stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act







The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On
The INDUCE Act

The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On
The INDUCE Act
07/14/2004 08:57 PM

Ernest Miller writes "Techdirt has already brief ly discussed the RIAA's letter defending the INDUCE Act. Now, you can read the RIAA's ori ginal letter, the abridged version, or the excessiv ely annotated version." No offense to Ernest, who put a lot of work into the excellent annotated version, but if you only have time for one, check out the abridged version.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act

Grok Headline matches for The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act

The Abridged RIAA Letter on the INDUCE
Act


The Abridged RIAA Letter on the INDUCE
Act
07/15/2004 01:30 AM

I know we all did not want to be bored and read the lengthy letter the RIAA sent to each member of congress well a readers digest version has been posted a must read. [Corante< /a>]


RIAA Sends Letter to Senate Supporting
INDUCE Act


RIAA Sends Letter to Senate Supporting
INDUCE Act
07/15/2004 11:51 AM

The Importance of...: The Obsessively
Annotated Introduction to the INDUCE Act


The Importance of...: The Obsessively
Annotated Introduction to the INDUCE Act
06/25/2004 04:10 AM
this detailed analysis .. deconstructs .. withering

corante.com/importance/archives/004563.html
track this site | 4 links


RIAA's INDUCE Act letter deconstructed


RIAA's INDUCE Act letter deconstructed 07/15/2004 05:31 AM
The RIAA has sent a letter to Congress, calling on it to pass the iPod-criminalising INDUCE Act. Ernest Miller has deconstructed the letter line by line, countering its claims.
That taking has consequences, human and creative. [Some of the consequences are good, some are bad. Separating them, however, is a pain and may not be possible.] My companies make money almost exclusively from the sale of our creative product. [And they still can, they will have to make some adjustments to their business model.] We don't have a performance right on radio and therefore derive no income from radio play. [Welcome to the wonderful world of "when Congress tries to dictate business models." And so, the RIAA proposes a sequel.] We don't make money from artist tours or merchandise. [And why is that? Is there a law against it? If so, I would recommend it be repealed.] We don't make money from endorsements of other products. [Is someone stopping them from doing that?] We just sell recorded music. [You're free to structure business however you like.]

We take profits from sales – when we're good and lucky enough to get them - and plow money back into the search for that next great talent who will thrill music fans around the globe. [I guess the industry must have been bad these last few years.] When we think we have found that talent, we invest huge amounts to sign, nurture, promote and distribute their creative product. [And the RIAA is the only way talent can be found and promoted, because?] Our economic vitality is based on generating hits – finding special talents that enjoy strong commercial appeal. [And we should care about the hit-maker mentality, because?]

Link (Thanks, Ernest!)

EFF's Letter to the Senate on INDUCE


EFF's Letter to the Senate on INDUCE 07/30/2004 08:31 AM
Slashdot Jul 30 2004 12:19PM GMT

RIAA defends Induce act and is on the
offensive


RIAA defends Induce act and is on the
offensive
07/14/2004 05:17 AM

Techdirt has a great article about the ridiculous INDUCE Act that was penned by Senator Hatch. It seems that the RIAA under a lot of pressure as a lot of major players are against the ACT have sent all 100 senators a letter telling them how this law will not affect the Betamax decision.

Buzz on over to Techdirt for all the links great coverage [Techdirt]


RIAA Defends INDUCE Act; Explains Why
It's No Betamax


RIAA Defends INDUCE Act; Explains Why
It's No Betamax
07/14/2004 03:43 AM
It's not surprising that the RIAA would come out in defense of the INDUCE Act from Senator Hatch. They practically wrote the bill themselves. They had hoped to sneak it through without any debate, but a bunch of tech companies have stood up and pointed out how ridiculous this is. Meanwhile, plenty of others are showing what kinds of technology would be banned by the law. Realizing this might not sail through Congress as smoothly as they had hoped, the RIAA has now gone on the offensive. RIAA head Mitch Bainwol has sent a letter to all 100 Senators defending the bill, and saying that, contrary to the claims of others, it wouldn't overturn the famous Betamax decision (which allowed technologies that could be used for infringement, if they had substantial non-infringing purposes as well). Bainwol claims that "intentional inducement" is a much higher standard than was used in the Betamax ruling. However, as Ernest Miller points out in his INDUCE Act rebuttal, the only reason that's a higher standard is because there was no law against "inducing infringement" when the Betamax decision went to court.

