stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business







California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam,
Will Make It Harder To Do Business

California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam,
Will Make It Harder To Do Business
11/03/2003 11:40 PM

I get inundated with more and more spam every day, and it's frustrating as anything. I want it to stop. However, if politicians insist on passing bad legislation in their attempts to stop spam, that's not going to do any good. I've already complained about the new California legislation and it looks like I'm not alone. A guy who runs a consulting firm and writes for Business Week points out why California's anti-spam law won't do a thing about spam, but will make life more difficult for legitimate small businesses. He describes a situation where he did a very targeted mailing for a company. It's probably up to your definition of spam as to whether or not you consider his mailing spam. I tend to draw the line on whether or not the mailing was "bulk" - which it sounds like his was. I believe that if the email is truly targeted and personalized about a potential business relationship, then it's hard to call it spam. The California law disagrees. In fact, the sponsor of the bill claims that any email contact between two companies is not legitimate if it hasn't been initiated under some other form. That's simply ridiculous. As I've said before, plenty of "commercial" websites contact Techdirt every day about the possibility of partnerships or links. Under California's anti-spam law, I could charge them with spam. I recently heard from a major technology magazine, asking if I would add them to my Quicklinks box. Should I sue them for spam? According to the law, I could.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business

Grok Headline matches for California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business

California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam,
Will Increase Lawsuits


California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam,
Will Increase Lawsuits
11/14/2003 07:29 PM
I hate spam and would like nothing better than to see an effective anti-spam law put on the books. However, as I've said before, the California anti-spam law is not the right law. Plenty of others seem to agree, and everyone believes that the law won't stand up if tested in court. The problem is what do people do until it's been tested? The other question is who is going to take on this law. Luckily, it won't be the Direct Marketing Association, who I don't trust in the slightest. They say they've burned up all their resources fighting the "Do Not Call" list. At a conference among email marketers, some were suggesting that they should file their own lawsuits under the bill in order to purposely clog the court system with such lawsuits. This seems like typical bad marketing thinking that overburdening a system somehow gets extra attention. The right response is that someone who gets sued for doing something that clearly is not spam is going to have to go to court and get the law overturned. Maybe (and this would be the best) it happens to someone who is not associated with an "email marketing" company, but just someone who sends a perfectly reasonable email and gets hit with a lawsuit.

CAN SPAM Designed To Make Congressmen
Look Good - Not Stop Spam


CAN SPAM Designed To Make Congressmen
Look Good - Not Stop Spam
01/07/2004 06:36 PM
We all know now that the CAN SPAM law is a disaster and is unlikely to do anything useful in the battle against spam. It's also becoming clear that the entire point of the bill was never to stop spam, but to make a few folks in Congress look good (which seems to be the entire point of most politics these days). First, Business Week spends some time comparing the mostly effective federal "Do Not Call" list with CAN SPAM. The DNC list was planned out carefully by the FTC and the FCC, and, while it upset many telemarketers, it was designed in a way to be effective. There was also enough time, and enough publicity given to the list that people knew about it and had the opportunity to sign up for it - while marketers had the ability to prepare on their end as well. With CAN SPAM, however, it was rushed through Congress with little thought towards whether or not it would actually do anything and without any money to actually deal with any of these cases. Meanwhile, the NY Times reports that the sponsors of the bill asked the FTC to sue a spammer the very first week the bill was in effect in order to make a big "splash" so they could pat themselves on the back - even as the spam levels continued to increase. FTC Chair Timothy Muris (who has spoken out against this spam law) apparently laughed them off and pointed out it was impossible to do such a thing. First of all, in order to violate the law, the spammers have to ignore an opt-out request. Then, the FTC would have to track down who the actual spammer was - with no additional funds, because the law didn't provide for them.

Anti-Spam Technical Alliance Publishes
Industry Recommendations to Help Stop
Spam


Anti-Spam Technical Alliance Publishes
Industry Recommendations to Help Stop
Spam
06/22/2004 09:17 AM
The Anti-Spam Technical Alliance (ASTA), whose participants include Yahoo! Inc., Microsoft Corp., EarthLink and America Online Inc., today unveiled the result of more than a year of close collaboration by presenting a host of detailed best practices and technical recommendations for the entire industry in an effort to fight the scourge of spam.

