stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Why Suppress Dissent







Why Suppress Dissent

Why Suppress Dissent 12/19/2004 03:40 PM

Before moving on to the Civil War, it may be useful to say a few words about the special problems posed by dissent in wartime. Criticism of the effectiveness of the military, the preparedness of our troops, the morality of the war, the brutality of casulaties inflicted on noncombatants, the number of American casualties, the wisdom of our generals, and so on can easily be seen as the highest form of patriotism. Indeed, the basic premise of democracy is that criticism of the government improves the quality of decisionmaking. On the other hand, such criticism can readily be cast as disloyal. Civil libertarians are often puzzled by this, but they shouldn't be. Dissent in wartime may improve the quality of decisionmaking, but it may also and at the same time strengthen the enemy's resolve. An enemy that knows we are divided and uncertain will fight harder than it we are united and resolute. It knows that even if it cannot win militarily, it might win (or at least obtain a more favorable settlement) because of domestic American politics. Thus, for those Americans who are firmly committed to the war, dissenters are acting treasonably because they are encouraging the enemy and arguably putting American lives at risk. Their response to dissenters is essentially, "Can't you see what you're doing? You're jeopardizing American soldiers! Just shut up!" Moreover, war unleashes profound passions. Thousands of lives are stake. No one whose child or spouse or friend is in combat wants to hear that he or she is risking life and limb for an immoral purpose. And even less are people willing to hear that when the child or spouse or friend is already dead or grievously wounded. There is a powerful need to rally around the troops and to promise that those who have died have not "died in vain." In such an atmosphere, it is inevitable that dissent will be equated with disloyalty and that the line between the two will be blurred. We have seen some of this even in the current period. It's also important to point out a critical feature of free speech. Few people rationally believe that their decision to sign a petition, send an email, or march in a demonstration will have any effect on national policy. Thus, the benefit to them of speaking out is very small. If they have any reason to fear that doing so will land them in jail, or subject them to government questioning or harassment, or threaten their current or future employment, they will quickly decide that it's not worth the risk to sign the petition, send the email, or march in the demonstration. This is what we mean by "chilling effect." The danger, of course, is not just that a lone individual will be silenced, but that an entire segment of the population that would otherwise be critical of the government will be stifled, thus mutilating the thinking process of the community. Has any of this actually happened since 9/11?




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Why Suppress Dissent

Grok Headline matches for Why Suppress Dissent

Suppress New Windows Revisited


Suppress New Windows Revisited 12/19/2004 03:25 PM
If you're like me, then you hate it when people use target="_blank". If you've installed Firefox 1.0 and are wondering why the suppress new windows advanced pref no longer works, it's because it's been overridden by a new advanced pref. To turn it on, go to about:config and set "browser.tabs.showSingleWindowModePrefs" to true. Or you can add user_pref("browser.tabs.showSingleWindowModePrefs", true); to your user.js file. Then in Tools | Options | Advanced | Tab browsing, a new option appears. You can then force links that open in new windows to open in the current window or a new tab instead. It's an experimental option for now, so it might be a little buggy, but it works for the most part. Update: The feature doesn't work on bookmarklets that open popup windows, like the bugmenot or Post to MT bookmarklets. It opens them in new tabs instead of as a new popup window. Update to Update: There's a pref for diverting window.open() calls too.

Ohio Tries to Suppress Municipal-Fi


Ohio Tries to Suppress Municipal-Fi 12/19/2004 03:18 PM
Esme Vos dissects the latest state bill that caters to incumbent operators: Existing law prevents municipalities--with their tremendous tax-free advantages as opposed to the massive subsidization of telcos and cable operators--from running their own cable TV systems. A modified bill, introduced by a graduate of the colleges of Zig Zigler and Dale Carnegie, adds telecom services to that mix. Esme would like to know which companies are behind this particular emendation to Ohio's law. [link indirectly via GigaOm]...

Outlawing dissent


Outlawing dissent 02/11/2004 07:35 AM
Spying on peace meetings, cracking down on protesters, keeping secret files on innocent people -- how Bush's war on terror has become a war on freedom.