GBP1.5 Billion Being Wasted On
Excessively Complex E-Government


GBP1.5 Billion Being Wasted On
Excessively Complex E-Government
06/09/2004 01:52 PM
ContactCenterWorld.com Jun 9 2004 4:05PM GMT

The Annotated Web


The Annotated Web 02/24/2003 11:42 PM
The Google acquisition of Pyra—makers of the most widely-used weblog platform, Blogger—left those unacquainted with weblogs scratching their heads. ...

an annotated Wiki


an annotated Wiki 06/21/2004 02:48 AM
FrontPage - drm

commonhouse.net/wiki/drm/FrontPage
track this site | 4 links


iPod, Annotated


iPod, Annotated 06/01/2004 09:55 PM
An itinerant inkster bites Apple in NOHO -- and the public bites back. By Laura Conaway, Village Voice (via MyAppleMenu)

The Annotated Universe


The Annotated Universe 12/10/2003 11:29 AM
An Atlas of the Universe. Sort of like Powers of Ten, but with lots of explanatory content.
via Signal + Noise

annotated, updated version


annotated, updated version 01/06/2005 02:24 AM
ricommentato

home.earthlink.net/~android606/commandline/index.htmltrack this site | 3 links


Annotated DRM talk on a Wiki


Annotated DRM talk on a Wiki 06/20/2004 09:36 AM
Quinn has posted my DRM talk to her Wiki with extensive annotation, and she's inviting more. How cool! Link

Flickr annotated photos


Flickr annotated photos 05/11/2004 01:43 PM
Flickr adds image annotation.

Flickr -- the fantastic social image-sharing Web app from Ludicorp -- has added image annotation; you can draw boxes around bits of the photos you post and mark up the contents of each box. When a viewer mouses over the box, a tooltip pops up with the annotation. Super cool.

Link

(vi a Kottke)

[unmediated]

Congrats to Stew and the crew over at Ludicorp!  I bet Greg Elin likes this!


The Annotated New York Times


The Annotated New York Times 04/05/2005 04:07 AM
what the blogospheres are saying about The Gray Lady .. The Annotated New York Times .. tracking

nytimes.blogrunner.com
track this site | 8 links


"The Annotated New York Times"


"The Annotated New York Times" 04/05/2005 09:50 PM

Annotated Gel Markup Language Project


Annotated Gel Markup Language Project 01/29/2004 03:02 PM
Research Article Published

"HOW-TO: Make your own annotated
multimedia Google map"


"HOW-TO: Make your own annotated
multimedia Google map"
03/14/2005 05:53 PM

Make your own annotated multimedia
Google map


Make your own annotated multimedia
Google map
04/10/2005 04:05 AM
If you liked the Craigslist/Google Maps combo, you'll be happy to hear that the boys and girls over at Engadget have a tutorial on how to make your own annotated multimedia Google map. Pretty sweet!

BlogBib - An Annotated Bibliography on
Webl0gs and Blogging


BlogBib - An Annotated Bibliography on
Webl0gs and Blogging
03/28/2005 08:11 AM
BlogBib - An Annotated Bibliography on Weblogs and Blogging
http://blog-bib.blogspot.com/

An Annotated Bibliography on Weblogs and Blogging, with a Focus on Library/Librarian Blogs...This annotated bibliography created by Susan Herzog, Information Literacy Librarian @ Eastern Connecticut State University includes definitions, articles about blogging and about library blogs, books, studies, links to samples of the myriad library blogs, tools for creating and using blogs, and links to presentations on blogging. This has been added to my Bots, Blogs and News Aggregators presentation.

turning narrative content into an
annotated timeline


turning narrative content into an
annotated timeline
12/02/2003 01:54 AM
A New Website for Harper's Magazine (Ftrain.com) .. Harpers.org was recently redesigned

ftrain.com/AWebSiteForHarpers.html
track this site | 8 links


Reader-annotated edition of Neal
Stephenson's "Command Line"


Reader-annotated edition of Neal
Stephenson's "Command Line"
01/05/2005 10:26 PM
Xeni Jardin: Boing Boing reader Alex says,
With Neal Stephenson's permission, this guy has annotated In the Beginning was the Command line and posted it online for everyone to see. I think this is a great example of how works can evolve and be improved upon. Unfortunately, In the Command Line has not been 'set free', but it's great that the author was able and willing to give permission for this development.
Li nk

Another Alt.Induce.Act


Another Alt.Induce.Act 08/06/2004 06:18 PM
Here's another alternative to the Induce Act, and there are others out there....