Spam, spam, spam, spam ... Canada
targets unwanted email (AFP)


Spam, spam, spam, spam ... Canada
targets unwanted email (AFP)
05/12/2004 04:17 AM
AFP - Canada unveiled a new action plan to combat unsolicited commercial e-mail, nicknamed spam, which jams inboxes and clogs Internet traffic worldwide.

Viruses and spam hit small firms harder


Viruses and spam hit small firms harder 06/15/2004 10:00 AM
Costly diversion

Finance Spam Passing Drug Spam While
Porn Spam Is Washed Up


Finance Spam Passing Drug Spam While
Porn Spam Is Washed Up
05/24/2004 05:37 PM
The latest study on spam trends appears to show that financial spam is outpacing pharmaceutical spam - though, honestly, so much of both is coming out that it's really hard to imagine that this matters at all. Meanwhile, it seems that porn spam is increasingly less interesting to spammers as the numbers have been on a noticeable decline for quite some time. No matter what, though, it appears that CAN-SPAM has done absolutely nothing to slow down the amount of spam sent.

From spam drops to spam spray to spam
stream


From spam drops to spam spray to spam
stream
06/05/2004 07:31 PM
I am now getting 2,000+ spams a day. There are 1,440 minutes in a day The rate of incoming spams is therefore getting close to the interval it takes me to check my email and dispose of a single spam: By the time I'm done checking, more spam has arrived. That is the point at which the spam droplets form a continuous stream. And that is the point at which no interval of my life will ever be spam-free again....

California 'disempowered' by federal
spam law


California 'disempowered' by federal
spam law
01/22/2004 06:18 PM
State Attorney General Bill Lockyer says California will have less protection against spammers under a new federal antispam law that recently superceded a stricter state law.

How to stop spam? Don't look to
legislation


How to stop spam? Don't look to
legislation
12/14/2003 09:50 PM
ZDNet Dec 14 2003 9:16PM ET

Stop Forwarding Spam


Stop Forwarding Spam 04/09/2004 04:11 PM
Advice from LJ's technical manager about how to use a local user account to stop forwarding spam and viruses.

Will California ’ s Spam Law Kill Your
Email Marketing ?


Will California ’ s Spam Law Kill Your
Email Marketing ?
10/29/2003 12:11 AM
You will grow your list fast if your Web site is built to be friendly to Google, which along with its syndicate partners (AOL and Yahoo) will send lots of ...

Easiest and Best Way to Stop mailto:
spam?


Easiest and Best Way to Stop mailto:
spam?
11/17/2002 09:46 PM
"We have published our email addresses on our web sites for almost 10 years using simple mailto: or forms. In the past year, the amount of spam has become intolerable. "

New Spam Law Won't Stop Number One
Spammer


New Spam Law Won't Stop Number One
Spammer
12/29/2003 06:52 PM
Alan Ralsky is famous as one of the top spammers around, so the NY Times went to see what he had to say about the new CAN SPAM law. While he says that he's upset at how "one-sided" it is, it won't do anything to stop him from spamming. He claims that he'll go legit with a real opt-out address in emails, but it's tough to believe that, when he claims in the same article that he's become an expert at hiding his identity in how he sends out spam. He also says that he can't stop spamming because there's "too much money" to be made - even if (he claims) it's been getting more expensive lately to keep ahead of all those filters. It's also amusing to see him blame "the internet" for "forcing" him to hide his identity online. Perhaps, if he wasn't annoying people by bombarding them with crap they didn't want, he wouldn't have had to hide himself.

Stop Spam by charging to email?


Stop Spam by charging to email? 12/12/2003 12:52 PM

Microsoft Moves To Stop Spam


Microsoft Moves To Stop Spam 05/07/2004 10:43 AM
Xposed May 7 2004 2:16PM GMT

Spam King Ordered to Stop


Spam King Ordered to Stop 01/05/2005 04:44 PM
theWHIR Jan 5 2005 8:11PM GMT

Spammers using random words to stop spam


Spammers using random words to stop spam 01/16/2004 10:58 AM
Any administrators worth their salt is going to go after spam on many fronts. As I have stated 2-3 times...

