. The hope is that this would gently persuade feed creators to pay attention to validation problems without stopping end users from reading invalid feeds.

After accepting that Sam's idea makes more sense than my own (which took all of two minutes!), I started coding this into FeedDemon. When a user subscribes to a feed, FeedDemon checks it for well-formedness, and if any problems are found the dialog shown below is displayed:

Proposed validation error dialog

Clicking the "Details" button shows the text of the validation error, and a link to the online Feed Validator provides a way for authors to check the feed for additional problems.

My hope is to include this in the next build of FeedDemon. As always, I'm open to other suggestions, so please post a comment here if you think this can be improved (or if you think it's a bad idea altogether).


MMOG Subscription Analysis Provides New
Insights


MMOG Subscription Analysis Provides New
Insights
08/19/2004 03:15 PM

Icasa probes subscription services


Icasa probes subscription services 04/24/2004 06:44 PM
Sunday Times South Africa Apr 24 2004 11:17PM GMT

DoCoMo retakes subscription crown


DoCoMo retakes subscription crown 07/07/2004 09:04 PM
Japan Times Jul 8 2004 0:52AM GMT

Yahoo! to Search Subscription Sites


Yahoo! to Search Subscription Sites 06/17/2005 07:22 PM

Apple iFlix DVD subscription service


Apple iFlix DVD subscription service 03/26/2005 07:51 PM
Apple hired someone who used to work for the XBox Live subscription service, so AppleInsider are speculating that Apple is considering a subscription model for the iTunes music store. I think it's more likely she's working on the Apple iFlix DVD subscription service (Codename "Celluloid"). With the DVD subscription service you "rent" movies in H.264 format (Apple FAQ, Wikipedia) via an iTunes like program and play them on your Mac Mini in your living room. You can have 4 movies...

Free Wired Magazine Subscription


Free Wired Magazine Subscription 06/29/2004 08:49 AM

cover12_07.jpg imageI used to think these free magazine things were a scam, until we started getting, like, six copies of Seventeen a month. DiscountMags has a free year's subscription to Wired, if you're not already signed up. Sure, it'll have all the stories we've already covered, but you'll get them on shiny paper.
Read [DiscountMags via Slickdeals]


Overture to Charge Compulsory
Subscription Fee


Overture to Charge Compulsory
Subscription Fee
08/10/2004 02:07 PM
Rumors that Overture/Yahoo was about to make major changes to their PFI model have been floating for about a month. Looks like some confirmations are starting to come in.

Microsoft to aid music subscription
services


Microsoft to aid music subscription
services
05/03/2004 12:58 AM
Taking aim at Apple's iTunes Music Store and iPod, Microsoft said Monday that AOL, Disney, Napster and others have agreed to use a new version of Microsoft's media software that will allow consumers who rent, rather than buy, digital music and movies to put those files on portable devices...

What RSS users want: consistent
one-click subscription


What RSS users want: consistent
one-click subscription
01/19/2004 10:42 AM
Saturday's Scripting News asked an important question: What do users want from RSS? The context of the question is the upcoming RS S Winterfest. Dave Winer adds:
I thought we should try to put the focus on people who use the technology, to let them set the agenda for the developers.
Amen. Over the weekend I received a draft of the RSS Winterfest agenda along with a request for feedback. Here's mine: focus on users. In an October posting from BloggerCon I present video testimony from several of them who make it painfully clear that the most basic publishing and subscribing tasks aren't yet nearly simple enough. ...

NNW Subscription to iPod Contacts script


NNW Subscription to iPod Contacts script 02/14/2004 04:05 PM
Doug’s AppleScripts for iTunes: “This script will copy the news items of the selected Subscription in NetNewsWire in vCard format to the Contacts folder of iPod for portable reading.”

Sun extends subscription pricing remit


Sun extends subscription pricing remit 02/13/2004 06:56 AM
Computer Weekly Feb 13 2004 11:11AM GMT

Siebel, IBM to offer subscription apps
to Europe


Siebel, IBM to offer subscription apps
to Europe
04/21/2004 02:29 PM
ZDNet Apr 21 2004 6:48PM GMT

Subscription Model Killing iTunes? Yawn


Subscription Model Killing iTunes? Yawn 02/05/2005 09:39 PM

By Hadley Stern, Apple Matters


Microsoft Readies 'A1' Security
Subscription


Microsoft Readies 'A1' Security
Subscription
01/04/2005 01:08 PM
eWeek Jan 4 2005 4:53PM GMT

CRTC to seek input for subscription
radio


CRTC to seek input for subscription
radio
07/09/2004 10:19 AM
Sympatico Jul 9 2004 2:03PM GMT

Orb scraps subscription fee on remote
media access


Orb scraps subscription fee on remote
media access
03/29/2005 12:09 PM
Orb Networks has scrapped the subscription fee for a service that lets users connect to their PC remotely via a Web browser and watch content including stored video and live television, it said Tuesday.

ADVERTISEMENT

Reducing the Total Cost of Ownership
Learn how to reduce the total coast of ownership in enterprise data management in this case study.


Grok Description matches for Really Simple Subscription, PII
GrokA matches for Really Simple Subscription, PII

Really Simple Subscription, PII

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

TopStyle 3.11
reviewed by
WebReference.com

Dexter Cartoon for
Jan 21, 2005

CSS and RSS: Rivals
or Partners?

I'm a little bit
country?

ANN: FeedDemon 1.5
RC3

IndiBloggies 2004:
The Winners

Dexter Cartoon for
Jan 28, 2005

Link Dump: Jan 31,
2005

FeedBurner is
Subscriber-Friendly

I'm such a geek
Thank God for Steve
Gillmor

The day after my
birthday

Vloggercon is booked
- solid.....

Guidelines for panel
presenters

LinkedIn finally
launches their
business model

Now it all makes
sense.....

God Bless Paolo
Looking into the
belly of the beast

Mating Dinosaurs,
crashed 'puters and
"virus' galore"

Om loves to jump on
hot news

Congrats to Ted
Shelton

Congrats to Jason
and Allie Shellen!

Blog.Marqui.com
Apple Refreshes
PowerBook Line

TiVo Offers SDK to
Extend Service

New Sober Worm
Surfaces

SBC, AT&T to Merge
in $16 Billion Deal

Take Two Hits Home
Run with MLB

Analyst: MS Office
Formats Not Open

Google Becomes
Domain Registrar

Verizon Wireless
VCAST Goes Live

Microsoft Launches
New MSN Search

iPods Could Appear
in Wal-Mart in April

IBM Adds Anti-Theft
Tech to ThinkPad

After CEO, TiVo
President Resigns

Gates: MS Will Be
'Very Responsive'

MSN Updates Desktop
Search Beta

Microsoft Snubs
Enthusiast Sites

What is a
Socio-Technical
System

Folksonomies in
Japanese

| The Register
test from ecto
How to fix Internet
Explorer security
holes

Friendly URLs in
Movable Type

Fighting comment
spam

Spell check for your
browser

RSS feeds and
copyright

Opera vs Firefox
Fighting comment
spam, linking
without google juice
and other reasons to
use the new href
attribute

How to run a program
as another user in
Windows

what is grok?