stargeek
PHP news website logo.
home    PHP scripts    articles    seo tools    links    search    contact    shop    realtors


Does Google help governments censor results?







Does Google help governments censor
results?

Does Google help governments censor
results?
04/30/2004 02:12 AM

Wired Magazine, January 2003
Brin was no expert on international diplomacy. So he ordered a half-dozen books about Chinese history, business, and politics on Amazon.com and splurged on overnight shipping. He consulted with Schmidt, Page, and David Drummond, Google's general counsel and head of business development, then put in a call to tech industry doyenne Esther Dyson for advice and contacts. Google has no offices in China, so Brin enlisted go-betweens to get the message to Chinese authorities that Google would be very interested in working out a compromise to restore access. "We didn't want to do anything rash," Brin says. "The situation over there is more complex than I had imagined."

Four days later, Chinese authorities restored access to the site. How did that happen? For starters, the Chinese government was deluged with outcries from the nation's 46 million Internet users when access to Google was cut off. "Internet users in China are an apolitical crowd," says Xiao Qiang, executive director of New York-based Human Rights In China. "They tend to be people who are doing well, and they don't usually voice strong views. But this stepped into their digital freedom."

The quick workaround: Chinese authorities tweaked the national firewall, making the new Google China different from the site that was turned off. Today, Chinese who use Google to search on terms like "falun gong" or "human rights in china" receive a standard-looking results page. But when they click on any of the results, either their browsers are redirected to a blank or government-approved page, or their computers are blocked from accessing Google for an hour or two. "They have a new mechanism that can block the results of certain searches," Brin says. Did Google help China find or obtain the filtering technology? "We didn't make changes to our servers" is all he'll say.

via google-watch.org

S eth Finkelstein describes how Google self-censorship works. Also, Jonathan Zittrain and Benjamin Edelman of the Berkman Center for Internet & Society, Harvard Law School have a paper on Localized Google search result exclusions which is quite interesting.

I can understand from a business perspective why Google would do this, but whenever I bring this up with people they deny it or can't believe it.

Does anyone else have any more information on this?

PS This has nothing to do with trying to hurt Google or their IPO. I've been trying to figure this out for the last few weeks and have reached a dead end in my research so I'm trying to understand more. How companies like this work with governments and how this information is then disclosed is very important.




This is a GrokNews Entry: (what is grok?)





Similar Items

Does Google help governments censor results?

Grok Headline matches for Does Google help governments censor results?

ICANN Doesn't Censor, Governments Do


ICANN Doesn't Censor, Governments Do 06/05/2005 11:44 PM
Corante Jun 4 2005 3:00PM GMT

Should Google Censor Sites?


Should Google Censor Sites? 04/15/2004 12:58 PM
About Web Search Apr 15 2004 5:26PM GMT

What Does Google Censor on AdWords?


What Does Google Censor on AdWords? 08/09/2004 12:58 PM
Search Engine Lowdown Aug 9 2004 5:22PM GMT

Is Google Helping China Censor the Net?


Is Google Helping China Censor the Net? 09/22/2004 01:49 PM
  • New Scientist: Google omits controversial news stories in China. Some users recently reported that Google's Chinese news search returned different results depending when they searched using a computer based outside of China. The claims were substantiated by researchers who connected to computers inside the country.
  • Very disturbing if true, but not all that surprising. The tech industry, after all, has happily been supplying China with technology that helps keep the Great Firewall up and running. Networking giant Cisco, for example, is just one of the many suppliers in this system. The Net will be zoned, it seems. See also the comments on this story on Slashdot.

    Does Google Censor Chinese News?


    Does Google Censor Chinese News? 09/22/2004 04:43 AM

    Over 2 Million Results on Google for
    Google Stock News


    Over 2 Million Results on Google for
    Google Stock News
    06/22/2004 02:47 AM
    Google Stock and Google IPO is a very high profile issue in both the finance and online world. There are millions of information pages about Google Stock with no real answers to key questions. A new site, Google-Stock (www.google-stock.net), launched today a free service to bring the hot headlines on Google to your own inbox, saving time searching through millions of results. [PRWEB Jun 22, 2004]

    Google works in Google Glossary to
    Results


    Google works in Google Glossary to
    Results
    07/15/2004 05:27 PM
    Google starts to display actual content in SERPs.