Stop al Spam: No reinventemos la rueda,
evolucionemos


Stop al Spam: No reinventemos la rueda,
evolucionemos
05/04/2004 06:44 AM

"Spam King" Agrees to Stop Spamming For
Now


"Spam King" Agrees to Stop Spamming For
Now
01/05/2005 10:18 PM

Experts Don't Believe Bill Gates Can
Stop Spam


Experts Don't Believe Bill Gates Can
Stop Spam
04/30/2004 02:47 PM
Earlier this year, Bill Gates made a splash by announcing that he was spending much of his time trying to come up with ways to fight spam. Unfortunately, most of the methods he listed have been tried before without much luck. Also, many people pointed out that some of the reason spam is such a problem is because of Microsoft security problems (which were not among the things Gates was looking to fix). Well, now the experts have weighed in and they pretty much agree with everyone else: Bill Gates won't be able to stop spam. In fact, many seem to think it's fairly amusing that he thinks he can.

Users Increasingly Looking To ISPs To
Stop Spam


Users Increasingly Looking To ISPs To
Stop Spam
06/09/2004 10:35 AM
Just as the news comes out that many ISPs are hesitant to filter spam, Gartner is showing that a small, but growing, number of users are getting fed up with their ISPs inability to stop spam, and would be willing to switch ISPs to get better spam protection. The problem right now, of course, is that it's not easy to get good spam filtering without too many false positives. While users say they want better spam filtering, the false positives can be just as big a problem as getting too much spam. Users are able to set up their own spam filters, of course, but they believe it's their ISPs responsibility. This viewpoint is only going to increase, and users will look to their ISPs to protect them against adware, spyware, phishing, trojans and all other types of attacks as well. ISPs have been taking either an ad hoc or a wait-and-see approach for most of this stuff, but it might make sense for them to start coming up with more comprehensive strategies that really focus on protecting their subscribers - and not just giving lip service to the idea.

Mobile scheme aims to stop spam


Mobile scheme aims to stop spam 07/08/2004 10:31 AM
The mobile industry has launched a scheme to give mobile users more control over premium rate texts.

Comcast looks to stop the spam coming
from its network


Comcast looks to stop the spam coming
from its network
05/24/2004 12:19 PM
Infected PCs of Comcast broadband subscribers are one of the largest sources of spam, sending upwards of 800 million e-mails daily. Now Comcast is preparing to fight bac.

Cisco's P-Cube aims to stop spam at
source


Cisco's P-Cube aims to stop spam at
source
09/20/2004 12:54 PM
The start-up, soon to be acquired by Cisco, adds feature to help broadband service providers fight "zombie" attacks.

IBM Unveils Anti-Spam Services to Stop
Spammers


IBM Unveils Anti-Spam Services to Stop
Spammers
03/22/2005 03:39 PM

E-mail postage will line pockets, not
stop spam


E-mail postage will line pockets, not
stop spam
02/10/2004 02:53 PM

Bill Gates Trying To Reinvent The Wheel
To Stop Spam


Bill Gates Trying To Reinvent The Wheel
To Stop Spam
01/23/2004 11:00 PM
Now that he's no longer running the business side of Microsoft, Bill Gates has apparently turned his attention to spam. That's right, in his spare time, he's been messing around with a variety of ways to solve the spam problem, though, it sounds like all of his ideas are already being tried elsewhere. I guess that's not all that surprising considering Microsoft's history. What will be more interesting is whether or not he can get any of these methods to really work. The first is using basic sender authentication via a challenge-response solution. His second idea is basically greylisting (making servers slow down emails from unknown senders to make it more difficult/expensive for spammers to send out so many messages), which seems to be getting some more attention these days. His final idea, though, which he seems to have the most faith in, is a money-based plan to charge unknown senders to email you. The idea is that you would set a price for unknown people to email you - but you have the option of waiving that fee if it turns out you really wanted to hear from someone. I've heard of people talking about similar plans, but have never heard of it being implemented.

When Software Fails to Stop Spam, It's
Time to Bring In the Detectives


When Software Fails to Stop Spam, It's
Time to Bring In the Detectives
05/31/2004 02:19 AM
The fight against spam has turned from software engineers who try to identify and block spam to private investigators, prosecutors and law enforcement agents.

Northern And Southern California
Businesses For Sale Dipped This Past
Week To 324 Business & Franchise Sales.
These Small Businesses Were Sold By
Business Brokers, Small Business Owners,
& Real Estate Agents Throughout
California.


Northern And Southern California
Businesses For Sale Dipped This Past
Week To 324 Business & Franchise Sales.
These Small Businesses Were Sold By
Business Brokers, Small Business Owners,
& Real Estate Agents Throughout
California.
06/23/2004 03:08 AM
Northern And Southern California Businesses For Sale Dipped This Past Week To 324 Business & Franchise Sales. These Small Businesses Were Sold By Business Brokers, Small Business Owners, & Real Estate Agents Throughout California. [PRWEB Jun 23, 2004]

Make Love Not Spam


Make Love Not Spam 12/19/2004 03:08 PM
About a month or so ago, Lycos Europe started beta testing a screen saver that uses a computer's idle time and spare bandwidth to launch pester requests at blacklisted Spam domains.