Induce No More


Induce No More 08/09/2004 09:08 AM
I have tremendous respect for the scholarship of Professor Larry Lessig, and I am honored to be asked to host his blog this week. I hope that over the coming 5 days, we will have a series of thought-provoking conversations. Your views and suggestions will be helpful to me as...

PK on the INDUCE Act


PK on the INDUCE Act 06/24/2004 09:59 AM
Nicely put.

Siva on INDUCE


Siva on INDUCE 07/24/2004 04:16 PM
Siva's got a great piec e in Salon on the INDUCE Act. Just remember, he was a guest blogger here first.

Induce Act Refuses to Die


Induce Act Refuses to Die 09/14/2004 11:00 AM
Last month, insiders in Washington felt the Induce Act, which would outlaw technology that could contribute to copyright infringement, was history. According to music activist organization Downhill Battle, a year-old organization dedicated to bringing balance to a debate often dominated by the RIAA and large music labels, this is no longer the case. "We were told by people on (Capital) Hill that it is less likely that the bill will come to the floor by itself and have a nice debate and vote," says Nicholas Reville, Downhill Battle Co-Founder. "More likely the Induce Act is going to be snuck through a back door in legislative procedure. The only supporters in any industry or interest group are in Hollywood. From their perspective (the Induce Act) is not going to happen if it gets full airing."

Stop the INDUCE Act


Stop the INDUCE Act 09/12/2004 03:26 AM
Save Betamax .. Sign up

savebetamax.org
track this site | 3 links


Other News: "Induce" Act


Other News: "Induce" Act 07/22/2004 09:39 AM
A copyright control bill gathers steam, and it's radical enough to kill the iPod, critics say.

Other News: INDUCE Act


Other News: INDUCE Act 06/29/2004 10:41 AM
This copyright crackdown bill looks vague and nasty....

INDUCE to vomit


INDUCE to vomit 06/25/2004 03:39 PM
Senator Orrin Hatch introduced the INDUCE bill earlier this week with broad, vague limits on who could be sued for copyright infringement. No longer limited to just companies producing programs or those hosting programs, this bill intends to criminalize anyone that aids in copyright infringement. The EFF have produced a mock complaint against Apple for the iPod, since it can play illegally obtained mp3s just as easily as legally purchased ones. Ernest Miller has broken down Hatch's entire "for the children" speech that introduced the bill, in excruciating detail. Those who own mp3 players, TiVos, and other sorts of disruptive technologies should watch this one closely, it could get really ugly.

Fasttracking Induce


Fasttracking Induce 08/20/2004 06:23 PM
So will MGM v. Grokster fasttrack the Induce Act, as many (here Seth F.) think? Hard to say, but there are some reasons, both from theory and history, to think that it won't. First, the Grokster decision, by creating a Circuit split, actually creates legal uncertainty that may slow down...

The Innovator's Induce Act


The Innovator's Induce Act 08/06/2004 02:46 AM
So what would an Induce Act look like that actually balanced the interests of copyright owner and technological innovators? Here's what: the "Inducing Innovation Act." Commentary below, comments and suggestions very welcome, and thanks to those who helped with this....

INDUCE vomiting


INDUCE vomiting 06/23/2004 01:53 PM
Orrin Hatch thinks of the children. As a convenient lever for shutting down P2P networks.

Musicians on the INDUCE act


Musicians on the INDUCE act 08/06/2004 01:14 PM

There's a bill currently being debated in the US Senate, called the INDUCE act (here's a good background on it), that aims to criminalize P2P networks, programmers, software compnaies, and anyone else that can be shown to help "induce copyright infringement."