    It's 5:00. Do you know what your Google
    results are?


    It's 5:00. Do you know what your Google
    results are?
    02/03/2003 06:21 PM
    Boston Globe: A Nation of Voyuers, How the Internet search engine Google is changing what we can find out about one another - and raising questions about whether we should. "Google changed our concept of time as well. It has helped make our past - or oddly refracted shards of it - present and permanent. That's a radical notion for a medium usually defined by its ability to constantly update itself." "It's the collapse of inconvenience," says Siva Vaidhyanathan, assistant professor of culture and communication at New York University. "It turns out inconvenience was a really important part of our lives, and we didn't realize it."...

    Odd Google Results


    Odd Google Results 12/23/2002 07:53 AM
    Odd Google Results Here's an odd Google result for "Joel's Currency Converter" [_Go_] Now don't get me wrong -- I understand why it came up. Still I wonder about this result when what I really wanted was this. But I can't bitch much at all -- the result I was expecting was right on top. I'm more just observing.

    Google Results via RSS


    Google Results via RSS 08/27/2004 01:51 PM

    Rajiv is beta testing Google.RSS, a service which uses the Google API to return search results as an RSS feed.


    Better Search Results Than Google?


    Better Search Results Than Google? 01/05/2004 04:11 PM
    Mechanik writes "CNN has an AP article about the next generation of up and coming search tools, which try to cope with the glut of hits that result from ...

    Results of Google IPO May Be Muted


    Results of Google IPO May Be Muted 05/10/2004 01:26 AM
    Los Angeles Times May 10 2004 5:48AM GMT

    Red Alert: Google Results on AOL - Now


    Red Alert: Google Results on AOL - Now 07/23/2002 11:00 AM
    Search AOL now staring results by Google. Appears to be a beta site.

    Seeing Two Sets of Google Results


    Seeing Two Sets of Google Results 03/22/2005 03:46 PM
    (subscription required): Members are seeing two distinct sets of Google results. Possibly a prelude to an update.

    Get Just Google Adwords Results


    Get Just Google Adwords Results 12/27/2004 11:26 PM
    Wondering what ads Google has for a particular keyword? Do your search at http://www.google.com/sponsoredlinks. You'll get JUST sponsored results. For interesting search results, try a keyword that's heavily in the...

    Better search results than Google?


    Better search results than Google? 01/05/2004 12:19 PM
    CNN Jan 5 2004 10:58AM ET

    Google Results on iWon


    Google Results on iWon 08/05/2002 10:45 PM
    First AOL, now Iwon.

    Use Google the Wrong Way to get the
    Right Results


    Use Google the Wrong Way to get the
    Right Results
    09/13/2004 04:17 PM
    Source: Search Engine Lowdown - How do you search for something on the web that search engines cache, but they won’t let you search for? I recently found myself with just such a dilemma....

    Google Ad Links Results


    Google Ad Links Results 03/22/2005 03:46 PM
    "I am finding that in the case of Ad Links, that if a surfer clicks on the Ad Link in the ad unit, nearly *all* click through to at least one of the sponsored listings on the second page."

    Visualizing Google Search Results


    Visualizing Google Search Results 08/30/2004 01:46 PM
    Source: SearchDay - MoreGoogle is a simple utility that enhances Google result pages with thumbnail images and other useful links....

    Compare Yahoo and Google Results


    Compare Yahoo and Google Results 04/14/2005 10:20 AM
    Wondering EXACTLY what the difference is between Yahoo and Google's results? Well, I can't help you there but I can give you a pointer. The pointer's to Yahgoohoogle, a site...

    Google: An explanation of our search
    results


    Google: An explanation of our search
    results
    04/15/2004 03:47 AM
    An explanation of our search results .. Google has officially responded .. Please read our note here .. ad

    google.com/explanation.html
    track this site | 6 links


    Google Speeds Up Results for Firefox


    Google Speeds Up Results for Firefox 03/31/2005 11:49 AM
    Software engineer Reza Behforooz announced Wednesday on the Google Blog that the company has added "prefetching" to some searches, which instructs the Web browser to automatically start downloading the top result. The feature is only available in Mozilla and Firefox, and can be optionally disabled.