How to make spam unstoppable


How to make spam unstoppable 02/10/2004 02:47 AM
A researcher has found a way to get past the filters many people use to stop junk mail reaching their inbox.

Tomorrow's Menu: Spam, Spam, Spam


Tomorrow's Menu: Spam, Spam, Spam 12/11/2003 06:15 AM
Congress overwhelmingly passes a bill to fight the online scourge, but critics say the unwanted e-mail will increase because the law will actually legitimize spam. By Amit Asaravala.

Microsoft Applauds Spam Enforcement
Action by State of California and
Federal Trade Commission


Microsoft Applauds Spam Enforcement
Action by State of California and
Federal Trade Commission
04/13/2005 10:58 PM
Microsoft Corp. today praised California Attorney General Bill Lockyer and the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) for their filing of a joint lawsuit on Tuesday against defendants allegedly responsible for initiating the transmission of millions of commercial e-mail messages since Jan. 1, 2004.

Move over spam, make way for "spit"


Move over spam, make way for "spit" 09/24/2004 11:37 PM

Chinese make beautiful spam music


Chinese make beautiful spam music 05/11/2004 10:41 AM
Ode to perlite - wonder material

EU ruling set to can business spam


EU ruling set to can business spam 07/05/2004 07:57 AM
Opt-out clause

Article: Move over spam, make way for
"spit" | New Scientist


Article: Move over spam, make way for
"spit" | New Scientist
09/25/2004 09:51 PM

Review: Advanced Spam Manager Attacks
Viruses, Spam For Exchange, Notes


Review: Advanced Spam Manager Attacks
Viruses, Spam For Exchange, Notes
03/27/2005 12:35 PM
Information Week Mar 27 2005 3:25PM GMT

Article: Move over spam, make way for
"spit" | New Scientist


Article: Move over spam, make way for
"spit" | New Scientist
09/24/2004 08:08 PM
The trinity of net annoyance: Spam, Spim and SPIT

newscientist.com/news/news.jsp?id=ns99996445
track this site | 3 links


Grok Description matches for California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business
GrokA matches for California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business

California Spam Law: Won't Stop Spam, Will Make It Harder To Do Business

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

Longer Report on
Apple's WPA Support

tijOS
jwall
E-voting vendor sued
for DMCA takedown

I think I'm
beginning to get
stressed out

Ted Leung joins OSAF
Dead Internet web
sites piling up

phpwsContacts -
phpWebSite Contacts
Mod

ptyaim
OpenRM Scene Graph
QuickRAM Operating
System

nroppix
Panther FileVault
Troubles?

MusicMatch vs.
iTunes on the
Desktop

ABC's 60 Minutes is
absolutely not fair
and balanced

Windows XP Service
Pack 2 is coming

Network
Communication
Magazines

Matrix Revolutions
ECG (Emulation Code
Generator)

I love pancakes
Intel snags market
share from AMD

Veritas announces
data-tracking
product

MTV eyes digital
music store by early
2004

The Benefits Of
Booze

Steve Earle vs. Bill
O'Reilly

ViewIt 2.3
AquilaCalendarMB
1.13

shadowIP 2.1
PsyncX 2.1.1
My Favorite Things
1.0.1

Meridian 1.1.0
Freeway 3.5.11
MacAstronomica 2.0.3
EchoMac 1.12
Safari 1.0
Cro-Mag Rally 2.2
IBM in, Intel out of
Xbox?

P800 users petition
for P900
functionality.

OctigaBay crafts
58-Gflops Opteron
MPP.

MusicMatch warns of
iTunes for Windows
problem

Secure HTML Lock
v1.2.7

Alchemy Eye Pro v5.4
MR Tech Systray v3.0
Alpha Preview 1 -
Refresh 3b

MegaSeg DJ plays
nice with Panther,
adds features

kbvote
Adding Style To
Substance

Internet Engineer
for a Search Engine

Musicmatch Tries To
Stay Plugged Into
iPod

The Most Wonderful
Time Of The Year

Musicmatch tries to
stay plugged into
iPod

what is grok?