There are a lot of problems with the act's broad language, but the Future of Music Coalition surveyed musicians to get their opinions on the target of the act, P2P networks. The final product of the survey is a letter to the senate committee debating the bill. The key points are illuminating and worth restating here: artists don't feature in discussions of the bill (just large music labels and technology companies), the bill assumes all copyright owners do not want their works shared on P2P networks (35% of musicians they surveyed saw value in P2P sharing for them), and the bill doesn't allow market-based (like licensing) solutions to occur. Former Creative Commons featured commoner Scott Andrew highlights the survey, the letter, and his problems with the bill in this post.


Will The INDUCE act change the iPod?


Will The INDUCE act change the iPod? 08/10/2004 09:07 AM

Hatch's Induce Act comes under fire


Hatch's Induce Act comes under fire 07/06/2004 09:59 AM
Congressman Boucher weighs in, guns blazing

Tuesday is INDUCE call-in day


Tuesday is INDUCE call-in day 09/14/2004 03:48 AM
Xeni Jardin: As my colleague Cory blogged last week, Tuesday September 14 is "Save Betamax National Call-in Day."
Why Save Betamax? The short version: We're organizing a call-in day to Congress on September 14 to oppose new legislation that would undermine the Betamax decision (INDUCE Act). Here's why: The Betamax VCR died more than 15 years ago, but the Supreme Court decision that made the Betamax and all other VCRs legal lived on. In Sony vs. Universal (known as the Betamax decision) the Court ruled that because VCRs have legitimate uses, the technology is legal—even if some people use it to copy movies. Of course, the movie industry was lucky it lost the case against VCRs, because home video soon became Hollywood's largest source of revenue. And the freedom to use and develop new technology that was protected by the Betamax decision set the stage for the incredible growth in computer technology we've seen in the last few decades.
Link
Grok Description matches for The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act
GrokA matches for The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act

The Excessively Annotated RIAA Letter On The INDUCE Act

The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















Also check out:


Grok

Ipod Porn on the
Rise

Brief Abstract of
Wikipedia's
Mesothelioma Cancer
page

Get first aid
instructions in your
cell phone

IE is crap
JSPWiki gains
podcasting support

Boomerang
Entrepreneurship:
How To Sell The Same
Startup Twice

Service Tax: Tech
Institutes Finally
In

Kupchak: Re-Signing
Bryant Not Sure
Thing (AP)

Slim-Fast Dumps
Goldberg Over Bush
Jabs (AP)

Ditka Says He Won't
Run for U.S. Senate
(AP)

Report Cites U.K.
Iraq Intelligence
Flaws (AP)

Baghdad Bomber Kills
10; Governor Slain
(AP)

Senate Scuttles Gay
Marriage Amendment
(AP)

National network to
fight bullies

Hostage's company to
leave Iraq

Football: Crespo
flies to Milan

Golf: Open set for
showdown

Apple profit surges
on iPod sales

Shipman drug storage
report due

Rail system shake-up
expected

Veritas buys
automation software
vendor Invio

Microsoft boosts
investment in
Business Solutions

hellbot 1.0.9
wmforkplop 0.9.1
MultiLingual Text
Editor 1

HTML Forms
generation and
validation
2004.07.14

closedShop - Open
Source Shopping 1.8

SRR Module 1.4.16
CIFS VFS 1.20c
(Development - 2.4)

xMule 1.8.4
ivtools 1.2.1
NetSQUID 1.3
(Stable)

Six Apart is Growing
2004-07-15T01:07:42
Police Chief Cracks
Down on Tattoos (AP)

mstor
Smarty-Light
Perl Web Application
Developer/Programmer
for epay application

Veritas Acquires
Invio for $35
Million

AutoZone Wins Brief
Stay in SCO
Copyright Case

New HOBO Henry
Science Kit
available for Mac OS
X

ChronoSync beefs up
performance,
features

Envision Web viewing
tool now available

Quark refocuses,
gets more
collaborative

Webshots co-founder
hits jackpot with
sale to CNET

Briefly: D-Link
debuts media player
with AOL radio

MacShogi 0.2.22
GraphPad Statmate
2.0

Cosmic Encounter
Online 1.0

my name is no
biscuits

Calendar ante upped.
Exclusive
ShopStarWars Figure
Revealed

Apple Computer's
Profit Triples
(Reuters)

Oracle Reaffirms
Financial Targets
(Reuters)

New Chips Could Put
Wi-Fi in Flight (PC
World)

what is grok?