    Gaga for Google? When results don't
    count


    Gaga for Google? When results don't
    count
    07/22/2002 05:40 AM
    Why what you get from Google is not always the whole story. We come to expect so much from Google that we forget how much there is that it doesn't track. But like the author, I'm amazed to see so many people who "don't exist" on the web.

    Google to post quarterly results


    Google to post quarterly results 07/20/2004 09:13 AM
    Source: News.com - Google is expected to give an indication of how much it expects bidders to pay for its shares in an updated initial public offering filing as soon as this week, according to potential investors....

    AdWords No Different from Stock Google
    Results


    AdWords No Different from Stock Google
    Results
    04/09/2004 04:06 PM
    AdWords are now displayed in same color as standard results. The thin line between Google search results and paid search results is now -- literally -- a visual thin line.

    Change in The Way Google Serves Results
    on .co.uk


    Change in The Way Google Serves Results
    on .co.uk
    03/14/2005 05:15 PM
    "USA sites are dropped down the rankings and UK sites are bumped to the top."

    Yahoo Results Getting More Similar to
    Google


    Yahoo Results Getting More Similar to
    Google
    05/18/2004 06:18 PM
    Search Engine Journal-46 minutes ago ... have been tracking overlaps for popular queries for several months and found a general increase in overlapping search results between Yahoo and Google. ...

    Getcher Google Results With Thumbnails


    Getcher Google Results With Thumbnails 08/18/2004 10:18 AM
    I have mentioned more and more in the last few months search engines which offer small screen shots of pages (thumbnails) with search results. While these are certainly nothing new...

    Google News Watch results


    Google News Watch results 11/04/2003 08:21 PM
    Google News is a robot-generated news page at the popular Google web search engine. Just over a year ago www.newsknife.com launched ...

    Google Explains Jew Watch Search Results


    Google Explains Jew Watch Search Results 05/12/2004 11:09 PM
    Search Engine Journal May 13 2004 3:18AM GMT

    Yahoo set to drop Google search results


    Yahoo set to drop Google search results 01/06/2004 10:29 AM
    Search Engine Lowdown Jan 6 2004 9:11AM ET

    Engineering Google Results to Make a
    Point


    Engineering Google Results to Make a
    Point
    01/22/2004 05:07 PM
    New York Times Jan 22 2004 8:49PM GMT

    Visual Comparison of Google, Yahoo
    Results


    Visual Comparison of Google, Yahoo
    Results
    06/17/2005 07:21 PM
    I find visual comparisons annoying. I'm a text-crawler. But this one I find less annoying than most. While this site is one that uses Flash to show search results, it's...

    Google Says It Doesn't Plan To Change
    Search Results


    Google Says It Doesn't Plan To Change
    Search Results
    04/12/2004 11:30 PM
    Google has no plans to alter its search results despite complaints that the first listing on a search for the word "Jew" directs people to an anti-Semitic Web site.

    Big Bug: Google Blocks All Results When
    Blocking Spam


    Big Bug: Google Blocks All Results When
    Blocking Spam
    10/28/2003 11:08 PM
    Seth Finkelstein has made a startling discovery, backed with lots of evidence: when a spam result comes up in a search, Google not only blocks the spam, but every result after it. This means that for searches where spam results manage to rise to the top, very few -- sometimes zero -- results will be returned. Examples: motorcycle candle, keyboard bracelet. These are common words for which you'd expect to see results (in fact, the latter even says there are thousands of results) but the bug prevents them from being seen. Eliminating the spam pages (by blocking a word, antenna, that appears on them) allows full results to be displayed. It's pretty amazing that such a serious bug made it past Google's tests. It will be interesting to see how quickly it's fixed....