Crushing of dissent


Crushing of dissent 01/11/2004 06:02 PM
The Internet is now basically banned and controlled for all but the elite in Cuba. In Iran, an unelected body has eliminated hundreds of reformist candidates from the general elections. That's what stiffling of dissent looks like. Stare it in the face, and ask your politicians and NGOs and friends to raise their voices against it as loud as they did against the war in Iraq. Promote freedom for people just like you around the world in a nonviolent way. (And I'm not talking about writing Bush to ask for Regime Change)

Dissent will not be tolerated


Dissent will not be tolerated 03/30/2005 02:44 PM
In the latest version of a familiar story, three Denver residents say they were thrown out of a Bush event because they disagreed with the president.

Dissent in the Bunker


Dissent in the Bunker 12/09/2003 05:05 AM
unimpressed .. Newsweek

msnbc.com/news/1002188.asp?0cv=KB10
track this site | 4 links


'Their job is to suppress us
noiselessly; ours is to survive.'


'Their job is to suppress us
noiselessly; ours is to survive.'
11/18/2003 10:12 PM
Victor Serge is one of the missing links in 20th-century history; in at the beginning of the Soviet Union, he saw before almost anyone what a nightmare it was going to be, wrote some prescient books, may have invented the word "totalitarian," knew everybody who was anybody, and was forgotten. Christopher Hitchens tries to remind us (quote and acknowledgment inside).

Do Web Search Engines Suppress
Controversy?


Do Web Search Engines Suppress
Controversy?
01/09/2004 09:55 PM
Do Web Search Engines Suppress Controversy? by Susan L. Gerhart
http://firstmon day.org/issues/issue9_1/gerhart/

Web behavior depends upon three interlocking communities: (1) authors whose Web pages link to other pages; (2) search engines indexing and ranking those pages; and (3) information seekers whose queries and surfing reward authors and support search engines. Systematic suppression of controversial topics would indicate a flaw in the Web’s ideology of openness and informativeness. This paper explores search engines’ bias by asking: Is a specific well–known controversy revealed in a simple search? Experimental topics include: distance learning, Albert Einstein, St. John’s Wort, female astronauts, and Belize. The experiments suggest simple queries tend to overly present the "sunny side" of these topics, with minimal controversy. A more "Objective Web" is analyzed where: (a) Web page authors adopt research citation practices; (b) search engines balance organizational and analytic content; and, (c) searchers practice more wary multi–searching.

O'Jays lose bid to suppress new album


O'Jays lose bid to suppress new album 04/14/2004 10:23 AM

Using Copyright To Suppress Political
Speech


Using Copyright To Suppress Political
Speech
08/11/2004 12:51 AM

"NYT > Opinion > Bob Herbert: Suppress
the Vote?"


"NYT > Opinion > Bob Herbert: Suppress
the Vote?"
08/16/2004 09:55 PM

A Campaign Reporter's Dissent


A Campaign Reporter's Dissent 02/10/2004 02:50 AM
"I really detest horserace coverage," says a reporter for the Worcester Telegram & Gazette. His struggle to realize something better in his reports tells a lot about the state of campaign journalism today.

Online dissent in China


Online dissent in China 11/07/2003 04:19 AM
China's crackdown on online dissent continues. It's been a year since the arrest of Chinese internet dissident Liu Di. Many of her supporters have signed petitions calling for her release, but last week one of their organizers, essayist Du Daobin, was himself arrested.

Iran targets dissent on the net


Iran targets dissent on the net 06/24/2005 02:59 PM
Iran is becoming increasingly sophisticated in its controls of the internet, says a report.

The price of ignoring dissent


The price of ignoring dissent 04/01/2005 01:38 PM
The Bush administration has little tolerance for opposing views. Two new reports show the consequences of not listening.

Kerry Hints GOP May Suppress Black Votes
(AP)


Kerry Hints GOP May Suppress Black Votes
(AP)
09/11/2004 10:00 PM
AP - John Kerry suggested Saturday night that Republicans may try to keep black voters from casting their ballots to help President Bush win in November.

Judge's dissent gives trio 'hope'


Judge's dissent gives trio 'hope' 03/31/2005 03:12 AM
Lawyers for three Irishmen convicted of training Colombian guerrillas, hope the verdict will be quashed.

Dissent Magazine - Spring 2004


Dissent Magazine - Spring 2004 07/17/2004 11:00 PM
Dissent Magazine - Spring 2004 .. review .. more .. more

dissentmagazine.org/menutest/articles/sp04/greif.htm
track this site | 5 links


Dissent on War; Face a Grand Jury


Dissent on War; Face a Grand Jury 02/10/2004 02:41 AM
AP: Feds win right to war protesters' records. In what may be the first subpoena of its kind in decades, a federal judge has ordered a university to turn over records about a gathering of anti-war activists. In addition to the subpoena of Drake University, subpoenas were served this past week on four of the activists who attended a Nov. 15 forum at the school, ordering them to appear before a grand jury Tuesday, the protesters said. Federal prosecutors refuse to comment on the subpoenas.

"with the accusation that the GOP will
try and suppress the African American
vote this election"


"with the accusation that the GOP will
try and suppress the African American
vote this election"
09/13/2004 02:40 PM

what he sees as an attempt to suppress
the black vote in Orlando


what he sees as an attempt to suppress
the black vote in Orlando
08/17/2004 09:01 AM
nytimes piece .. infuriating

nytimes.com/2004/08/16/opinion/16herbert.html?hp
track this site | 3 links


"what he sees as an attempt to suppress
the black vote in Orlando"


"what he sees as an attempt to suppress
the black vote in Orlando"
08/17/2004 03:41 AM

The New York Times > Opinion >
Op-Ed Columnist: Suppress the Vote?


The New York Times > Opinion >
Op-Ed Columnist: Suppress the Vote?
08/16/2004 01:50 PM
Suppress the Vote? .. Bob Herbert column .. reports

nytimes.com/2004/08/16/opinion/16herbert.html?ex=1250395200& en=01a3e0df2ded98f4&ei=5090&partner=rssuserland
track this site | 4 links


Diebold fight to suppress information
lands them in court


Diebold fight to suppress information
lands them in court
11/04/2003 12:49 AM
Diebold who is a bit pissy about having some of it's internal e-mail documents being posted on the web from...

Diebold Attempting To Suppress Leaked
Legal Memos


Diebold Attempting To Suppress Leaked
Legal Memos
04/23/2004 04:27 PM
Ernest Miller writes "Last Tuesday it was revealed that Diebold was informed by its lawyers that what it was doing was most likely illegal (Diebol d Knew They Broke The Law With Uncertified Voting Machines). Where did this information come from? Leaked legal memos from Diebold's law firm, Jones Day. A judge has ordered that all memos not already published on the internet be returned to Jones Day (A New Pentagon Papers Case - Newspapers, Blogs and the Diebold/Jones Day Memos). But, if you can't stop newspapers from publishing the Pentagon Papers, why can you stop a newspaper from publishing memos dealing with important issues regarding voting? Perhaps the lesson for newspapers is that if you think the public should be informed, publish as much as possible and don't try to hold back information for "exclusives." "

In Greece, a Torch Relay to Suppress
Electronic Games


In Greece, a Torch Relay to Suppress
Electronic Games
05/12/2004 08:02 PM
ATHENS.

U.S. Soldier Seeks to Suppress Iraq
Abuse Photos (Reuters)


U.S. Soldier Seeks to Suppress Iraq
Abuse Photos (Reuters)
08/23/2004 06:42 AM
Reuters - A U.S. soldier at the center of the Iraqi prisoner abuse scandal sought on Monday to strike from his court martial potentially incriminating photographs at a hearing before a military judge in Germany.