    The Business Of Making Your Google
    Results Worse


    The Business Of Making Your Google
    Results Worse
    08/06/2004 06:45 PM
    While it's well known that there are plenty of folks working on ways to boost rankings in Google, it turns out that the opposite is true as well. First, there's the sort of confidential information that accidentally gets revealed online, which people don't want Google to have. Usually that can be quickly removed from the index by letting Google know. However, others want to make sure that bad or embarrassing things aren't the top results. The article even notes that one PR firm has a full-time search engine optimizer whose main job is to make sure bad stories about clients get pushed down in the rankings.

    Google Fights Lawsuit Over Search
    Results


    Google Fights Lawsuit Over Search
    Results
    01/14/2003 12:26 PM
    In a case that underscores the increasing importance search rankings have on business, Google Technologies is fighting to dismiss a lawsuit claiming that it ...

    G-Metrics Measures Google Results Across
    Time


    G-Metrics Measures Google Results Across
    Time
    08/10/2004 07:01 AM
    You might be interested in the popularity of keywords in Google for a variety of reasons -- you might be doing research on a technology, or you might be trying...
    Grok Description matches for Does Google help governments censor results?
    GrokA matches for Does Google help governments censor results?

    Does Google help governments censor results?

    The following phrases have been identified by the grok system as matching this entry:

















    Also check out:


    Grok

    Ipod Porn on the
    Rise

    Brief Abstract of
    Wikipedia's
    Mesothelioma Cancer
    page

    Get first aid
    instructions in your
    cell phone

    IE is crap
    JSPWiki gains
    podcasting support

    Jiiva announces
    SuperScrubber 1.5 in
    three editions

    Steampunk/dead media
    photoshopping
    contest

    Free mall WiFi on
    the rise

    Using a game to
    describe all the
    images on the net

    LA hacker-con
    early-bird is open

    Mitsubishi seeks new
    rescue plan

    House prices 'soar'
    across Wales

    Teenager Kriss laid
    to rest

    Worker beaten with
    golf club

    Italy passes
    disputed media law

    EU asylum seekers to
    lose homes

    iTunes 4.5 And DRM
    verisimilitude:
    Dictionary.com Word
    of the Day

    JTestCase
    Government Launches
    Comparison Shopping
    Site For Drugs

    EPIC Grandstanding,
    Makes Up Google-FBI
    Link

    Thoughts On The
    Google IPO Filing

    U.S. Marines Pull
    Back from Some
    Falluja Positions
    (Reuters)

    Condor 6.7.0
    ZAP Multiplayer
    1.1.2

    ArtDesignFilter
    Emulator Images for
    Windows Mobile
    2003-based Pocket PC
    Development

    Emulator Images for
    Windows Mobile
    2003-based
    Smartphone
    Development

    Company's decision
    to sell shares in
    auction a break with
    IPO tradition

    Google registers
    eagerly awaited IPO

    Gateway to eliminate
    another 1,500 jobs

    Google files $2.7B
    IPO -- and you can
    play

    Google plans $2.7bn
    share sale

    Google to sell its
    Shares

    The goods on Google
    Google founders
    break new ground

    Allen: 'We Drank
    Some Castor Oil'

    The $12 Billion
    Education of Paul
    Allen

    Bush's Double Vision
    on Privacy

    Tech Jobs Are
    Sprouting Again

    At the Track, a
    Technology with Legs

    Democracy and
    Control in Google's
    IPO

    Google This: Reality
    Check

    Ericsson to expand
    Austrian 3G network

    4ppl3 s4uc3
    It was "King of
    Queens."

    Memos show Gorelick
    involvement in
    'wall' - The
    Washington Times:
    Nation/Politics -
    April 29, 2004

    American Digest:
    Small Moves, the
    Spirit of America,
    and Doing What You
    Can

    Claims vs. Facts
    Database - Center
    for American
    Progress

    Defense Department
    official for
    altering a contract
    to benefit
    mobile-phone group

    Savaged Nokia crops
    prices

    Visto expands sync
    suit

    IBM vows to assault
    users with
    virtualization
    technology

    MS Office vastly
    overpriced, says UK
    consumer outfit

    IBM and Cisco feel
    the networking love

    what is grok?