Vietnam orders crackdown on Internet
dissent


Vietnam orders crackdown on Internet
dissent
05/20/2004 11:22 AM
AFP via Yahoo! May 20 2004 3:23PM GMT

China's crackdown on online dissent
continues


China's crackdown on online dissent
continues
11/07/2003 05:28 AM
The 'mouse' that caused an uproar in China .. Fight the power, Liu Di! .. STAINLESS STEEL MOUSE: .. CS Monitor

csmonitor.com/2003/1106/p01s04-woap.html
track this site | 5 links


Vietnam orders crackdown on Internet
dissent (AFP)


Vietnam orders crackdown on Internet
dissent (AFP)
05/20/2004 10:17 AM
AFP - The Vietnamese government has ordered a crackdown on "bad and poisonous information" being circulated over the Internet just months after tough new rules regulating the use of the web came into force.

Dissent on Intelligence Is Critical,
Report Says (washingtonpost.com)


Dissent on Intelligence Is Critical,
Report Says (washingtonpost.com)
03/30/2005 01:15 AM
washingtonpost.com - A presidential commission assigned to look into the intelligence failures leading up to the Iraq war will recommend a series of changes intended to encourage more dissent within the nation's spy agencies and better organize the government's multi-tentacled fight against terrorism, officials said yesterday.

" Quarantining dissent / How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech "


" Quarantining dissent / How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech "
01/05/2004 09:11 PM

Quarantining dissent / How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech


Quarantining dissent / How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech
01/06/2004 03:19 AM

Quarantining dissent; How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech


Quarantining dissent; How the Secret
Service protects Bush from free speech
01/06/2004 08:05 AM
to never see or hear anyone who might disagree with him .. Disturbing article

sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2004/ 01/04/INGPQ40MB81.DTL&type=printable
track this site | 10 links


"Dissent Magazine - Anti-totalitarianism
as a Vocation An Interview with Adam
Michnik"


"Dissent Magazine - Anti-totalitarianism
as a Vocation An Interview with Adam
Michnik"
05/10/2004 09:53 PM

The New York Times > Books >
Sunday Book Review > The 9/11
Report: A Dissent


The New York Times > Books >
Sunday Book Review > The 9/11
Report: A Dissent
08/30/2004 03:27 PM
New York Times Book Review on the 9/11 Commission's report .. Richard Posner

nytimes.com/2004/08/29/books/review/29POSNERL.html?ex=1251432 000&en=17b9f85a8f8841f4&ei=5090&partner=rssuserland
track this site | 3 links


Grok Description matches for Why Suppress Dissent
GrokA matches for Why Suppress Dissent

Why Suppress Dissent

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

The Civil War
World War I
The "Good War"
The O'Reilly Factor
O'Reilly and the
Cold War

Vietnam and Farewell
NewsGator Announces
Three Key
Partnerships to
Drive RSS Platform &
Adoption

NewsGator Online
Edition FREE to
Consumers

NewsGator Closes
Second Finance Round
& Expands Leadership
Team

TypePad and Movable
Type posting
plug-ins available

bfi-toolkit
PiTiVi
Hive-Transe
The hoarse
whisperer: PHP and
the enterprise myth

I need case studies
Apparently, I have
gone insane

php|architect is
looking for book
authors

Update on my case
study quest

More about php|a
books

php|architect?s
Seven Days of
Christmas

Zend PHP
Certification
Practice Test Book
now available for
preorder ? get your
copy today!

Holiday Express 1.0
Videocue 1.0.3
Lynkeos 1.1
Adventure Inlay 1.0
Bugdom 2 2.0.1
PHP 4.3.10
Otto Matic 2.0.1
Adobe Acrobat Reader
6.0.2

I feel a wave of
flaming gathering in
the west

Links: 2004-12-03
A little project for
you

Content Syndication
with RSS (and Atom,
Second Edition)

Thousands of
clueless web surfers
+ a good aggregation
engine

Google Suggest Beta
Revenge will be
slow, and probably
involve quite a bit
of pain.

Confounded websites
Links: 2004-12-11
Links: 2004-12-12
Links: 2004-12-13
Comment Spamalot
Posted elsewhere
today

Offshoring
Creativity

Web Exclusive: Creme
of the Crop

Marshall Goldsmith:
It's Not a Fair
Fight If You're the
CEO

Poll Position: Gore
Text

The Fabric of
Creativity

FC Now: Feemaster
FC Now: It's the
Little Things

FC Now: eBay's
Latest Move

what is grok?